Research Methods I - Projective Tests & IQ Measurement
Projective Tests
Introduction
Projective tests aim to reveal an individual's psychological characteristics by interpreting their responses to ambiguous stimuli.
The interpretation of these stimuli, such as inkblots or vague stories, is believed to reflect the individual's personality components.
The individual projects aspects of themselves when interpreting the ambiguous stimuli.
Examples include the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT) and the Rorschach test.
The Thematic Apperception Test (TAT)
Developed by H. Murray and C. Morgan at the Harvard Psychological Clinic, published in 1938.
Aims to reveal dominant drives, emotions, sentiments, complexes, and conflicts of personality. It is especially useful for exposing underlying inhibited tendencies.
Popularity: By 1971, over 1800 articles and several books were written based on the TAT.
Usage: Was the 6th most commonly used test by clinical psychologists (Camera et al., 2000).
Consists of 20 cards each with ambiguous stimuli for 4 groups (males, females, boys, girls).
Focus is on the interaction between individuals and their environment.
TAT Procedure
The examinee interprets the picture and creates a plausible story that includes:
What occurs in the picture.
Thoughts/feelings of the depicted characters.
Events leading up to the situation.
Outcome (what happens after the depicted event).
What the TAT Reveals
Can reveal conflicts between personal wishes and external demands.
May show whether parents are supportive or dominant.
The TAT can be valuable because it:
Reveals the examinee's inner drives.
Elicits information that might not be easily communicated otherwise.
Makes internal states (ego-distant) easier to access by interpreting a picture, thereby projecting their inner drives of behavior.
Administration of TAT
General aspects procedure include:
Time between stimulus and start of story-telling.
Complete recording of the response.
Questioning/inquiry.
Presentation sequence.
Exact administration is variable (Gieser & Stein, 1999).
Number of cards presented.
Sequence of presentation.
Types of cards provided.
What the TAT Reveals About Family Relations
Autonomy vs. conformity.
Parent-child relations.
Scoring of TAT
Normative standards are lacking.
Scores are frequently interpreted based on intuition and clinical experience.
Standardized scoring system developed by D. Weston (1995), but not widely implemented.
Rorschach Test
Rorschach test published in 1921 in Psychodiagnostik (1921/1941).
Goal: to assess characteristic responses in specific populations to differentiate between them.
Later used to assess personality components.
Administration of Rorschach Test
Administration should be standardized:
Introduction to the technique to reduce anxiety.
Providing the test instruction.
The response phase.
Inquiry.
Scoring of Rorschach Test
Coding of the different categories, i.e.:
Location: Refers to the area of the inkblot.
Determinants: Style/characteristic of the blot (shape, color, texture).
Content: Type/quantity.
Structural summary.
Interpretation.
Reliability and Validity of Projective Tests
Interrater reliability:
Can be relatively high ( r > .8 ).
Test-retest reliability:
Mean reliability around (Meyer et al., 2001).
Validity coefficients:
Approx. (Hunsley et al., 2001), but variable.
Measuring IQ
What is IQ?
IQ stands for Intelligence Quotient.
Tools used to measure IQ include:
WAIS (Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale).
WISC (Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children).
Development and Scales of the WAIS
Verbal Comprehension
Perceptual Reasoning
Visual reasoning and visuospatial integration performance, visuomotor performance, etc.
Working Memory
Processing Speed
IQ Ranges and Classifications (WAIS-III/WISC-III)
Higher extreme above average: 130+
Well above average: 120-129
High average: 110-119
Average: 90-109
Low average: 80-89
Well below average: 70-79
Lower extreme: 69 and below
Percentage of cases under portions of the normal curve
Standard deviations from the mean (0) are shown with corresponding percentages of cases under the curve.
Cumulative percentages are also provided.
Percentile equivalents are given, along with corresponding Stanford-Binet and Wechsler IQs.
Wechsler subtest scores, z scores, T scores, stanines, and percent in stanine are also displayed on the normal distribution curve.
Assessment and Reporting of IQ
Advantages and disadvantages were briefly mentioned.