Study Notes on Law, Morality, and Sexual Orientation
Foundation of Legal Regulation and the Standard Modern Position
Legal Context and Origin of the Framework:
- The framework originates from an affidavit of evidence prepared in for the Colorado Amendment court case, Evans v. Romer, subsequently published in a fuller version in , and compiled in the volume Same Sex: Debating the Ethics, Science, and Culture of Homosexuality (edited by J. Corvino, Rowman & Littlefield, pp. ).
- Natural law ethics provides the underlying rational framework for analyzing legal regulation, sexual morality, and public policy regarding sexual orientation.
The Two Limbs of the Standard Modern Position:
- Since the mid-, a distinct standard form of legal regulation regarding sexual conduct has emerged across modern legal systems. This standard modern position is defined by two complementary limbs:
- First Limb (Private Realm Limits): The state lacks legal authorization to, and does not, make it a punishable criminal offense for consenting adult persons to engage in private, consensual, sexually immoral acts (such as private homosexual conduct).
- Second Limb (Public Realm Authority): The state retains legitimate legal authority to discourage homosexual conduct and homosexual orientation, specifically when overtly manifested as an active public willingness to engage in homosexual acts or adopt a public lifestyle endorsing such conduct.
- Since the mid-, a distinct standard form of legal regulation regarding sexual conduct has emerged across modern legal systems. This standard modern position is defined by two complementary limbs:
Exceptions and Boundaries of Legal Supervision:
- Supervision of truly private consensual adult conduct is properly excluded from the state's normal jurisdiction, subject to narrow exceptions:
- Acts involving sado-masochistic bodily damage remain subject to legal restriction regardless of private consent.
- State intervention in cases such as assisting in suicide represents an apparent, rather than real, exception to private autonomy rules.
- Supervision of the public realm and moral-cultural-educational environment is maintained as a vital justification for the state's legitimate claim to the loyalty of its citizens.
- Supervision of truly private consensual adult conduct is properly excluded from the state's normal jurisdiction, subject to narrow exceptions:
State Justifications for Supervising the Public Environment:
- The public realm is the precise environment in which young people of all sexual inclinations are educated and formed.
- It constitutes the structural context that directly assists or hinders parents, educators, and guardians in helping young people avoid destructive forms of life.
- It forms the cultural milieu that either encourages citizens in their internal aspirations toward integrated good character, autonomy, and self-control, or discourages and undermines them by luring them into becoming slaves to impulse and sensual gratification.
Conceptual Ambiguities and Legal Definitions of Sexual Orientation:
- The terms "homosexual activity," "homosexual acts," and "homosexual conduct" are used synonymously to designate bodily acts performed on a person of the same sex executed to secure orgasmic sexual satisfaction for one or more participants.
- The standard modern position identifies a critical ambiguity in the phrase "sexual orientation," which gay rights movements equivocally collapse into two distinct meanings:
- Meaning : A psychological or psychosomatic disposition inwardly orienting an individual toward homosexual activity.
- Meaning : A deliberate decision to orient one's public behavior to express, manifest, or endorse active interest in homosexual conduct or social institutions presumptively involving such conduct.
- The standard modern position treats discrimination based solely on Meaning —a person's internal psychological disposition or another's belief regarding that disposition—as unjust.
- Conversely, laws prohibiting "discrimination based on sexual orientation" as promoted by gay rights movements extend full legal protection to public acts designed to promote, procure, and facilitate homosexual conduct (Meaning ).
- Enacting such broad anti-discrimination laws creates significant legal injustice and structural harm against families, associations, and social institutions that organize themselves around traditional ideals of conjugal family life.
Philosophical Foundations of Marriage and Moral Critique of Homosexual Conduct
Ancient Philosophical Consensus:
- The critical moral judgment that homosexual conduct is wrong does not stem from irrational hostility, theological dogma, sectarian belief, or social prejudice, but from publicly intelligible, reflective, rational considerations.
