Aggression and Prejudice Course Notes
AI vs. You: Debunking Psychological Myths
The Myth of Catharsis and Venting: * Venting activities such as punching a pillow, screaming, or going for a run are often believed to help get rid of anger. * Common results from student exercises show that the majority fall for the catharsis myth, believing these actions provide relief because they feel good in the moment. * Scientific psychology challenges these instincts; while venting feels like relief, it does not actually reduce anger. * AI vs. Human Understanding: 1. ChatGPT correctly identifies that venting doesn't work (the conclusion). 2. AI fails to provide the reasoning (the "why") or what should be done instead, leaving the user with surface-level knowledge rather than genuine understanding. 3. AI lacks depth: It may sound confident but often fails to mention foundational concepts like Freud's hydraulic model, catharsis theory, cognitive dissonance, or specific mechanisms explained in textbooks. 4. The Running Error: Most AI suggests going for a run helps with anger. The textbook challenges this: if someone runs while mentally replaying the source of their fury, they remain in an aroused state, "stewing" in their anger and potentially making it worse.
Defining and Categorizing Aggression
Definition of Aggression: Intentional behavior aimed at causing physical harm or psychological pain to another person.
Aggression vs. Assertiveness: It is important to distinguish between being aggressive (harm-oriented) and being assertive (standing one's ground without the intent to harm).
Hostile Aggression: Aggression stemming from feelings of anger and aimed at inflicting pain or injury.
Instrumental Aggression: Aggression used as a means to some goal other than causing pain (e.g., a football player tackling an opponent to get the ball).
Interaction Styles (Not in textbook): Understanding social interactions through categories of Passive, Aggressive, and Assertive.
Real-World Scenarios: * Hostile Scenario: Sara shouts at Sami, "That’s why no one really likes you…" and Sami runs to hit her. * Anonymity/Frustration Scenario: Driving on the from Sharjah to Dubai and having a car flash lights and tailgating (aggressive driving) without a personal provocation.
Evolutionary and Biological Roots of Aggression
Is Aggression Innate? Aggression is both innate and learned. Rat studies support the biological component.
Evolutionary Perspective: * Male Dominance: Established to achieve the highest position in the hierarchy. * Paternity/Jealousy: Ensuring a mate is not having sex with other men to guarantee paternity.
Gender and Aggression: * Men are socialized into non-playful aggression (pushing, shoving, hitting) from a young age. * Statistics: More than of all mass murderers (defined as killing at least four people in one location) are committed by men (Hillshafer, ). * Men are more likely to engage in spontaneous aggression and violent acts.
Testosterone: * Occurs in both sexes but is higher in males. * Prisoners who have committed violent crimes show higher levels of testosterone (Dabbs, ). * OFC Link: Testosterone is associated with reduced activity in the Orbitofrontal Cortex (OFC), which is critical for self-regulation and impulse control.
Pinker (): Argues we live in a less violent time than in the past. Aggressive acts like war, crime, torture, and murder have been declining over centuries compared to the eras of Vikings, slavery, and gladiators.
Social and Cultural Influences on Aggression
Culture of Honor: * Herders vs. Farmers: Herders are more vulnerable to theft (loss of livelihood) and develop more aggressive responses to protect property. Farmers must develop cooperative strategies for survival. * Nisbett (): Economic circumstances are directly associated with higher rates of violence.
Gender Similarities: Female aggression often stems from protecting offspring/family. The difference in willingness to inflict harm between sexes disappears when both feel justified and provoked.
Relational Aggression: Harming another person through the manipulation of relationships. * Women are more likely to be perpetrators. * Examples: Backbiting, shunning, or spreading false rumors.
Social-Cognitive Learning Theory
Albert Bandura: Developed the theory that people learn social behavior (both positive like altruism and negative like aggression) through observation and imitation.
The Bobo Doll Experiment: * Research Question: Will watching an aggressive model cause children to behave aggressively? * Independent Variable (IV): Child’s exposure to an aggressive model (Adult hitting/hammering a plastic air-filled "Bobo" doll) vs. a control condition (no exposure). * Dependent Variable (DV): The child's subsequent aggression. * Results: Children in the experimental group imitated the adults' exact abusive actions. Children in the control group almost never showed aggression.
Physiological and Environmental Influences
Alcohol: * Acts as a disinhibitor, lowering the "muscle" that prevents impulsive acts contrary to social norms. * Reduces anxiety and disrupts information processing (focusing on the obvious rather than nuances). * "Think Drink" Effect: Expectations about the effects of alcohol influence behavior more than the actual amount consumed.
Pain and Discomfort: * Pain: Animals (rats, mice, monkeys, etc.) will attack members of their own species or even inanimate objects (tennis balls) if in pain and unable to flee. * Discomfort: Heat, humidity, air pollution, and offensive odors increase aggression. * The Long, Hot Summer: Research (Hsiang et al., ) shows a correlation between rising temperatures and increased aggression/conflict.
