The Long Second Wave, The Fourth Movement of Immigrants, & Mexican Immigrants in the Fourth Movement
The Robins Theory of Economics and Immigration
The political and economic relationship governing United States immigration policy is defined by the Robins "Love Them or Screw Them" theory of economics and immigration.
The fundamental principle of this theory establishes an explicit, direct correlation between the macroeconomic performance of the United States and national attitudes toward immigrant labor and foreign entry:
Periods of economic prosperity—characterized by high Gross Domestic Product (), high employment numbers, low national unemployment rates, and widespread job placement within specialized fields—correlate directly with national openness, social tolerance, and state incentives welcoming foreign labor.
Periods of economic downturn, market contraction, fiscal crisis, or soaring unemployment correlate directly with intense anti-immigrant sentiment, systemic scapegoating, legislative restriction, and mass deportation.
The historical trajectory of Mexican migration across the century serves as the archetype demonstrating the predictive validity of this economic model.
The 1920s Economic Boom and the Long Second Wave
The Long Second Wave of Mexican migration represents the first true immigration wave of Mexicans into the United States, distinguishing it from the initial incorporation era resulting from territorial annexation and military conquest.
Mexican immigrants were uniquely exempt from the restrictive national quota systems codified in the Immigration Quota Acts of and , allowing continuous legal entry until the statutory reforms of .
The domestic economic conditions of the (the "Roaring Twenties") fueled this sustained migration:
Following World War I, the United States stood as one of the few functional, undamaged global industrial economies while the principal infrastructure of Europe lay devastated.
The decade maintained the lowest unemployment rates recorded in the United States up to that era, accompanied by broad-scale industrialization and abundant job availability.
The "American Dream" emerged as a prevailing societal conviction: the cultural and economic expectation that children would inevitably achieve greater financial prosperity than their parents and that continuous prosperity was guaranteed.
Under the Immigration Act of , lawmakers deliberately preserved an exemption for migrants from the Western Hemisphere to ensure an uninterrupted supply of low-wage labor for agricultural and manual positions that domestic workers refused at prevailing wage levels.
As predicted by the economic theory, the United States actively solicited, recruited, and encouraged Mexican laborers to enter the domestic labor market throughout the .
The Great Depression and the Scapegoating of Mexicans (1929–1939)
The Wall Street stock market crash of abruptly concluded the economic expansion of the and initiated the Great Depression, precipitating a structural collapse of domestic employment.
National unemployment reached a historical peak of , signifying that in every individuals willing and able to work could not secure employment.
Conforming to the Robins economic theory, public and governmental attitudes inverted immediately: Mexican laborers—the predominant group entering the country due to global immigration caps restricting the rest of the world to roughly persons—were cast as scapegoats for the nationwide financial crisis.
Shifts in Federal Border Enforcement and Statutory Policy:
The United States Border Patrol, originally established in the primarily to intercept unauthorized Chinese immigrants crossing the Canadian and Mexican borders, was repurposed during the to halt Mexican entry.
Although Western Hemisphere migrants remained statutory exempt from numerical quotas, consular and border officials weaponized administrative hurdles by voiding existing entry visas, rejecting new visa applications, and aggressively policing the Rio Grande border.
Congress enacted the Undesirable Aliens Act of , which officially criminalized undocumented entry as a federal misdemeanor and repeated undocumented entry as a federal felony, imposing severe judicial penalties and prison sentences.
The Mexican Repatriation Program ():
A federal, state, and municipal campaign designed to deport and forcibly expatriate populations of Mexican descent over a ten-year timeline.
Conducted largely without formal legal proceedings or constitutional protections, municipal and federal authorities forcibly transported individuals across the southern border.
Over Mexicans and Mexican Americans were expelled from the United States under this repatriation initiative.
Approximately of all individuals rounded up and deported under the program were legally recognized citizens of the United States who had never previously resided in Mexico.
World War II and the Bracero Program (1942–1965)
The onset of World War II catalyzed the United States industrial war machine, completely rehabilitating the domestic economy and expanding production capacity beyond all other combatant nations, whose domestic infrastructures were destroyed.
The national unemployment rate plunged from to , creating an immediate, severe labor shortage across agricultural, manufacturing, and transportation sectors.
In accordance with the theoretical framework, federal policy reversed course from targeted deportation back to state-sponsored labor recruitment.
