Conservatism: An Overview of Key Concepts and Thinkers

Conservatism

Critique of Locke: David Hume

  • Hume’s Theory: In his work Treatise on Human Nature (1740), David Hume presents a critical view of John Locke's stance on human reason and morality.
    • Rejection of Morality: Hume argues that morality is not inherent in human nature as Locke believed. Instead, it arises from social customs, traditions, and conventions, evolving over time through society's collective experiences.
    • Role of Reason: He claims that reason serves merely to indicate how to achieve specific goals rather than determining whether those goals are moral or ethical.
  • Kant’s Influence: Immanuel Kant famously professed, "Out of the crooked timber of humanity, no straight thing was ever made," suggesting a fundamental skepticism about human nature.

Classical Conservatism: Edmund Burke

  • Burke’s Perspective: In Reflections on the French Revolution (1790), Edmund Burke articulates the conservative ethos centered around stability and order within society.
    • Government’s Role: He posits that the primary objective of government is to maintain peace and stability; changes should occur gradually rather than disruptively.
    • Respect for Tradition: Institutions that have withstood the test of time should be respected for their functional value and contribution to societal stability.
  • Cautions Against Revolution: Burke warns against radical political experiments and social upheavals that could lead to chaos, advocating for a conservativism that prioritizes gradual evolution over revolutionary change.

Burke (Continued)

  • Conservative Organicism: Burke emphasizes that communities, along with their historical institutions, play a crucial role in shaping individual identities and societal origins.
  • Social Hierarchy: He argues that inequality and a social hierarchy are intrinsic to human society due to inherent diversities and imperfections.
    • Political Influence: Burke believes that individuals with property and wealth should possess greater influence in politics, as their opinions are deemed vital for the nation's welfare.

Modern Conservatism

  • Disposition vs. Ideology: Modern conservatism is characterized more as a disposition than a rigid ideology, valuing familiarity, caution, and practicality.
    • Unique Values: Unlike universalistic ideologies, modern conservatism appreciates values and norms specific to individual communities and nations.
  • Nationalism and Tradition: Central to modern conservatism are appeals to nationalism and patriotism, aimed at garnering support from non-elite groups.
    • Support for Liberal Values: It aligns with liberal principles of free markets and limited government while emphasizing law, order, religion, and family, generally resisting radical social reform or wealth redistribution.

Neo-Liberalism: Hayek and Friedman

  • Economic Perspective: Economists Friedrich Hayek and Milton Friedman argue that the welfare state hinders individual freedom and initiative; wealth redistribution undermines prosperity.
    • Advocacy for Smaller Government: They advocate for reduced governmental roles, lower taxes, and cuts to social programs to restore free market functions.
  • Influence on Conservative Thought: Neo-liberal ideologies gained significant traction within conservative discourses during the 1970s, heavily influencing the Reagan (USA) and Thatcher (UK) policies in the 1980s.

Libertarianism

  • Core Tenets: Libertarians, viewed as extreme neo-liberals, prioritize maximizing individual freedoms and advocate for minimal state intervention.
    • Reject Welfare State: They call for dismantling the welfare state and advocate for laissez-faire capitalism and strong private property rights.
  • Government’s Role: Libertarianism supports strict law enforcement while granting individuals maximum autonomy as long as they do not harm others, alongside a robust military policy to promote free trade.

Social Conservatism/Religious Right

  • Traditional Values: Social conservatives oppose lifestyles and identities seen as threats to traditional institutions, especially family structures.
    • Opposition to Change: They resist movements such as feminism, abortion rights, LGBTQ+ rights, and drug decriminalization.
  • Active Faction: This group actively participates in modern conservative movements, with evangelical Christians representing a vital demographic in conservative politics.

Alt-Right Populism

  • Target Audience: Alt-Right Populism appeals to individuals who feel alienated and threatened by societal changes, especially increasing diversity.
    • Nostalgia for the Past: They seek to return to a perceived better past (e.g., "Make America Great Again") and are skeptical of established elites and institutions.
  • Characteristics: This movement is marked by its irrationality, distrust of science, and tendencies toward conspiracy theories.
    • Xenophobic Tendencies: There is a notable anti-immigrant sentiment and an inclination toward nationalism that can verge on racism and intolerance toward minorities.