Assignment retake.

1. Why is being not a genus?

  • A genus is a general category divided into species by differences.

  • For example, the genus “animal” includes humans, distinguished as rational animals.

  • Being cannot be divided in this same way because every real difference is already included in being.

  • Any difference outside being would be nothing.

  • Nothing cannot distinguish one kind of being from another.

  • Therefore, being is not a genus; it includes all categories and their differences.

2. Why must every being be one?

  • Every being must have unity to exist as a particular thing.

  • Being “one” means being undivided in itself.

  • Something can have many parts and still be one unified being.

  • For example, your many organs belong to one living organism.

  • If that unity is destroyed, the original being no longer exists as that whole.

  • Therefore, every being must be one, although this does not mean that everything is a single being.

3. Why do we need substance to explain identity through change?

  • Substance is the underlying being that has properties.

  • Those properties, called accidents, can change while the substance remains.

  • For example, you can grow taller while remaining the same person.

  • Substance explains what stays the same and whose properties are changing.

  • Without an enduring subject, we could not explain how different properties belong to the same being over time.

  • Substance therefore explains identity through accidental change, but it does not survive its own destruction.

4. What does the Principle of Non-Contradiction state, and why must it always be affirmed?

  • The Principle of Non-Contradiction states that something cannot both have and lack the same property at the same time and in the same respect.

  • For example, the same door cannot be completely closed and not completely closed at the same moment.

  • This principle allows change because the door can be closed now and open later.

  • It applies to being as being, meaning everything insofar as it exists.

  • Anyone arguing against the principle already relies on it by expecting their denial to exclude its opposite.

  • Therefore, it must be affirmed as a first principle that meaningful reasoning already assumes.