Comprehensive Study Guide: Occupational Health and Safety Act (LSST)
Statutory Framework: LSST (OHSA) vs. LSPAAT (WSIA)
Legislative Relationship and Purpose:
The Occupational Health and Safety Act (Loi sur la santé et sécurité au travail — LSST) and the Workplace Safety and Insurance Act, 1997 (Loi de 1997 sur la sécurité professionnelle et l’assurance contre les accidents de travail — LSPAAT) represent two distinct but complementary statutory frameworks governing Ontario workplaces.
LSST (OHSA): Focuses primarily on preventative standards, duties of workplace parties, internal responsibility systems, hazard identification, and regulatory enforcement to prevent illness and injuries.
LSPAAT (WSIA): Operates primarily as an insurance and compensation system designed to support injured workers, manage rehabilitation, and facilitate return to work following an accident or occupational disease.
The Three Fundamental Rights of Workers
Foundational Pillars: Workplace health and safety legislation in Ontario establishes three core rights for workers:
Right to Know (Droit de connaître):
Workers have the inherent legal right to be informed about actual and potential dangers, hazards, and toxic substances associated with their work.
Right to Participate (Droit de participer):
Workers have the right to actively participate in workplace health and safety initiatives.
Key avenues of participation include asking questions, directly reporting hazards to supervisors and employers, and participating in or serving on the Joint Health and Safety Committee (JHSC / Comité mixte sur la santé et la sécurité au travail — CMSST).
Right to Refuse (Droit de refuser):
Workers have the explicit legal right to refuse to perform work that they reasonably believe to be dangerous or unsafe to themselves or others without fear of reprisal.
Classification and Manifestations of Workplace Accidents
Typology of Accidents and Hazards: Under workplace safety law, a workplace accident or occupational illness encompasses a broad spectrum of incidents, risks, and health hazards:
Slip Hazards: Slipping on surfaces that are icy, oily, or wet.
Trip Hazards: Tripping caused by inadequate or defective lighting, clutter, or excessive workplace obstruction.
Falls from Heights: Falling from elevated positions such as ladders, scaffolds, staging, roofs, or raised platforms.
Ergonomic and Musculoskeletal Injuries: Improper lifting techniques when handling heavy loads, as well as prolonged adverse ergonomics during seated or sedentary desk work (e.g., prolonged computer usage).
Structural Collapses: Structural failures or collapses of temporary and permanent frameworks, buildings, or retaining structures.
Impact Injuries: Being struck by falling or moving objects on the head or any other body part.
Toxic and Chemical Exposures: Inhalation, absorption, ingestion, or direct contact with harmful chemicals, hazardous materials, or contaminated atmospheres.
Workplace Violence and Harassment: Incidents of psychological harassment, sexual harassment, threats, or physical violence occurring in the workplace.
Electrical Hazards: Electrocution, electrical burns, and arc flashes.
High-Risk Equipment Misuse: Improper, negligent, or uncertified operation of equipment characterized by a high risk of bodily harm.
Occupational Diseases: Work-related chronic conditions and diseases resulting from environmental or airborne exposures, such as asbestosis (amiantose).
Regulatory Compliance and Financial Penalties: Case Jurisprudence
Legal Imperative of Compliance:
Workers, supervisors, constructors, and employers are all legally obligated to adhere to the LSST.
Failure to uphold statutory responsibilities carries significant legal exposure, including crippling monetary fines and potential terms of imprisonment.
Representative Judicial Enforcement Penalties:
Leamington Case: A workplace fatality resulted in combined fines totaling imposed on two separate employers.
Bradford Case: A workplace fatality resulted in a fine of imposed on a corporate operating entity.
London Case: A workplace fatality resulted in a fine of levied against an enterprise for non-compliance.
Statutory Duties of Employers (OHSA Section 25)
General Equipment and Structural Standards — Section 25 (1):
An employer must ensure that:
Prescribed equipment, materials, and protective devices are provided (s. 25 (1)(a)).
The equipment, materials, and protective devices provided are maintained in good condition (s. 25 (1)(b)).
The personal protective clothing and devices provided, worn, or used are properly fitted and appropriate in the circumstances, taking into account all relevant factors, including any factors that may be prescribed (s. 25 (1)(b.1)).