- The major figures of classical Greek philosophy—Socrates, Plato, and Aristotle—unanimously rejected homosexual conduct as intrinsically immoral, repudiating the core premises of gay ideology.
- The Platonic-Aristotelian critique relies on three fundamental theses:
- Thesis : The open-ended, exclusive sexual commitment of a man and a woman in the union of marriage is intrinsically good and reasonable, excluding all extra-marital sexual relations.
- Thesis : Homosexual acts are radically and uniquely non-marital, rendering them intrinsically unreasonable and unnatural.
- Thesis : As emphasized by Plato (and implicit in Aristotle), homosexual acts share a foundational moral equivalence with solitary masturbation, both being radically non-marital and unworthy of human dignity.
The Biological and Personal Reality of Marital Union:
- Human biological reality is an integral component of personal reality, not a mere external instrument used by a conscious self.
- In heterosexual intercourse of the reproductive kind, the union of the reproductive organs of husband and wife biologically unites them with respect to the single function of reproduction.
- In respect of the procreative function, the spouses become a single biological and personal reality: "two in one flesh."
- This biological union allows spouses to actualize and experience their real common good, irrespective of whether a specific act results in conception or whether the spouses are temporarily or permanently sterile.
- The intelligible common good of marriage comprises two unified aspects forming its wholeness: parenthood and friendship.
Non-Marital Acts, Instrumentality, and Personal Dis-integration:
- The common good of non-marital friends (e.g., man and man, woman and woman, man and boy) cannot encompass shared procreation or biological unity.
- Because same-sex or non-marital partners cannot unite their reproductive organs to form a biological unit, their sexual acts cannot actualize a real common good.
- Lacking a actualizable common good, non-marital sexual acts collapse into acts of individual self-gratification.
- In non-marital sexual acts, partners reduce their bodies to mere instruments used in the service of their consciously experiencing selves.
- This instrumentalization results in personal dis-integration, severing the acting person's conscious self from their bodily reality.
Platonic Critique of Hedonism and Sexual Worthlessness:
- Reality is apprehended through rational judgment, not subjective emotion or generous internal intentions.
- In Plato's Gorgias (), the philosophical critique of hedonism establishes that sexual acts lack unitive moral value unless they actualize the comprehensive biological, affective, and volitional unity of marriage.
- There is no essential difference in moral worthlessness between:
- Solitary masturbation.
- Being sodomized as a prostitute for monetary exchange.
- Being sodomized purely for sensual pleasure.
- Masturbating for gratification and fantasy following a shift on an assembly line.
- Consensual sexual activity between strangers to provide mutual pleasure.
- To possess true unitive significance, sexual acts must be marital in character, combining the generosity of friendship with the intrinsic procreative significance of being acts of the reproductive kind.
Sterile Marriages versus Non-Marital and Masturbatory Acts:
- Classical philosophy and historical Christian tradition affirm that natural sterility (or pregnancy) does not render conjugal intercourse non-marital.
- When sterile spouses unite their reproductive organs in an act suitable for generation so far as their bodily capacity allows, they function as a real biological and personal unit, actualizing the two-in-one-flesh good of marriage.
- Conjugal intercourse during sterile periods differs fundamentally from non-marital or masturbatory acts committed by married couples (e.g., sodomy, fellatio, or coitus interruptus).
- In legal tradition, non-generative acts such as fellatio or sodomy do not consummate a marriage because they fail to actualize the two-part marital good, regardless of the subjective feelings of intimacy expressed by the partners.
Social Order, Natural Facts, and the Threat to Conjugal Marriage
Clarification of the Natural Facts Argument:
- Natural law ethics does not commit the fallacious move of deriving normative moral principles directly from purely non-normative natural facts.
- It does not rely on a simplistic moral imperative such as "Respect natural facts or natural functions."
- Instead, practical reason identifies basic human goods (such as marriage and personal inner integrity) and applies moral principles (e.g., that one must never act directly against a basic human good, nor prefer an illusory instantiation of a good over a real one) to the natural realities of human constitution, intentions, and circumstances.