Frustration-Aggression Theory
Definition: The idea that frustration—the perception of being prevented from attaining a goal—increases the probability of an aggressive response.
Factors Influencing Frustration: * Goal Proximity: The closer you are to a goal, the more frustration is felt if blocked. Harris () found people cutting in the place in line elicited more aggression than cutting in front of the person. * Unexpectedness: More unexpected frustration leads to higher aggression.
Clarifications: Frustration doesn't always lead to aggression; it increases anger and readiness for it.
Mitigating Factors: Aggression is reduced if the frustration is understandable, legitimate, or unintentional.
Sexual Assault and Media Violence
Definitions: * Rape: Penetration of any part of the body with another body part or object. * Sexual Assault: A broader term where lack of consent is the key criterion.
Statistics: of all rapes or attempted rapes are acquaintance rape.
The "High-Status" Myth: Textbooks often suggest sexual violence is committed by high-status men (athletes, celebrities) who equate power with sexuality. However, the Dominique Gisele Pelicot Case (where men including soldiers, nurses, truck drivers, journalists, and prison wardens were accused) shows that sexual assault is committed by men across all social statuses.
Sexual Scripts: Implicit rules and norms (based on gender, culture, religion) that constitute proper sexual behavior.
Media Effects: * Watching violence increases aggressive behavior, thoughts, and hostility. * Numbing Effect: Media violence numbs people to difficult events and increases indifference toward victims. * Longitudinal Evidence: A study of families over showed that TV watching in adolescence predicted adult violence.
Blaming the Victim and Anger Management
Blaming the Victim: Participants who harm innocent people often derogate them to convince themselves the victim deserved it. This makes it easier to inflict further harm.
Parenting: Modeling is key. Parents losing their temper at a child's meltdown models the very aggressive behavior they seek to stop.
Punishment: To work, punishment must be swift and certain, which is difficult to achieve in practice.
Healthy Display of Anger: Avoid shouting and venting; instead, focus on naming, describing, and soothing emotions.
Apologies: A real apology requires a heartfelt tone, acceptance of responsibility, and remorse. Avoid the "I am sorry, but…" phrasing which justifies behavior.
Prejudice: The Three Components
Definition: A hostile or negative attitude toward people in a distinguishable group based solely on their membership in that group.
Cognitive Component (Stereotypes): Simplified rules of thumb to understand people. * Adaptive: Identifying group attributes accurately. * Maladaptive: Blinding us to individual differences. * Hostile Sexism: Viewing women as inferior (less intelligent/competent). * Benevolent Sexism: Positive but stereotypical views of women.
Affective Component (Emotions): Ingrained feelings often based on the peripheral route of persuasion (feelings rather than logic).
Behavioral Component (Discrimination): Unjustified negative or harmful actions. * Hiring: Overweight individuals are hired/promoted less. * Criminal Justice: African Americans are disproportionately arrested for drug charges compared to whites.
Identifying and Activating Prejudice
Microaggressions: Small "slights," indignities, and put-downs (e.g., complimenting an Asian student on "excellent English").
Social Distance: Reluctance to get close (work with, marry, live near) to another group.
Activation: Prejudices surface when people are stressed, angry, or have suffered a blow to self-esteem.
Implicit Biases: Biases hidden from oneself. * Implicit Association Test (IAT): Measures speed of reactions to target groups. It may measure personally held bias or general cultural stereotypes.
The Impact of Prejudice on the Victim
Self-Fulfilling Prophecy: People act in ways that confirm others' expectations. * Word, Zanna, & Cooper (): White interviewers showed discomfort toward Black candidates, leading the candidates to act more nervous and confirm low expectations.
Stereotype Threat: Feeling evaluated as a member of a group rather than an individual. * Example: Asian women perform worse on math tests when their female identity (stereotyped as poor at math) is salient, but better when their Asian identity (stereotyped as good at math) is salient.
Causes and Cures for Prejudice
Causes: * Normative Conformity: Going along with the group to gain acceptance. * Ethnocentrism: Believing one’s own culture is superior. * In-Group Bias: Favoring one's own group to enhance self-esteem. * Out-Group Homogeneity: Perceiving all members of an out-group as being the same ("They are all alike"). * Realistic Conflict Theory: Limited resources lead to conflict and prejudice.
The Contact Hypothesis: Simply bringing groups together can increase hostility unless four conditions are met: 1. Mutual interdependence (depending on each other). 2. Common goal. 3. Equal status. 4. Support by social norms.
The Jigsaw Classroom: Students must depend on each other for different pieces of information to succeed. This breaks down in-group/out-group perceptions and builds empathy.