Group Formation Notes

Formation

Who Joins Groups?

  • Sets of Influences: Group formation is influenced by personal qualities, the nature of the situation, and liking for each other.
  • Individual Differences: People differ in personality, motivations, past experiences, and expectations, which influence their interest in joining groups.

Personality

  • Definition: Personality is the configuration of distinctive but enduring dispositional characteristics, including traits, temperament, and values, that characterize an individual’s responses across situations.
  • The Five-Factor Model: Identifies five key traits that structure and sustain enduring consistencies in outlook, action, and disposition:
    • Extraversion
    • Agreeableness
    • Conscientiousness
    • Neuroticism
    • Openness
  • Extraversion and Agreeableness: Predict general sociability. Extraverts tend to be happier than introverts.
  • Openness: Influences the type of groups individuals seek to join.

The Five-Factor Model (The Big 5)

  • Extraversion:
    • Extraverted: talkative, enthusiastic, bold, energetic
    • Introverted: reserved, quiet, unsociable, withdrawn
  • Agreeableness:
    • Agreeable: sympathetic, warm, kind, cooperative
    • Disagreeable: cold, unsympathetic, critical, quarrelsome
  • Conscientiousness:
    • Conscientious: organized, efficient, systematic, practical
    • Careless: disorganized, sloppy, inefficient, careless
  • Neuroticism:
    • Neurotic: moody, anxious, temperamental, easily upset
    • Stable: content, relaxed, calm, emotionally stable
  • Openness to Experience:
    • Open: creative, imaginative, complex, intelligent
    • Closed: uncreative, unintellectual, conventional, unimaginative

Sex Differences in Group Engagement

  • Sex differences in group engagement are relatively minor.
  • Relationality: Women tend to be higher than men in relationality.
  • Group Preferences: Women seek membership in smaller, informal, intimate groups, whereas men seek membership in larger, more formal, task-focused groups.
  • Influences: These differences are likely due, in part, to sex roles and sexism.

Social Motives

  • The strength of social motives such as the need for affiliation, the need for intimacy, and the need for power also predict one’s group-joining proclivities.
  • Byrne’s Studies: Relationship between need for affiliation and rejection sensitivity.
  • Schutz’s FIRO Theory: Fundamental Interpersonal Relations Orientation (FIRO) theory explains how people use groups to satisfy their need to receive and express inclusion (affiliation), control (power), and affection (intimacy).

Shyness and Social Anxiety

  • Shyness: The dispositional tendency to feel uneasy, uncomfortable, and awkward in social situations (Zimbardo, 1977).
    • Less likely to join groups
    • Tend to form associations with other shy individuals
    • More comfortable in activity-focused groups such as sports and academic groups
  • Social Anxiety: Feeling of apprehension and embarrassment experienced when anticipating or actually interacting with other people, causing them to disaffiliate.

Attachment Style

  • One’s characteristic approach to relationships with other people.
    • Pre-occupied: Seek out membership but worry excessively about rejection (high anxiety, low avoidance).
    • Fearful: So insecure about themselves that they fear rejection (high anxiety, high avoidance).
    • Secure: Self-confident and willing to rely on others (low anxiety, low avoidance).
    • Dismissing: Uninterested in joining groups (low anxiety, high avoidance).

Additional Factors Influencing Group Membership

  • Individuals who are socially inhibited, shy, and anxious are less likely to join groups.
  • People’s attitudes, experiences, and expectations are all factors that influence their decision to join groups.
  • Prior Experiences: Individuals who had prior positive experiences in groups tended to seek out further group memberships.
  • Social Movement Participation: Two key factors that influence participation in a social movement are sense of injustice and angry emotions.

When Do People Seek Out Others?

  • Festinger’s theory of social comparison: Assumes that affiliation is more likely when individuals find themselves in ambiguous, frightening, and difficult circumstances.
  • Schacter’s Findings: When putting people into a threatening situation, found that they affiliated with others rather than remain alone.
  • Preferences: People prefer to affiliate with individuals who likely have useful information about a situation and others who are in a similar situation.
  • Embarrassment: When people worry that they will be embarrassed when they join a group, they usually do not affiliate with others.

Social Support from Groups

  • Groups provide their members with social support during times of stress and tension.
  • Basic Types of Support:
    • Inclusion and emotional
    • Informational
    • Instrumental
    • Spiritual support
  • Health Consequences: Group support buffers the negative health consequences of stress, possibly by triggering improved autoimmune and reward system functioning.
  • Comparison Targets:
    • By choosing comparison targets who are performing poorly compared to themselves, individuals bolster their own sense of competence.
    • By choosing superior targets, individuals refine their expectations of themselves.

Types of Support Groups Provide

  • Inclusive Support: Acceptance, reassurance of belonging, including in group activities
  • Informational Support: Way to perform a task, problem-solving, advice, direction, suggestions
  • Emotional Support: Respect and approval, listening, sharing feelings, encouragement
  • Spiritual Support: Explaining challenging events, sharing faith, reconfirming one’s worldview, allaying existential faith, fear of death
  • Instrumental Support: Doing favors, lending money or possessions, assisting with work/duties, transporting, providing a place to stay

Processes of Formation

  • Proximity
  • Elaboration principle
  • Similarity
  • Complementarity
  • Reciprocity
  • Minimax principle
  • Comparison level and comparison level for alternatives

Detailed Explanation of Formation Processes

  • Proximity: (Physical distance) people tend to like those who are situated nearby.
  • Elaboration: Groups often emerge when additional elements (people) become linked to the original members.
  • Similarity: Most groups tend toward increasing levels of homophily.
  • Complementarity: Liking others who qualities are different but useful when combined with one’s attributes or characteristics.
  • Reciprocity: Liking tends to be mutual.
  • Minimax Principle: Individuals are attracted to groups that offer them maximum rewards and minimum costs.