G

Summary of Key Concepts from Chapter on Colonialism and Nature

  • A woman in Tlaxcala, New Spain, executed shortly after her crime, had her identity erased from historical records.

  • On July 8, she smashed crosses in a church, incited rebellion among local tribes, and killed an Indian using sorcery.

  • Arrested the next day, she defended herself by recounting a dream in which deer symbolized a new cosmic order.

  • Her vision threatened colonial authority and capitalist norms; she was hanged as a witch, illustrating suppressive reactions to alternative worldviews.

  • The concept of nature vs. society took shape during the rise of European colonial capitalism, particularly between the late 15th and late 17th centuries.

  • Nature began to be viewed as the opposite of society, which reinforced the distinction of social hierarchies and conceptualized Indigenous populations as lesser beings requiring civilization.

  • Key thinkers like Descartes established foundational ideas (i.e., mind vs. body) and ideologies that justified European domination over nature and people, linking the possession of nature with economic and political power.

  • Capitalism exploited nature and connected social and ecological crises to economic systems, contriving ideas and boundaries that positioned certain humans within nature to justify coercion for production and profit.

  • Historical resistance to these structures, exemplified by Indigenous peoples, illustrates ongoing struggles against the colonial and capitalist imposition of order.

A woman in Tlaxcala, New Spain, was executed shortly after her crime, illustrating the harsh realities faced by those who challenged colonial authority. Her identity was erased from historical records, emphasizing how those involved in colonial dynamics were often marginalized or forgotten.

On July 8, she committed an act of vandalism by smashing crosses in a church, a significant symbol of colonial faith imposed on Indigenous populations. This act was not only a personal rebellion but also incited rebellion among local tribes, reflecting the growing discontent and resistance against colonial rule. During this tumultuous event, she allegedly killed an Indian using sorcery, a supernatural accusation that exemplified the fears and biases of the colonial authorities.

Arrested the next day, she defended herself by recounting a vivid dream where deer symbolized a new cosmic order, a vision that juxtaposed the Indigenous worldview with the colonial perspective. Her dream articulated a challenge to the existing power structures, threatening colonial authority and rejecting the capitalist norms that dominated the period. In response to her perceived threat, she was hanged as a witch, illustrating the suppressive reactions of colonial authorities to alternative worldviews that contradicted their control.

The concept of nature versus society gained prominence during the rise of European colonial capitalism, particularly between the late 15th and late 17th centuries. Nature was increasingly seen as the antithesis of society, reinforcing social hierarchies and further conceptualizing Indigenous populations as lesser beings in need of civilization. Key thinkers of the time, such as René Descartes, laid the intellectual groundwork for this worldview through fundamental ideas like the mind-body dualism, which justified European domination over both nature and Indigenous peoples. Such ideologies linked the possession of natural resources to economic and political power, rationalizing exploitation.

Capitalism's exploitation of nature is reflected in its connection to social and ecological crises, where economic systems contrived boundaries and ideas that deemed certain humans as being part of nature. This created a justification for coercing these populations in the name of production and profit, encapsulating the moral and ethical dilemmas present in colonial interactions.

Historical resistance to these oppressive structures, exemplified by various Indigenous peoples' struggles, highlights the ongoing challenges against the imposition of colonial and capitalist orders. These resistance efforts serve as an important reminder of the complexity of history and the necessity of recognizing diverse perspectives that have historically been silenced or marginalized. Understanding these dynamics is crucial to grasping the multifaceted impacts of colonization that continue to resonate today.