The prescribed measures and procedures are carried out and observed in the workplace (s. 25 (1)(c)).
The equipment, materials, and protective devices provided are utilized in the prescribed manner (s. 25 (1)(d)).
Any building, structure, or part of a building, structure, or workplace — whether temporary or permanent — is capable of supporting any loads that may be applied to it, in accordance with:
The applicable requirements of the building code in force at the time of construction (s. 25 (1)(e)(i));
Other prescribed requirements (s. 25 (1)(e)(ii)); or
Sound and recognized engineering practices, if subclauses (i) and (ii) do not apply (s. 25 (1)(e)(iii)).
Legislative History: R.S.O. 1990, c. O.1, s. 25 (1); 2011, c. 11, s. 9; 2024, c. 41, Sched. 3, s. 8.
Supervisory, Informational, and Procedural Duties — Section 25 (2):
Without limiting the duties imposed by subsection (1), an employer must:
Provide workers with information, instruction, and supervision necessary to protect worker health and safety (s. 25 (2)(a)).
In a medical emergency, provide on request, for purposes of diagnosis or treatment, any information in their possession (including confidential trade information) to a legally qualified medical practitioner and other prescribed persons (s. 25 (2)(b)).
Appoint a competent person when filling supervisory roles (s. 25 (2)(c)).
Acquaint workers or persons with authority over workers with the hazards inherent to the work and the handling, storage, use, disposal, and transport of any article, device, equipment, or biological, chemical, or physical agent (s. 25 (2)(d)).
Afford assistance and full co-operation to the joint health and safety committee and safety representatives during the performance of their statutory functions (s. 25 (2)(e)).
Employ in or near the workplace only persons who meet or exceed the prescribed minimum working age (s. 25 (2)(f)).
Refrain from knowingly permitting an underage person to be in or near the workplace (s. 25 (2)(g)).
Take every precaution reasonable in the circumstances for the protection of a worker (the general duty clause) (s. 25 (2)(h)).
Post in a conspicuous workplace location or provide in an easily accessible electronic format, in English and the language of the majority of workers, a copy of the Act and explanatory ministry materials outlining worker rights, responsibilities, and duties (s. 25 (2)(i)).
Prepare a written occupational health and safety policy, review it at least once a year, and establish and maintain an ongoing program to implement that policy (s. 25 (2)(j)).
Conspicuously display or electronically make available a copy of the occupational health and safety policy (s. 25 (2)(k)).
Provide the committee or health and safety representative with the findings and relevant sections of any occupational health and safety reports in the employer's possession (s. 25 (2)(l)).
Notify workers of the findings of safety reports and make copies of the relevant sections available upon request (s. 25 (2)(m)).
Promptly notify the Director if a committee or safety representative identifies structural inadequacies in any permanent or temporary building, structure, or part of the workplace that could endanger workers (s. 25 (2)(n)).
Legislative History: R.S.O. 1990, c. O.1, s. 25 (2); 2017, c. 34, Sched. 30, s. 1 (1); 2024, c. 19, Sched. 4, s. 6.
Direct Assumption of Supervisory Duties — Section 25 (3):
For the purposes of clause (2)(c), an employer who is competent may personally assume the duties and responsibilities of a supervisor (s. 25 (3)).
Legislative History: R.S.O. 1990, c. O.1, s. 25 (3).
Statutory Duties of Supervisors (OHSA Section 27)
Supervisory Oversight — Section 27 (1):
A supervisor must ensure that every worker:
Works in the manner and utilizes the protective devices, measures, and procedures required by the Act and associated regulations (s. 27 (1)(a)).
Employs or wears the protective equipment, personal protective devices, or clothing mandated by the employer (s. 27 (1)(b)).
Additional Supervisory Responsibilities — Section 27 (2):
Without limiting subsection (1), a supervisor must:
Inform the worker of any actual or potential danger to health or safety of which the supervisor is aware (s. 27 (2)(a)).
Where prescribed, provide the worker with written instructions regarding protective procedures and measures (s. 27 (2)(b)).
Take every precaution reasonable in the circumstances for the protection of a worker (s. 27 (2)(c)).
Legislative History: R.S.O. 1990, c. O.1, s. 27.
