What is 'Development'? - Definitional Debates and Development Studies Scope
The Contested Meaning and Evolution of ‘Development’
Definitions and Inherent Ambiguity: Alan Thomas () characterizes ‘development’ as a concept that is contested both theoretically and politically, inherently complex, and fundamentally ambiguous.
Historical Shift in Vision: Charles Gore () identifies a paradigm shift from the vision of the liberation of people and peoples that animated practice in the and . This has been replaced by a vision of the liberalization of economies.
Conceptual Transitions:
The goal of structural transformation has been largely superseded by the goal of spatial integration.
Broad attention to the dynamics of long-term transformations of economies and societies has slipped from view, replaced by a focus on short-term growth and the re-establishment of financial balances.
Gore labels this shift toward ahistorical performance assessment as a form of the "post-modernization" of development policy analysis.
Social Construction and Value Systems: Hickey and Mohan () state that post-modern approaches view poverty and development as socially constructed and embedded within specific economic epistemes. These epistemes prioritize certain assets over others. Post-modernism seeks alternative value systems to recognize the spiritual and cultural ‘assets’ of the poor rather than stigmatizing them.
Immanent vs. Intentional Development: Cowen and Shenton () distinguish between:
Immanent Development: An unintentional and underlying process of change (e.g., the historical development of capitalism).
Intentional Activity: A willed, deliberate process to ‘develop’ (e.g., post- efforts in the Third World).
Value-Laden Nature of Change: Robert Chambers () defines development simply as ‘good change.’ This raises questions about what constitutes ‘good’ and what types of change matter. He argues that any development agenda is value-laden and that failing to consider ‘good things to do’ is a surrender to fatalism.
Subjectivity in the ‘Good Life’: Ravi Kanbur () emphasizes that because development depends on values and alternative conceptions of the ‘good life,’ there is no unique or uniform answer to its definition.
Three Primary Conceptualizations of Development
1. ‘Development’ as a Long-term Process of Structural Societal Transformation
Core Focus: This perspective views development as a historical process of change. It was dominant in the and and is currently favored more by the academic/research community than by practitioners.
Key Characteristics:
Historical and Long-term: Focuses on major societal shifts over centuries.
Multidimensional Changes: A shift in one dimension (e.g., from rural/agriculture-based to urban/industrial-based) has radical implications for other dimensions, such as the relations of production (capital vs. labour).
Non-prescriptive: Generally does not relate to specific objectives or assume all societies follow the same path. It accommodates decline or crisis as part of structural change.
Meta-narratives: Related to grand visions like modernization or emancipation from underdevelopment, which proposed common pathways for newly independent countries.
2. ‘Development’ as a Short- to Medium-term Outcome of Desirable Targets
Core Focus: Described by Thomas () as a ‘vision or measure of progressive change,’ this view is technocratic, instrumental, and indicator-led.
Key Characteristics:
Ahistorical Outlet: Focuses on measurable performance indicators and targets (e.g., poverty reduction, income levels).
Practitioner Dominance: Favoured by international donor agencies (OECD, UNDP, World Bank).
The Millennium Development Goals (MDGs): Serve as a primary contemporary example of this targets-based approach.
Critique of Paternalism: Critics suggest this approach assumes universal values and may lack ‘ownership’ by the people it aims to benefit, potentially depoliticizing development by separating it from social relations and the distribution of power.
3. ‘Development’ as a Dominant ‘Discourse’ of Western Modernity
Core Focus: This ‘post-modern,’ ‘post-development,’ or ‘post-structuralist’ position views development as a set of ideas that shapes reality and power relations, often imposed by the West on the Third World.
Key Characteristics:
Rejection of Objective Reality: Drawing on Michel Foucault (), it argues that reality is only known through ‘discourse.’
Inferiority-Superiority Dynamics: Development is defined as synonymous with ‘modernity,’ framing non-Western approaches as ‘backward’ or ‘inferior.’
Historical Trigger: The position is often trace back to President Truman's declaration on making scientific and industrial progress available to ‘underdeveloped’ areas.
Orientalism: Edward Said () argued that Western cultural representations are systematic disciplines used to produce and manage the ‘Orient’ (synonymous with non-Western societies).
Internal Contradiction: Foucault’s ‘performative contradiction’ points out that if all reality is socially constructed, the post-modern account itself is also a social construct.