Operation of the Bracero Program ():
Established via a bilateral treaty framework between the United States and Mexico, the term bracero derives from the Spanish word brazo ("arm"), denoting manual agricultural laborers working with their hands.
Over the duration of the program, approximately Mexican laborers were legally admitted to perform contract labor.
The United States government directly managed logistics, operating trains, buses, and motor vehicles into the Mexican interior to collect laborers and issue standardized Bracero identification cards functioning as temporary work visas.
Contractual Promises versus Material Realities:
The program contractually guaranteed free round-trip transportation between Mexico and the United States, guaranteed living or minimum wage standards, sanitary work camp housing, and communal dining facilities.
In practice, actual camp environments were substandard, sanitary infrastructure was inadequate, and wage disbursements routinely failed to meet living wage standards.
Despite severe conditions, the program experienced overwhelming demand from Mexican laborers because domestic compensation in the United States substantially exceeded contemporary economic returns in Mexico.
Administrative Characteristics and Union Opposition:
Open to both men and women, though the participant demographic was overwhelmingly male.
The Bracero visa remained an explicitly temporary, non-immigrant labor contract that permitted return migration and the temporary accompaniment of dependents, but offered zero pathway to permanent residency, legal status, or United States citizenship.
Any minor violation of employer rules or criminal statutes resulted in immediate revocation of visa status and summary deportation.
Domestic labor unions vehemently opposed the Bracero Program and refused to represent Bracero workers, arguing that temporary foreign contracts artificially suppressed domestic wages and undermined domestic collective bargaining, drawing historical parallels to nineteenth-century anti-Chinese labor arguments.
Stereotypes, Scientific Racism, and Systematic Discrimination
Ideology of the "Inferior Race" and Inherent Non-Assimilability:
Drawing upon early twentieth-century eugenics and scientific racism, domestic theorists constructed the classification of the "Mexican race."
State and popular discourse categorized Mexicans as "unassimilatable," asserting that physical and racial traits precluded integration into Anglo-American society, that they possessed no interest in learning English, and that they had no intention of permanent civic assimilation.
"Unassimilatable" functioned as a racial barrier: individuals exhibiting darker physical characteristics could not "pass" as white and were subjected to racial exclusion, whereas light-skinned individuals occasionally circumvented this classification.
Migrants underwent dehumanizing physical border inspections and compulsory IQ tests, the results of which were leveraged to justify confining Mexican workers to low-wage manual labor.
Media-Driven Stereotypes of Inherent Violence:
Emerging twentieth-century mass media (film and television) replaced older print political cartoons, codifying and disseminating racial tropes nationwide.
Stereotypes drew upon American perceptions of violence stemming from the historical Mexican Revolution.
The "Ruthless Bandito": Depicted as dark-complexioned, heavily armed with crossed chest bandoliers, lawless, revolutionary, and actively subversive to American domestic tranquility.
"Hyper Machismo": Portrayed Mexican males as excessively sexualized, pathologically violent, prone to domestic abuse against women and children, alcohol-dependent, and prone to public violence—mirroring earlier anti-Irish immigrant tropes.
Universal Criminalization: Portrayals systematically associated Mexican populations with gang violence, lawlessness, and organized narcotics trafficking.
Systematic Legal and Extralegal Discrimination:
Anti-Miscegenation Laws: States enforced legal prohibitions against sexual contact and matrimonial unions between differing racial categories (laws tracing back to that originally targeted relationships between Black and white individuals were deployed against Mexican populations).
Involuntary Sterilization: Leveraging the Supreme Court precedent set in Buck v. Bell, public health authorities subjected Mexican and Mexican American women to non-consensual surgical sterilizations.
Extralegal Violence: The Ku Klux Klan (KKK) and allied vigilantes terrorized Mexican communities, executing extrajudicial lynchings of Mexican individuals through the .
Institutional Labor Segregation: Mexican workers were barred from access to high-wage employment sectors and excluded from mainstream collective bargaining gains.
Resistance, Community Building, and the Chicano Movement
Cultural Resistance as Passive Retaliation:
Mexican populations countered assimilationist pressures through the deliberate preservation of cultural traditions, including home instruction in the Spanish language, continued practice of Roman Catholicism, traditional culinary habits, and community celebration of holidays such as Cinco de Mayo.
