Attitudes and Job Satisfaction Study Notes

Components of Attitudes

  • Definition of Attitudes: Evaluative statements—either favorable or unfavorable—concerning objects, people, or events. They reflect how an individual feels about something.
  • The Three Components of an Attitude (Exhibit 3-1):
    • Cognitive Component (Evaluation): The opinion or belief segment of an attitude. Example: "My supervisor gave a promotion to a coworker who deserved it less than I did. My supervisor is unfair."
    • Affective Component (Feeling): The emotional or feeling segment of an attitude. Example: "I dislike my supervisor!"
    • Behavioral Component (Action): An intention to behave in a specific way toward someone or something. Example: "I'm looking for other work; I've complained about my supervisor to anyone who would listen."
  • Interconnectedness: Affect, behavior, and cognition are closely interrelated. Evaluative thoughts (cognition) feed into emotional reactions (affect), which lead to concrete behavioral intentions or actions (behavior), culminating in an overall negative attitude toward a target.

Exhibit 3-1 The Components of an Attitude

Relationship Between Attitudes and Behavior

  • Attitude-Behavior Link: Traditional views hold that the attitudes people possess directly determine their actions.
  • Cognitive Dissonance Theory (Leon Festinger):
    • Cases where behavior precedes or alters attitude illustrate the effects of cognitive dissonance.
    • Cognitive Dissonance: Any incompatibility or inconsistency an individual perceives between two or more attitudes, or between behavior and attitudes.
    • Individuals naturally desire consistency among their attitudes and between their attitudes and their behavior, actively taking steps to reduce dissonance when it occurs.
  • Mitigating / Moderating Variables:
    • Attitude's importance
    • Correspondence to specific behavior
    • Accessibility in memory
    • Presence of social pressures
    • Direct personal experience with the attitude
  • Impact of Direct Experience: The relationship between an attitude and behavior is significantly stronger when the attitude stems from direct personal experience.

Mitigating Variables in Attitude-Behavior Relationship

Major Job Attitudes

  • Job Satisfaction: A positive feeling about a job resulting from a thorough evaluation of its characteristics.
  • Job Involvement:
    • The degree to which a person identifies psychologically with a job, actively participates in it, and considers perceived performance levels important to self-worth.
    • Psychological Empowerment: Employees' belief in the degree to which they affect their work environment, their competence, the meaningfulness of their job, and their perceived autonomy in their work.
  • Organizational Commitment:
    • The degree to which an employee identifies with a particular organization and its goals, wishing to maintain membership in the organization.
    • Committed employees exhibit lower rates of work withdrawal, even when dissatisfied, because of a deep sense of organizational loyalty.
  • Perceived Organizational Support (POS):
    • The degree to which employees believe that the organization values their contributions and genuinely cares about their well-being.
    • POS is higher when rewards are allocated fairly, employees participate in decision-making processes, and supervisors are viewed as supportive.
    • POS is especially critical in national cultures characterized by low power distance.
  • Employee Engagement:
    • An individual's involvement with, satisfaction with, and enthusiasm for the work they perform.
    • Highly engaged employees demonstrate high passion for their work and a strong connection to their company.
  • Distinctiveness of Job Attitudes: Major job attitudes are highly interrelated and share significant theoretical and empirical overlap, which can occasionally lead to confusion, though each captures distinct aspects of the work experience.

Defining and Measuring Job Satisfaction

  • Definition: A positive feeling about a job resulting from an evaluation of its key characteristics.
  • Two Popular Measurement Approaches:
    • Single Global Rating: Asking individuals to respond to one overall question (e.g., "All things considered, how satisfied are you with your job?").
    • Summation of Job Facets: Identifying core job elements (nature of the work, supervision, current pay, promotional opportunities, relations with coworkers) and rating each on a standardized scale to create an aggregate satisfaction score.
  • Worst Jobs of 2016 for Job Satisfaction (Evaluated by physical demands, work environment, income, stress, and hiring outlook; Source: CareerCast.com, 2016):
    • Newspaper reporter: $37,200 full-year income
    • Logger: $35,160 full-year income
    • Broadcaster: $37,200 full-year income
    • Disc jockey: $29,010 full-year income
    • Enlisted military: $27,936 full-year income
    • Pest control worker: $30,660 full-year income
    • Retail salesperson: $21,670 full-year income
    • Advertising salesperson: $47,890 full-year income
    • Taxi driver: $23,210 full-year income
    • Firefighter: $45,970 full-year income

Exhibit 3-2 Worst Jobs of 2016 for Job Satisfaction

Global and Facet-Based Job Satisfaction Levels

  • General Trends:
    • Over the past 30 years, workers in the United States and most developed nations have reported high overall job satisfaction.
    • Economic downturns lead to marked drops in worker satisfaction levels.
    • Satisfaction scores vary considerably depending on the specific job facet being measured.
    • Clear cultural variations exist across international boundaries.
  • Satisfaction by Facet (Exhibit 3-3):
    • Overall Job Satisfaction: ~78%
    • Work Itself: ~77%
    • Coworkers: ~69%
    • Supervision: ~65%
    • Pay: ~57%
    • Promotion Opportunities: ~21%

