The Great Depression
The Great Depression
As I have already hinted at, the progressive movement was disappearing in the late 1910s and 1920s and this would have a huge impact on the decades to come. Progressivism disappeared for the following four (disconnected) reasons:
Discontent - Some of the major leaders of the progressive movement no longer felt like it was working. Unions were angry at the post-war crackdowns and farmers were angry with falling wartime prices.
Disillusionment- Liberal progressive intellectuals became disillusioned with the grassroots supporters they were trying to lead and the backlash that had developed including the lack of effectiveness of prohibition, the KKK, and fundamentalism.
Distraction- Middle-class reformers became preoccupied and distracted by such things as shopping.
Done- Some progressives felt that with the enactment of the 18th and 19th Amendments their work was finished.
As you will see at least on the national level progressive politicians were soon replaced by Republican Conservatives.
By the election of 1920, many were tired of Wilson's idealism and opted to elect Warren G. Harding who campaigned on a "return to normalcy" platform. Despite being what many considered to be a "stunning mediocrity," Harding won and soon revealed himself to be in over his head as he made many poor choices including selecting his cabinet members. Despite his ineptitude, Harding fulfilled his campaign promise and took many of the following steps to turn back that nation’s clock. Harding quickly enacted the following:
Revenue Act (1926)- This act extended benefits to high-income groups by lowering estate taxes.
Fordney- McCumber Tariff (1922)- This act raised the tariff protecting big business.
Although he could not dissolve regulatory agencies he intentionally named commissioners who were “friendly” to those they were regulating.
Embraced pre-WWI isolationism. Under Harding, America was going to mind her own business.
Despite Harding's best efforts, the reality was that in a post-WWI world America's isolationism was impossible for the following reasons:
War Debts- The US had loaned the allies large sums of money to finance their war effort. By 1917 Great Britain and France had run out of money. The US continued to try and collect, while the British maintained that they did not have to pay back their debt because they were protecting the US by fighting the war without her. The issue became even more difficult when Germany, forced to pay reparations defaulted twice! In a very convoluted solution, US banks began loaning money to Germany to pay back Britain and France so they in turn could pay the US back. Needless to say, this plan failed epically.
Disarmament- The US was invested in preventing another horrific war. To that end, she agreed to the Five-Power Pack which required the five leading nations ( Great Britain, France, Italy, the US, and Japan) to limit the size of their navies. And she also signed the Kellogg-Briand Pact which declared signatories to “renounce war as an instrument of national policy. Sixty-two nations signed,
Despite his actions to return the US to its pre-progressive day Harding's behavior and poor choices soon caught up with him. His administration was plagued with scandals of all types, privately he continued with having affairs, gambling, and drinking. In 1923, while on a tour of Alaska, Harding supposedly had an attack of food poisoning and suddenly died. His VP, Calvin Coolidge replaced him. For many, Coolidge, who was the exact opposite of Harding, was a relief. Given the nickname "Silent" Cal, Coolidge was simple, direct, self-righteous, patriotic, frugal, principled, and most of all silent. Coolidge quickly ushered in the return of big business by protecting industrial development by reducing taxes and removing federal regulations. He was so good at his job that he was reelected in 1924.
Coolidge’s second term was more of the same. While Coolidge helped big business he did little to help anyone else. By now many farmers were beginning to feel the post-war bounce and were hurting financially. Instead of helping them, Coolidge vetoed the McNary-Haugen Bill which would have set protective tariffs on agricultural goods and protected farmers from international competition. He did even more damage to workers. Under Coolidge, industries became Open Shop which meant that employers could hire and fire anyone they wanted. It also allowed employers to exclude unionists and refuse to recognize unions altogether. Some companies went so far as to have their workers sign what were called Yellow Dog Contracts that stipulated that if workers joined a Union they could and would be fired.
In 1928 Coolidge announced he was not going to seek reelection. The Republicans nominated Herbert Hoover who won in a landslide. Upon his election, Hoover stated, “ I have no fears for the future of our country… it is bright with hope.”
At first, all seemed well, in 1928 US stocks rose 40%. Speculation raced at a fever pitch and credit was being handed out like candy. But then in August of 1929, things began to change. During the third week of October, the stock market continued to destabilize. It was so bad that on Tuesday, October 24th, 16 million shares were traded and the index dropped by 43 points ( almost 10%.) In fact, in one day all of the gains from the previous year were destroyed! In some cases stock became worthless.
IMPORTANT: Now repeat after me…BLACK TUESDAY DID NOT CAUSE THE GREAT DEPRESSION!!! The Crash was a symptom of several causes that caused the Depression. The best way to think about the Depression is to compare it to the common cold. When you have a cold you have a cough (in this case the Crash) but the cough is not the cause of the cold it is a result of the cold. Now you ask, what were the causes of the Great Depression? Well, there are five main ones and in reality, they were a long time coming…
Lack of Market Diversification- By 1920 the US had two major industries- cars and construction. The problem was that both of these were one-time purchases. In other words, unlike today, people in the 1920s bought one house or one car, and that's all they would purchase for a lifetime. Things were fine until everyone had their car or house. At that point, production should have decreased or stopped. It did not and both industries flooded their respective markets.
Misdistribution of Purchasing Power- As the saying goes the rich get richer and the poor get poorer. Nowhere was this more evident than in the 1920s. The problem was that the rich only made up a small portion of the nation’s purchasers which meant as the number of poor increased the number of consumers decreased. As consumers decreased the need for workers decreased which meant businesses had to lay off workers which further added to the US’s economic depression.