Institutional and Informational Networks:
Immigrants established mutual aid societies to provide collective economic capital, burial insurance, and social safety nets, mirroring institutions established by earlier Irish, Chinese, and Southern Italian immigrants.
The formation of an extensive Spanish-language press network consisting of hundreds of newspapers circulated across the nation, providing regional American reporting alongside political and legislative updates from Mexico to assist temporary and return migrants.
The Chicano Civil Rights Movement:
Emerging during the and alongside the broader African American Civil Rights and Black Power movements, the Chicano Movement championed Mexican Pride.
Rejected the anglicization of surnames, discarded attempts to pass as white, embraced traditional Mexican apparel, and enforced bilingual cultural pride.
Organized agricultural workers through unionization drives—notably the United Farm Workers (UFW)—to secure basic labor rights, fair wages, and working protections for farm laborers who were excluded from standard federal labor protections.
Challenged institutional voter suppression (such as discriminatory literacy examinations and registration blocks) to establish legal aid clinics, expand enfranchisement, and mobilize Mexican American electoral power.
The Fourth Movement and the Immigration and Nationality Act of 1965
Demarcation of the Fourth Movement:
Spans from to the present day, constituting the numerically largest immigration movement in the history of the United States.
Prompted by the civil rights era and presidential initiatives seeking to modernize foreign policy and erase racially biased immigration statutes.
Legislative Origins and Passage:
In , President John F. Kennedy publicly denounced the national origins quota formula of the as "intolerable," though congressional inertia blocked immediate reform.
Following Kennedy's assassination, President Lyndon Baines Johnson utilized his extensive legislative acumen ("Master of the Senate") to pass the Great Society platform, driving approximately progressive domestic measures through Congress, including the Civil Rights Act, the Voting Rights Act, environmental statutes, food safety regulations, and infrastructure modernization.
As an essential component of the Great Society, Johnson signed the Immigration and Nationality Act of (Hart-Celler Act), abolishing the national origins quota system instituted in and .
Structural Mechanisms of the 1965 Act:
Dismantled percentage-based calculations linked to historical national censuses, substituting an absolute numerical ceiling capped at visas annually.
Divided total visas hemispherically: allocated to the Eastern Hemisphere, and allocated to the Western Hemisphere (a distribution that favored the Eastern Hemisphere despite its population being double that of the Western Hemisphere).
Imposed a per-country statutory cap of immigrant visas per year for individual nations.
Eradicated the remnants of the Chinese Exclusion Act, reopening immigration pipelines from Asia, Latin America, and Africa.
Rescinded the Western Hemisphere exemption: For the first time in United States history, Mexican immigration was subjected to numerical ceilings and individual country limits, ending the era of open border entries.
Terminated the Bracero Program in , stranding laborers and precipitating mass expulsions via trains, planes, and automobiles.
The Family Reunification Mandate:
Established family reunification as the paramount objective of United States visa processing, prioritizing immediate relatives (spouses, minor children, and parents of United States citizens or lawful permanent residents).
Visas granted under family reunification classifications were made completely exempt from all numerical and hemispheric quotas.
Catalyzed widespread "chain migration," wherein an individual entered the country, acquired lawful permanent residency or citizenship, and filed petitions for extended family members.
Cultivated inter-immigrant resentment: groups possessing established generational family networks in the United States (such as Mexicans) secured substantial numbers of family visas, whereas new immigrant populations without relatives faced prolonged visa queues.
Demographic and Logistical Consequences:
Annual legal immigration volumes escalated dramatically beyond the baseline statute: rising from to annually, expanding to roughly per year during the , and crossing annually by —levels unseen since the peak immigration decade of the .
Physical intake stations such as Ellis Island became obsolete; visa adjudications shifted to electronic pre-clearance administered in home countries, with entries occurring across all international airports, rail depots, and national land border posts.
Traditional, geographically centralized ethnic enclaves (such as Five Points in New York or San Francisco's Chinatown) were replaced by decentralized immigrant communities distributed across the interior United States.
Capping legal Mexican entries at per year, combined with terminating temporary farm work visas, directly spurred the emergence of a massive undocumented population after .
The Four Modern Pathways for Mexican Entry Post-1965
Official Permanent Visa:
Grants legal permanent resident status, legal employment authorization, and eligibility for naturalized citizenship.
