Research Methods I - Projective Tests & IQ Measurement

Projective Tests

Introduction

  • Projective tests aim to reveal an individual's psychological characteristics by interpreting their responses to ambiguous stimuli.

  • The interpretation of these stimuli, such as inkblots or vague stories, is believed to reflect the individual's personality components.

  • The individual projects aspects of themselves when interpreting the ambiguous stimuli.

  • Examples include the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT) and the Rorschach test.

The Thematic Apperception Test (TAT)

  • Developed by H. Murray and C. Morgan at the Harvard Psychological Clinic, published in 1938.

  • Aims to reveal dominant drives, emotions, sentiments, complexes, and conflicts of personality. It is especially useful for exposing underlying inhibited tendencies.

  • Popularity: By 1971, over 1800 articles and several books were written based on the TAT.

  • Usage: Was the 6th most commonly used test by clinical psychologists (Camera et al., 2000).

  • Consists of 20 cards each with ambiguous stimuli for 4 groups (males, females, boys, girls).

  • Focus is on the interaction between individuals and their environment.

TAT Procedure
  • The examinee interprets the picture and creates a plausible story that includes:

    • What occurs in the picture.

    • Thoughts/feelings of the depicted characters.

    • Events leading up to the situation.

    • Outcome (what happens after the depicted event).

What the TAT Reveals
  • Can reveal conflicts between personal wishes and external demands.

  • May show whether parents are supportive or dominant.

  • The TAT can be valuable because it:

    • Reveals the examinee's inner drives.

    • Elicits information that might not be easily communicated otherwise.

    • Makes internal states (ego-distant) easier to access by interpreting a picture, thereby projecting their inner drives of behavior.

Administration of TAT
  • General aspects procedure include:

    • Time between stimulus and start of story-telling.

    • Complete recording of the response.

    • Questioning/inquiry.

    • Presentation sequence.

  • Exact administration is variable (Gieser & Stein, 1999).

    • Number of cards presented.

    • Sequence of presentation.

    • Types of cards provided.

What the TAT Reveals About Family Relations
  • Autonomy vs. conformity.

  • Parent-child relations.

Scoring of TAT
  • Normative standards are lacking.

  • Scores are frequently interpreted based on intuition and clinical experience.

  • Standardized scoring system developed by D. Weston (1995), but not widely implemented.

Rorschach Test

  • Rorschach test published in 1921 in Psychodiagnostik (1921/1941).

  • Goal: to assess characteristic responses in specific populations to differentiate between them.

  • Later used to assess personality components.

Administration of Rorschach Test
  • Administration should be standardized:

    • Introduction to the technique to reduce anxiety.

    • Providing the test instruction.

    • The response phase.

    • Inquiry.

Scoring of Rorschach Test
  • Coding of the different categories, i.e.:

    • Location: Refers to the area of the inkblot.

    • Determinants: Style/characteristic of the blot (shape, color, texture).

    • Content: Type/quantity.

    • Structural summary.

    • Interpretation.

Reliability and Validity of Projective Tests
  • Interrater reliability:

    • Can be relatively high ( r > .8 ).

  • Test-retest reliability:

    • Mean reliability around .66.66 (Meyer et al., 2001).

  • Validity coefficients:

    • Approx. .30.30 (Hunsley et al., 2001), but variable.

Measuring IQ

What is IQ?
  • IQ stands for Intelligence Quotient.

  • Tools used to measure IQ include:

    • WAIS (Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale).

    • WISC (Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children).

Development and Scales of the WAIS
  • Verbal Comprehension

  • Perceptual Reasoning

    • Visual reasoning and visuospatial integration performance, visuomotor performance, etc.

  • Working Memory

  • Processing Speed

IQ Ranges and Classifications (WAIS-III/WISC-III)
  • Higher extreme above average: 130+

  • Well above average: 120-129

  • High average: 110-119

  • Average: 90-109

  • Low average: 80-89

  • Well below average: 70-79

  • Lower extreme: 69 and below

Percentage of cases under portions of the normal curve
  • Standard deviations from the mean (0) are shown with corresponding percentages of cases under the curve.

  • Cumulative percentages are also provided.

  • Percentile equivalents are given, along with corresponding Stanford-Binet and Wechsler IQs.

  • Wechsler subtest scores, z scores, T scores, stanines, and percent in stanine are also displayed on the normal distribution curve.

Assessment and Reporting of IQ

  • Advantages and disadvantages were briefly mentioned.