Volatile Credit Structure- By the latter half of the 1920s most of the country was in debt, which meant that smaller banks were constantly at risk of closing due to their customer's likelihood of default. Moreover, during the previous decade, credit had been easy to obtain with many banks loaning to high-risk clients- those who were probably not going to be able to pay them back. This in turn hurt larger banks that had lent money to the smaller banks. Furthermore, many banks had invested recklessly in the stock market and had lost large sums of their capital. As a result, banks began contracting their credit making it harder for new businesses to get loans.
The decline in International Trade- Following WWI international trade had been booming but by the end of the decade, two things had happened. Either international countries had recovered their industries or countries were facing economic depressions of their own and had no money to spend. **** IMPORTANT: The Hawley-Smoot Tariff did not cause the Great Depression. ****
International Debt Structure- I have already touched on this but due to the convoluted plan to fix the international debt, the US losing money hand over foot as the money she loaned to Germany to pay back to France and Great Britain was never paid back to the US.
For a while, in 1929 it appeared that the economy was recovering. Stocks bounced back but by 1930 reality set in. Between 1930 and 1933 900 banks went bankrupt or closed completely. This set off a chain reaction that soon resulted in a deadly self-perpetuating cycle. As the banks closed the money supply shrank by 1/3 which led to a decline in credit and purchasing power. As people lost their money, consumer demand plummeted, which in turn made companies reduce the prices of their products which in turn lowered their overall earnings. As companies lost money they began enacting labor cuts either decreasing the amount they paid their workers or laying off more workers. As workers were laid off their purchasing power further declined. As the economy plummeted the government did what they always had done in the past. The Federal Reserve increased interest rates with the result that credit was further contracted.
By 1932 US unemployment was 25% (that translates to 1 in 4 Americans being jobless!) Of the 75% still employed 1/3 of those were underemployed meaning they were earning less than they were worth. Certain areas of the country were hit worse than others. In New England and the Midwest industrial hubs were hit particularly hard with unemployment in Cleveland at 50%, Akron at 60%, and Toledo at 80%. All across the south over 60% of all farmers had lost their farms. Adding to the misery the West experienced the worst drought in history resulting in what became known as the Dust Bowl (which did not cause the Depression). The Dust Bowl made western farms uninhabitable forcing already destitute families to leave their homes and search for homes and jobs elsewhere.
Women lost their jobs to men. The US government created a law that women were required to give up their civil service jobs. However, the reality was that every member of the family had to work. Additionally, women returned to traditional in-house jobs to support their families including sewing, canning, and farming. As unemployment increased entire families moved in together to save money. Divorce, marriage, and birth rates all declined during this period. It should be noted though that divorce only declined due to its cost. Despite the hardships facing the country, Americans still embraced the idea of the American Dream. This was widely reflected in the radio shows and movies created during this period which allowed Americans at least short periods of escapism.
By 1930 the radio had become very popular with the creation of shows such as Amos n Amos, Superman, Dick Tracy, the Lone Ranger, and the first soap operas. Radios also aired public events including baseball games, horse races, and disasters such as the Hindenburg explosion in 1937. The best example of escapism came in the form of Orson Welles's famous War of the Worlds which was aired on October 31st, 1938! Movies during this period also embraced a sense of delight with the creation of Frank Capra's Mr. Deeds Goes to Town (1936) and Mr. Smith Goes to Washington (1939). During this period screwball comedies also became popular including It Happened One Night and the Marx Brothers movies. The best example of the 1930s optimism though was the creation of Walt Disney’s Mickey Mouse. Disney’s second animated short, Steam Boat Willy was a hit. He soon followed it up with the first-ever full-length animated film Snow White (1937). Other great movies created during this time include The Grapes of Wrath, The Wizard of Oz, and Gone with the Wind.
America had faced economic depression before and had always recovered with little help (read no help) from the government. However, this current depression was different. It just kept getting worse and worse. Hoover (who is often unfairly criticized for doing nothing) soon began attempts to fix the economy. His attempts were still woefully limited by his belief that government should not interfere with free markets. And as you will see his attempts were like putting a band-aid on an amputated limb. Hoover’s attempts included:
Calling a meeting between businessmen, laborers, union leaders, and farmers where each group would voluntarily come to agreements to keep mills and shops open, maintain wages, spread out work, and avoid layoffs. The problem was since these agreements were voluntary they were not binding and soon were discarded.
Increasing government spending that included $423 Million for public works. Hoover also encouraged states and local governments to do the same. Despite the seemingly astronomical amount, it was but a single drop in the barrel.
Creating aid for farmers in the form of the Hawley Smoot Tariff (1930) which increased tariffs on 75 farm products, thus, protecting farmers from international competition, and the Agricultural Market Act (1929) which created farm boards that would provide loans to national marketing cooperatives and create government corporations to purchase surplus farm products in the hopes it would help stimulate prices.
Despite America's sunny optimism soon some groups began speaking out including farmers and veterans and included:
The Farmers Holiday- The Farmers Holiday was a farmers' strike. Farmers agreed to withhold farm products from the market. The problem was that no one was able to buy their products in the first place so the strike did little to help their situation.
Bonus Army- In 1924 Congress had promised all WWI veterans a $1000 bonus to be paid in 1945. In 1932 desperate veterans demanded immediate payment of their bonus. When Hoover rejected their request 20,000 veterans marched on DC where they set up tents. Hoover called in the police but the veterans retaliated. Hoover then called Douglas MacArthur along with his 3rd Cavalry plus two additional Infantry Regiments, Machine Guns, and 6 tanks. It was a black day in US history….