Societal Repudiation of Non-Marital Behaviors:
- Human societies across history (including classical Athens and modern states) distinguish between actions that are merely offensive (such as consuming excrement) and actions repudiated as destructive to human character and social order.
- Bestiality (Copulation with Animals): Repudiated because it reduces human sexual capacity to animal coupling, completely divorced from an intelligible shared human good.
- Same-Sex Genital Coupling: Repudiated for structural reasons analogous to bestiality:
- It is inherently sterile and abdicates responsibility for the continuation of humankind.
- It fails to actualize genuine mutual devotion, causing personal harm through the dis-integrative instrumentalization of the body.
- It treats human sexual capacities in a manner hostile to the self-understanding of citizens who commit to traditional marital responsibilities.
Homosexual Orientation as a Threat to Marriage Institutions:
- Homosexual orientation (in the sense of a active willingness to engage in same-sex acts) represents a standing denial of the intrinsic capacity of sexual intercourse to express the exclusive, open-ended commitment of marriage.
- Accepting same-sex acts as a valid use of sexual capacities logically requires viewing sexual organs and acts as mere instruments for personal self-gratification.
- This instrumental view undermines the foundational logic of marriage, making nonsense of the principle that extra-marital acts such as adultery are intrinsically incompatible with conjugal love.
- A political community focused on preserving the stability, protective security, and educative capacity of family life possesses compelling rational grounds to:
- Reject same-sex acts and the "gay lifestyle" as valid human choices.
- Deny legal recognition of marriage to same-sex unions.
- Exercise its subsidiary authority to discourage public displays and endorsements of homosexual conduct.
Natural Law Theory, Aquinas, and De-maritalized Sexual Acts
Debate with Modern Critics and New Natural Law Theory:
- The framework aligns with the New Natural Law approach developed by scholars such as Germain Grisez, Robert George, Gerard Bradley, and John Finnis.
- In response to critiques (such as those by Andrew Koppelman in Homosexual Conduct: A Reply to the New Nature Lawyers), New Natural Lawyers explicitly reject as fallacious the premise that natural functions or physical tendencies are themselves moral standards.
- Contrary to widespread academic assumptions, Thomas Aquinas's historical sex ethics does not rely on a fallacious physicalist teleology, but on practical reason regarding basic human goods.
Aquinas's Criteria for Immoral Sexual Acts:
- Aquinas addresses the conditions under which sexual intercourse between lawfully married spouses becomes seriously wrong:
- Spousal sex is seriously wrongful whenever it becomes depersonalized or de-maritalized.
- If a spouse chooses intercourse solely for physical pleasure, solely for bodily health, or solely as a preventative relief from temptations toward masturbation or fornication—and would be equally willing to engage in the act with a prostitute, acquaintance, or another person's spouse—the act is non-marital.
- De-maritalized spousal sex is contrary to reason, and consequently contrary to human nature.
- It violates reason because it is dis-integrated from the primary basic human good directed by the first principles of practical reason: the intrinsic good of marriage itself.
- Aquinas addresses the conditions under which sexual intercourse between lawfully married spouses becomes seriously wrong:
Marital Fides and Internal Dis-integration:
- Marriage is a fundamental human good in which spousal friendship is fulfilled through the procreation, nurture, protection, education, and moral formation of children.
- Authentic marital intercourse actualizes and reinforces mutual spousal commitment (marital fides).
- A sexual act between spouses fails to actualize marriage if the acting person maintains an internal willingness under any circumstances to engage in non-marital sexual acts, including:
- Adultery.
- Fornication.
- Intentionally sterilized intercourse.
- Solitary masturbation.
- Mutual masturbation or sodomy.
- Even the conceptual acceptance of non-marital sexual acts as morally permissible introduces a state of mind that directly undermines and disintegrates the marital character of a couple's sexual acts.