The Scope of Development Studies (DS)
DS and the ‘Third World’
Origins of the Term: Coined by Alfred Sauvy in , based on the French Revolution's ‘Third Estate.’ It originally reflected ‘exclusion’ rather than ‘inferiority.’
Historical Context: Associated with the ‘non-aligned movement’ () and the G77 alliance (). The term is now considered dated by the end of the Cold War.
Commonalities: Julius Nyerere argued that common characteristics (like the experience of colonization according to Toye, ) transcend the differences between developing countries.
Broadening the Scope Beyond the ‘Third World’
Universal Relevance: Poverty and structural change exist in all countries. For example, life expectancy in the Calton area of Glasgow ( years) is lower than in many developing countries.
Global Interconnectedness: Cross-disciplinary analysis is relevant to industrialized countries due to issues such as:
Demographic Dynamics: Older populations and low growth in the North vs. young populations and high growth in the South.
Over-development: Problems like obesity and high emissions in industrialized nations.
Global Challenges: Terrorism, pandemics (HIV/AIDS, Avian Flu), and environmental effects.
Blurring Boundaries: Simon Maxwell () suggests the distinction between North and South now rests more on tools of analysis than levels of living.
Classification and Acronyms of Countries
World Bank Income Groups ( GNI per capita thresholds):
Low income: Below
Lower middle income: to
Upper middle income: to
High income: or above
Key Acronyms:
BRIC: Brazil, Russia, India, and China
NIC: Newly Industrializing Countries
LDC: Less Developed Country (or Least Developed Country depending on context)
LICUS: Low Income Country Under Stress (fragile states with weak institutions)
HIPC: Heavily Indebted Poor Country
Transition Countries: Former state-planned economies moving to markets (e.g., Vietnam, Mongolia, Cambodia, Laos).
Aid Dependency Clubs:
Club: Countries deriving approximately of GDP from aid.
Club: Countries where aid plays a much smaller role, focusing on managing globalization.
Development Indicators: History and Evolution
The Search for Rigorous Measures
Pre-: Initial reliance on economic growth (GNP/GDP per capita) as a proxy for welfare.
The Dudley Seers Revolution: In , Seers proposed three fundamental questions: What has been happening to poverty, unemployment, and inequality? If these increase, it is not development, even if per capita income rises.
Basic Needs Approach (): Shifted focus toward physical necessities (food, shelter) and public services, led largely by the International Labour Office (ILO).
The Human Development and Capabilities Approach
Origins: Established in by Amartya Sen, Mahbub ul Huq, Richard Jolly, Frances Stewart, and Meghnad Desai.
Sen’s Philosophy: Development is the process of expanding real freedoms and capabilities for people to lead the kind of lives they value.
Core Concepts:
Functionings: Outcomes of wellbeing (what a person is or does, e.g., being healthy).
Capabilities: The substantive freedoms or opportunities to achieve those functionings.
Five Basic Freedoms: Political/participative freedoms, economic facilities, social opportunities, transparency guarantees, and protective security.
Human Development Indicators:
HDI (Human Development Index): Combines longevity (life expectancy), knowledge (literacy/enrolment), and living standard ( income per capita).
GDI (Gender Development Index): Adjusts HDI for gender inequality.
HPI-1: Measures absolute deprivation in developing countries.
HPI-2: Measures relative deprivation in industrialized countries (includes long-term unemployment).
The UN Millennium Development Goals (MDGs)
The List of MDGs:
Eradicate extreme poverty and hunger.
Achieve universal primary education.
Promote gender equality and empower women.
Reduce child mortality.
Improve maternal health.
Combat HIV/AIDS, malaria, and other diseases.
Ensure environmental sustainability.
Develop a global partnership for development.
Critiques of the MDGs (Ajit Saith, ):
Ghettoization: Locates development problems exclusively in the Third World.
Top-down Construction: Created largely by industrialized countries without adequate consultation.
Distortionary Impact: Diverts social science research towards agency-driven agendas and leads to the manipulation of statistics.
Omissions: Fails to capture participation, democracy, and risk adequate sustainability.
Subjective vs. Objective Wellbeing
Context-Specific Indicators: Robert Chambers () advocates for the perceptions of poor people to be the point of departure. Items like dignity, voice, and security may be more important than consumption.
Psychological Shift: Moving from physiological conditions (objective physical state) to psychological conditions (subjective experience). McGregor () defines it as: "What a person has, what a person can do with what they have, and how they think about what they have and can do."