Bound by the statutory national quota of visas per country annually from until .
Represents the numerically smallest cohort of Mexican migrants residing in the United States due to strict legal ceilings.
Commuter Visa:
Requires formal application, security checks, and fee payments in Mexico.
Permits individuals to reside permanently in Mexican border municipalities while crossing the border daily to work in the United States.
Highly desired by hundreds of thousands of Mexican workers because United States wage scales drastically outpace those in northern Mexico.
Distinctly advantageous to United States employers and local economies: domestic businesses extract cheap labor while the state assumes no civic responsibilities, as commuter workers cannot vote, cannot own land or domestic real property, cannot obtain employment authorization for their spouses, and cannot enroll their children in domestic public schools.
Fosters zero assimilation into American civil society because laborers return nightly to Mexico.
Border Crosser Visa:
Modeled after the temporary labor mechanisms of the Bracero Program, functioning as a non-immigrant, fixed-duration work permit issued for intervals of , , , or a maximum aggregate of .
Precludes circular migration: departing the United States automatically invalidates the visa, forcing workers to remain within the country for the entirety of the contract.
Prohibits the migration of dependent families, because minor children cannot legally work under domestic labor laws; this institutional framework recreates an isolated "bachelor society" analogous to early nineteenth-century Chinese migration.
Applies nationwide rather than strictly to border zones: laborers utilize ground transit and commercial aviation to work across the interior, including destinations such as Chicago, Florida, North Dakota, and the northern border of Maine.
Undocumented Entry:
Represents the smallest numerical category among the four primary pathways of modern Mexican entry.
While individuals may acquire undocumented status by birth to undocumented parents, the overwhelming majority enter the country legally through temporary visas or border crosser permits.
Undocumented status is primarily acquired via visa overstay (e.g., failing to depart upon the expiration of a short-term visa after ) rather than through unauthorized physical border crossings across fences or the Rio Grande.
Questions & Discussion
Question: What were the economic conditions of the United States during the ?
Response: The United States economy was exceptionally strong, earning the period the nickname the "Roaring Twenties." Following World War I, the United States was the primary industrial power operating with an intact, functional domestic infrastructure while the rest of the world lay destroyed. The nation achieved the lowest unemployment rates recorded up to that point, fostering the widespread societal belief in the American Dream—the economic expectation that tomorrow would always be stable and children would out-earn their parents.
Question: What caused the economic collapse of the , and what was its impact on employment?
Response: The stock market crash of ended the economic boom and initiated the Great Depression. National unemployment reached a historic peak of , meaning that out of every people able and desiring to work was unemployed. In accordance with economic scapegoating patterns, the public and the state blamed immigrant laborers, focusing specifically on Mexicans.
Question: What is the meaning and social implication of "repatriation"?
Response: Repatriation literally denotes deportation or returning individuals to their country of origin. However, under the Mexican Repatriation Program (), the state expelled over people to Mexico, approximately half of whom were native-born United States citizens who had never lived in Mexico.
Question: What does the term machismo signify in the context of racial stereotypes?
Response: It represents an exaggerated, hyper-masculinized sexualization and aggression. The media weaponized this concept against Mexican men, depicting them as domestic abusers who mistreated women and children, could not manage alcohol consumption, and constantly engaged in barroom brawls, mirroring nineteenth-century stereotypes assigned to Irish immigrants.
Question: What was the geographic reach of workers holding border crosser visas, and what was the farthest known destination they reached?
Response: Border crosser laborers were not confined to the southwestern border; they were transported wherever manual labor was required across the United States, including Florida, Chicago, and North Dakota. The northernmost known destination of border crosser workers was the northern border of the state of Maine.
Question: Are individuals holding border crosser visas permitted to travel by commercial air transit?
Response: Yes. The term "border crosser" is a misnomer with negative connotations; holders of these legal visas are permitted to travel via commercial aircraft to their work destinations and are not required to walk across border checkpoints.
Question: How do the majority of undocumented immigrants establish undocumented status in the United States?
Response: While an individual can be born undocumented, the predominant pathway for undocumented immigrants—Mexican or otherwise—is visa overstay. The majority enter the United States with a legally valid entry or border crosser visa, but remain in the country after the authorized period expires rather than returning to their nation of origin.