Thomas Jefferson’s Racism (1788)

Thomas Jefferson’s Racism (1788)

Overview of American Racism in the Post-Revolution Era

  • American racism intensified following the American Revolution.

  • Racial prejudice existed for centuries, but a belief emerged in the late 18th century that African-descended people were inherently inferior to Anglo-descended people.

  • Writings like those of Thomas Jefferson supported faulty scientific reasoning that justified slavery and white supremacy.

Key Concepts and Arguments in Jefferson’s Writing

Physical Differences Between Races
  • Color is emphasized as the primary distinguishing factor:

    • Jefferson discusses the origin of skin color, questioning whether it is due to biology (blood, bile, skin secretion).

    • He concludes that these differences are natural and significant.

  • Descriptions of black and white beauty:

    • Jefferson claims that the combination of red and white skin tones represents beauty, contrasting with the 'monotony' of black skin.

    • Argues that these aesthetic qualities matter in human propagation, akin to breeding livestock.

  • Additional physical distinctions mentioned:

    • African-descended individuals have less bodily hair and are said to secrete more through the skin, resulting in unpleasant odors.

    • They are purported to have a higher tolerance for heat and a lower tolerance for cold.

    • Differences in sleep patterns are noted, suggesting blacks require less sleep compared to whites, causing them to stay awake longer at night even after labor.

Behavioral and Emotional Characteristics
  • Jefferson describes behavioral traits:

    • Perceptions of bravery and adventurousness, linked to a lack of foresight in recognizing danger.

    • Emotional expressions are characterized as more passionate but lacking in depth in matters of love.

    • Grief is seen as transient; he claims blacks feel and recover from afflictions more quickly than whites.

    • Overall, a perspective that their existence is driven more by sensation than by reflection.

Cognitive Abilities
  • Comparing memory, reason, and imagination:

    • Claims that African-descended individuals have equal memory abilities but are inferior in reasoning skills.

    • Suggests they lack the capability to comprehend advanced mathematical or philosophical concepts, like Euclid’s investigations.

    • Characterizes their imagination as dull and tasteless, showing no potential for higher creative expression.

  • Noted differences in artistic capability:

    • Acknowledges that while blacks may possess musical talent, he doubts their capacity for composing complex music.

Cultural Comparisons
  • Jefferson mentions Native Americans:

    • Draws examples from Native American art and oratory to highlight areas of potential intellectual creation, contrasting them with African-descended individuals.

  • He argues that the lack of artistic output from blacks reflects their perceived deficiency in cognitive abilities.

The Implications of Racial Distinctions

Emancipation and Race Mixing
  • Jefferson addresses the complexities surrounding emancipation:

    • Observes that unlike Roman slavery, which allowed for straightforward emancipation, American scenarios require additional steps to prevent racial mixing post-emancipation.

    • Emancipation in America, requires the freed individuals to be removed from the potential for interracial mixing, a concept he believes is unique to history.

  • Reflects on the challenges faced by advocates of emancipation, noting that they struggle with maintaining the dignity and beauty of the human races while seeking liberty.

Concluding Thoughts by Jefferson

  • He expresses a suspicion that blacks, whether inherently different or shaped by circumstances, are inferior in traits to whites.

  • Jefferson appeals to natural history, suggesting that various species and races can display different qualifications, expressing a philosophical view on race relations and the preservation of racial distinction as it exists in nature.

  • He highlights the need for a significant consideration of racial differences when discussing human liberty and social integration.