Chapter VIII: Business Ethics

Introduction:

world of business - often seen as an amoral world

business people - often viewed as ruthless, self-interested individuals

principal task of ethics - to enforce the values of justice and fairness in situations where there are grave abuses of power and a gross imbalance in the allocation of resources between people that are meant to share them.

business - prone to many unethical practices, especially by those who occupy the seats of power of corporations.

Multinational Corporation
  • multinational corporation - companies that have manufacturing, marketing, service, and administrative operations in many different nations.
  • globalization - has brought the world many benefits. They bring jobs, skills, income, and technology to regions of the world.
Normative Theories of Business Ethics

3 basic normative theories

  1. the stockholder theory - the people who invested money in the company that serve as the main source of business decisions.
  • managers - acts as agents that serve at the pleasure of investors
  • stockholders - have the final say in everything that happens in the business
  1. the stakeholder theory - holds that the management's fundamental obligation is not to maximize the firm's financial success but to ensure its survival by balancing the conflicting claims of multiple stakeholders
  • stakeholder - defined as any group or individual that stands to benefit or suffer from decisions made by corporation

2 principles of stakeholder management

  • principle of corporate legitimacy - the corporation should be managed for the benefit of its stakeholders: its consumers, suppliers, owners, employees, and the local communities.
  • stakeholder fiduciary principle - it must act in the interest of the stakeholders as their agent, and it must act in the interest of the corporation to ensure the survival of the firm safeguarding the long-term stakes of each group.
  1. the social contract theory - all business are ethically obligated to enhance the welfare of society by satisfying the consumer and employee interests without violating any of the general canons of justice

How business enhance the welfare of society from the perspective of the social contract - benefit consumers by increasing economic efficiency benefit employees by increasing their income potential minimizing pollution and depletion of natural resources.

corporate social responsibility - a company's strategic initiative to contribute to the well-being of society and the environment

CSR - corporate social responsibility

R. Eric Reidenbach and Donald P. Robin

- argues that there are certain organizational behaviors that exhibit a business' level of moral development

  • Kohlberg’s model - shows how an individual’s moral development progresses from being based on external factors to one that is founded upon internal moral motivation
Kohlberg’s Model

Level 1: Pre-conventional morality

Stage 1: obedience and punishment - behavior driven by avoiding punishment

Stage 2: Individual interest - Behavior driven by self-interest and rewards

Level 2: Conventional morality

Stage 1: interpersonal - Behavior driven by social approval

Stage 2: authority - Behavior driven by obeying authority and conforming social order

Level 3: Post-Conventional morality

Stage 1: social contract - Behavior driven by balance of social order and individual rights

Stage 2: Universal ethics - Behavior driven by internal moral principles

5 Stages of Organizational Moral Development

Stage 1: the amoral organization - Defined by a “winning at any cost” attitude

an enterprise completely absorbed in productivity and profitability - amoral organization

Stage 2: the legalistic corporation - “Exhibit compliance with the letter of the law as opposed to the spirit of the law”

Stage 3: the responsive corporation - Begins to acquire values other than profitability and legality.

Stage 4: the emergent ethical organization - recognizes the existence of a social contract between business and society.

Stage 5: the ethical organization - an organization-wide acceptance of a common set of ethical values that permeates the organization’s culture.