Statutory Duties and Prohibitions for Workers (OHSA Section 28)
Mandatory Worker Actions — Section 28 (1):
A worker must:
Work in full compliance with the provisions of the Act and the regulations (s. 28 (1)(a)).
Use or wear the equipment, protective devices, or clothing required by the employer (s. 28 (1)(b)).
Report to the employer or supervisor the absence of or any defect in any equipment or protective device that could endanger the worker or others (s. 28 (1)(c)).
Report to the employer or supervisor any known infraction of the Act or regulations, or the presence of any known workplace hazard (s. 28 (1)(d)).
Worker Prohibitions and Unsafe Conduct — Section 28 (2):
A worker must not:
Remove or render ineffective any safety or protective device required by the regulations or employer, unless an adequate temporary protective device is substituted; once the need for removal ends, the original protective device must be replaced immediately (s. 28 (2)(a)).
Operate or use any machinery, device, apparatus, or item, or work in a manner that endangers themselves or any other worker (s. 28 (2)(b)).
Engage in pranks, practical jokes, unnecessary contests, feats of strength, unauthorized races, or boisterous and violent conduct (s. 28 (2)(c)).
Offences, Sanctions, and Penalties (OHSA Part IX, Section 66)
General Penalties for Individuals — Section 66 (1):
Subject to subsections (2) and (2.1), any person who contravenes or fails to comply with the Act, regulations, an order or requirement of an inspector or Director, or an order of the Minister, is guilty of an offence.
Upon conviction, the individual is liable to:
A fine not exceeding ;
Imprisonment for a term of up to months; or
Both fine and imprisonment simultaneously.
Legislative History: R.S.O. 1990, c. O.1, s. 66 (1); 2017, c. 34, Sched. 30, s. 4 (1); 2022, c. 7, Sched. 4, s. 2 (1).
Maximum Fines for Corporations — Section 66 (2):
If a corporation is convicted of an offence under subsection (1), the maximum fine that may be imposed is .
Legislative History: 2022, c. 7, Sched. 4, s. 2 (2); 2023, c. 15, Sched. 5, s. 1.
Liability of Corporate Officers and Directors — Section 66 (2.1):
Any director or officer of a corporation who contravenes or fails to comply with Section 32 is guilty of an offence.
Upon conviction, an officer or director is liable to:
A fine of up to ;
Imprisonment for a term of up to months; or
Both fine and imprisonment.
Legislative History: 2022, c. 7, Sched. 4, s. 2 (2).
Aggravating Circumstances in Sentencing (Section 66 (2.2))
Statutory Criteria for Determining Penalties: For the purpose of sentencing, the court considers each of the following elements to be an aggravating circumstance:
Severe Outcome: The offence resulted in the death of a worker, or caused serious injury or serious illness.
Recklessness: The defendant committed the violation recklessly.
Disregard of Orders: The defendant ignored, defied, or neglected an inspector’s order.
Prior Convictions: The defendant has previous convictions under this Act or under any other statute.
Prior Contraventions: The defendant has a documented history of contravening the Act or its regulations.
Lack of Remorse: The defendant exhibits no remorse or contrition.
Moral Blameworthiness: The conduct involves a distinct element of moral culpability.
Financial Motive: In committing the offence, the defendant was motivated by financial gain (e.g., increasing revenues or cutting operational costs).
Obstruction and Concealment: Following the offence, the defendant:
Attempted to conceal or hide the commission of the offence from the Ministry or other public authorities; or
Failed to co-operate with Ministry inspectors or public regulatory bodies.
Prescribed Circumstances: Any other circumstance legally prescribed by regulation as an aggravating circumstance.
Legislative History: 2022, c. 7, Sched. 4, s. 2 (2).
Statutory Due Diligence Defence (Section 66 (3))
Burden and Scope of Reasonable Precaution:
The accused may present a valid legal defence by demonstrating that every precaution reasonable in the circumstances was actively taken (due diligence).
This statutory defence applies strictly against charges alleging non-compliance with:
Subsection 23 (1);
Clauses 25 (1)(b), 25 (1)(c), or 25 (1)(d); or
Subsection 27 (1).
Legislative History: R.S.O. 1990, c. O.1, s. 66 (3).