Chapter 7 The trade policy of the European Union

Chapter 7: Challenges for EU Trade Policy

Overview

  • This chapter reviews the main challenges that the EU's trade policy currently faces.

  • Key issues include:

    • Rise of emerging economies.

    • Stagnation of negotiations within the WTO.

  • These factors led to a reorientation of the EU's trade policy towards more bilateral free trade agreements (FTAs).

  • The FTAs have become deeper and more comprehensive, reflecting a degree of externalization of the EU's internal market.

  • Trade policy is increasingly linked with other EU policies like human rights, competition, and environmental policy, leading to institutional and political challenges.

EU's Trade Agreements

  • The EU's global network of trade agreements is characterized by a hierarchy of preferential market access.

  • Key components of the trade agreements:

    • European Economic Area (EEA): Established in 1992, it allows free movement of goods, services, capital, and persons.

    • Customs Union: Example with Turkey, allowing for free circulation of certain goods complying with EU norms.

    • Partnership and Cooperation Agreements (PCAs): Initially established with transition countries, these aimed for preferential treatment without free trade.

    • Deep and Comprehensive Free Trade Areas (DCFTAs): Replacing some PCAs to enhance market access and integration.

Shift in EU Trade Strategy

  • The 'globalization management' policy shifted focus after early 2000s due to:

    • Stalled Doha Development Round.

    • Emergence of assertive economies engaging in competitive liberalization.

  • This led the EU to prioritize bilateral agreements, targeting countries like:

    • India, Japan, Canada, and the United States: FTAs are based on symmetric reciprocity.

    • Emerging economies and developing countries: Asymmetric reciprocity is applied, with the EU liberalizing more rapidly.

Key Types of Trade Agreements

  • Internal Market Association: Example: EEA (Norway, Iceland, Liechtenstein)

  • Customs Union: Turkey, Andorra, San Marino

  • Free Trade Agreements (FTAs):

    • Symmetric Reciprocity: South Korea, Singapore, Canada, Japan.

    • Asymmetric Reciprocity: Mexico, Chile, South Africa.

  • Partnership and Cooperation Agreements: Example: Russia, Armenia, Azerbaijan.

Challenges in Trade Policy

  • Intensifying Global Competition: Demands for more competitiveness among economies.

  • WTO Negotiations Stalemate: Major issues like public procurement and investment protection remained unaddressed.

  • Regulatory Divergence: Differences in regulatory standards create challenges in negotiations and implementation.

  • Political and Institutional Challenges: EU's complex decision-making framework might slow down responses to changing global trade conditions.

Trade and Internal Policies Nexus

  • Expanding trade agreements integrated with EU policies on labor rights and environmental standards.

  • Increasing scrutiny of the impacts of trade agreements on local economies and environments.

  • Competition Policy: EU’s approach to ensure fair competition domestically and globally through cooperation agreements.

Human Rights and Trade

  • The EU promotes human rights through trade agreements:

    • Non-execution clauses linked to violations of human rights.

    • The inclusion of human rights clauses in major agreements, like the Cotonou Agreement.

    • Seeking coherence across various EU policies remains challenging due to varying interests of member states.

Conclusions

  • The EU's trade policy must navigate a complex landscape influenced by global dynamics and internal demands.

  • Future challenges include the impact of international developments, such as:

    • US trade policy under President Trump.

    • The ongoing implications of Brexit on trade agreements.

  • Effective communication and transparency in trade negotiations are crucial for public trust and support.

  • The chapter emphasizes the delicate balance between economic interests and the EU's normative values in trade relations.