Exhibit 3-3 Average Job Satisfaction Levels by Facet

  • Average Employee Job Satisfaction Levels by Country (Exhibit 3-4) (Source: J. H. Westover, Journal of Management & Organization, 2013):
    • Mexico: 5.88
    • Switzerland: 5.72
    • Norway: 5.63
    • Denmark: 5.51
    • United States: 5.46
    • Japan: 5.45
    • Germany: 5.44
    • Sweden: 5.30
    • Great Britain: 5.27
    • Canada: 5.24
    • Russia: 5.22
    • Australia: 5.18
    • Czech Republic: 5.16
    • France: 4.89
    • South Korea: 4.76

Exhibit 3-4 Average Levels of Employee Job Satisfaction by Country

Causes of Job Satisfaction

  • Job Conditions:
    • The intrinsic nature of the work itself, positive social interactions, and high-quality supervision represent the most crucial predictors of overall satisfaction and employee well-being.
  • Personality and Core Self-Evaluations (CSE):
    • Core Self-Evaluations: Bottom-line conclusions individuals hold regarding their capabilities, competence, and overall self-worth.
    • People with positive core self-evaluations are substantially more satisfied with their jobs than those with negative core self-evaluations.
  • Pay and Financial Compensation:
    • Pay correlates with job satisfaction and general happiness up to a threshold of comfortable living, beyond which the relationship flattens.
    • Meta-analytic findings by T. A. Judge et al. (2010) show a weak overall relationship between average job pay (ranging from $20,000 to $160,000 in 2009 US$) and the percentage of job satisfaction scale maximum achieved by employees.

Exhibit 3-5 Relationship between Average Pay in Job and Job Satisfaction

  • Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR):
    • Definition: Self-regulated organizational actions aimed at benefiting society or the environment beyond standard legal mandates.
    • Encompasses environmental sustainability projects, nonprofit partner work, and community charitable giving.
    • CSR initiatives play an increasing role in employee job satisfaction, especially among Millennials, though individual employee appreciation for CSR varies.

Outcomes of Job Satisfaction

  • Job Performance: Satisfied and happy workers exhibit higher productivity levels.
  • Organizational Citizenship Behavior (OCB): Satisfied employees are significantly more inclined to engage in discretionary, helpful workplace behaviors that extend beyond formal duties.
  • Customer Satisfaction: High employee job satisfaction directly enhances customer satisfaction and loyalty.
  • Life Satisfaction: Job satisfaction demonstrates a strong positive correlation with overall life satisfaction.

Four Employee Responses to Dissatisfaction

  • Framework Dimensions (Exhibit 3-6):
    • Constructive vs. Destructive: Whether the response aims to solve the problem or worsen conditions.
    • Active vs. Passive: Whether the response involves direct behavioral action or passive waiting.
  • Specific Response Types:
    • Voice (Active + Constructive): Actively and constructively attempting to improve conditions, including making suggestions, discussing issues with managers, or participating in union actions.
    • Exit (Active + Destructive): Behavior targeted at leaving the organization, including searching for new employment or resigning.
    • Loyalty (Passive + Constructive): Passively but optimistically waiting for conditions to improve, including defending the organization against external criticism and trusting management.
    • Neglect (Passive + Destructive): Passively allowing work conditions to deteriorate through chronic absenteeism, lateness, reduced effort, and increased error rates.

Exhibit 3-6 Responses to Dissatisfaction

  • Counterproductive Work Behavior (CWB):
    • Actions that deliberately damage the organization, including theft, physical or verbal aggression toward coworkers, unexcused tardiness, or absenteeism.
    • Absenteeism: There is a clear negative correlation with job satisfaction; higher satisfaction reduces missed workdays.
    • Turnover: A consistent trajectory of declining job satisfaction is the single best predictor of an employee's intention to quit.
  • Managerial Misalignment: Managers frequently misunderstand or underestimate employee dissatisfaction and its operational impacts.

Managerial Implications

  • Predictive Value: Among major job attitudes (job satisfaction, job involvement, organizational commitment, POS, and employee engagement), an employee's job satisfaction level serves as the single best predictor of workplace behavior.
  • Performance and Retention Monitoring: Managers should closely monitor job satisfaction as a key determinant of employee performance, turnover, absenteeism, and withdrawal behaviors.
  • Objective Measurement: Job attitudes should be assessed objectively and at consistent intervals to evaluate employee reactions to workplace practices.
  • Job Design: To elevate employee satisfaction, evaluate alignment between individual work interests and the intrinsic features of their roles to build challenging and engaging work.
  • Compensation Strategy: High pay alone is unlikely to establish or sustain a truly satisfying work environment.