Turning Tide Ch.8

The Quest for Parity: The Diplomatic Option

The Impact of Disease on Kamehameha’s Reign

  • Kamehameha's legacy as a military leader and statesman is overshadowed by the health crisis during his reign. Despite his efforts to be pono (morally upright), the population suffered a dramatic decline due to infectious diseases introduced by foreign visitors.

  • It is estimated that the Hawaiian population dropped by about 50% during his time, primarily due to epidemics such as ka ma'i 'oku'u which plagued his campaigns and troops.

  • Kamehameha himself contracted this illness but managed to recover, while many key chiefs, essential to the nation’s governance, did not survive.

The Arrival of Foreign Diseases

  • The introduction of Western diseases created a catastrophe for the native population. Oswald A. Bushnell's work highlights how encounters with Westerners exposed Hawaiians to foreign pathogens against which they had no immunity.

  • Despite Captain Cook’s awareness of potential health risks, transgressions continued among his crew. One sailor was punished for engaging sexually with native women while suffering from venereal diseases.

Demographic Crisis and Isolation

  • The isolation of Hawaii prior to contact with Europeans left the native population vulnerable to various diseases, including tuberculosis and gastro-intestinal issues, all of which had catastrophic impacts.

  • Various experts dispute the population estimates before Cook's arrival, with figures ranging from 110,000 to possibly over a million, but all agree that catastrophic declines resulted from these epidemics.

Cultural Representations of Disease

  • Literature from the colonial period, such as Pierre Loti's The Marriage of Loti, reflects the romanticization of native peoples and the impending doom brought about by contact with Western culture. Loti’s character embodies the corruption and decay of the Polynesian race due to foreign influences.

  • While diseases like syphilis and cancer existed prior to Cook’s arrival, the scale of devastation brought on by new illnesses was unprecedented.

The Role of Healers

  • Traditional Hawaiian healers, or kahuna lapa'au, attempted to treat ailments using a combination of herbal remedies and spiritual practices. They had some knowledge of existing diseases prior to Western contact but struggled with the influx of new ones.

  • European medicine at the time was often primitive, and figures like Paracelsus sought holistic approaches contrasting with the invasive methods of Western medicine.

Responses to Epidemics

  • Eventually, as diseases like leprosy—known in Hawaii as ka Pake—spread, a harsh regime was implemented leading to quarantines and separation of the afflicted from their families, notably on Kalaupapa in Moloka'i.

  • Father Damien emerged as a key figure during this crisis, providing care and dignity to leprosy patients, ultimately succumbing to the disease himself.

The Shift in Hawaiian Governance

  • With the introduction of foreign diseases, traditional political structures crumbled. Kamehameha’s successors faced immense challenges in maintaining sovereignty while adapting to Western politics.

  • The conversion of many ali'i (chiefs) to Christianity showcased a rejection of traditional beliefs and a shift towards Western ideologies, partly as a response to the social and political upheaval caused by epidemics.

The Economic Impact of Trade

  • The sandalwood trade significantly affected Hawaiian society. Initially, Kamehameha I pushed for the collection of sandalwood, but realizing the negative impact on food cultivation led to restrictions on its collection.

  • Following Kamehameha's death, the trade was unregulated, leading to exploitation of resources and fostering a cycle of dependency on foreign goods.

Foreign Influence and Legislative Changes

  • By the 1820s, American missionaries played a central role in reshaping Hawaiian law and governance, encouraging Western-style education and legal systems.

  • The code of laws introduced in 1825 reflected modified biblical principles. Unlike their predecessors, these laws often clashed with traditional Hawaiian customs, enforcing strict moral codes influenced by Protestant values.

The Quest for Diplomatic Parity

  • Following significant foreign interventions and recognizing the shifting power dynamics, Hawaiian leaders sought to establish their nation’s sovereignty through diplomacy.

  • Kamehameha III’s era was marked by efforts to navigate foreign pressures, including treaties with Western powers that both recognized and undermined Hawaiian sovereignty.

Conclusion: Parity and Future Challenges

  • The shifting dynamics of power within the Pacific, highlighted by the establishment of diplomatic relations, culminated in a precarious balance. Despite assertions of independence post-1843, Hawaii faced ongoing challenges from both Western nations and emerging internal political factions.

  • The legacies of disease, colonization, and cultural transformation set the stage for the ongoing struggle for Hawaiian identity and sovereignty in the years to follow.