Applied Behavior Analysis and Discrete Trial Instruction: Clinical Principles and Generalization

Foundations and Research of Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA)

  • Historical Context: The speaker references the work of Lovaas in 1987 with individuals with autism at UCLA (University of California, Los Angeles).
  • Evidence-Based Practice: ABA is regarded as one of the methods with the most research backing it because it is highly quantifiable.
  • Quantifiability: The process involves direct observation, measurement, and detailed documentation.
  • Reputation and Critiques:
    • ABA sometimes has a "bad rap" with certain individuals, including adults with autism who recall their experiences.
    • The quality of ABA practitioners (referred to as "ABA characters") varies; not all are considered effective or empathetic.
    • A common concern is that children may pick up a "script" rather than developing functional communication.
      • Example (Austin): Austin uses specific scripted behaviors to tell people to stop. If told to pick something up, he might start pushing things away or acting as if he is waking up. He does not explicitly say "I don't want to" or "stop talking to me"; he follows a script he has internalized.

Core Characteristics of Applied Behavior Analysis

  • Developmental Alignment: Goals are peer-focused and set at the child's specific developmental level.
  • Objective Measurement: Behavior must be measured objectively.
  • Systematic Progression: The transition from one target skill to the next is structured and systematic.
  • Data-Driven Decisions: The modification of goals and targets is strictly database-driven.
  • Generalization: After a skill is mastered, the focus must shift to generalizing that skill across various settings.
    • Criticism of Generalization: One of the main arguments against ABA is that children often get "stuck," and the learned behavior does not transfer to other environments outside the clinical setting.

Discrete Trial Instruction (DTI) and Discrete Trial Training (DTT)

  • Definition and Relationship to ABA: DTI (also known as DTT) is a specific technique that falls under the broader field of ABA.
  • ABA vs. DTI:
    • ABA: A broad field of study involving the collection of data to assess systematic modifications of environmental conditions.
    • DTI: Involves teaching a child to attend to specific environmental cues to improve responding within a highly circumscribed set of conditions.
  • The DTT Cycle: Every attempt at a skill must follow a specific cycle. If the cycle is not completed, it is not considered true DTT. The steps are:
    1. Discriminative Stimulus (SDS^D): The specific instruction given to the child.
    2. Response: The child's reaction or answer to the instruction.
    3. Consequence: The immediate reaction from the instructor (e.g., a reward/reinforcement for a correct response or a correction/labeling for an incorrect one).
    4. Inter-Trial Interval: A short pause between the consequence and the next instruction.
  • Mass Trials: DTT often utilizes mass trials, where the same stimulus is repeated continually to teach a new skill.

Strengths and Weaknesses of DTT

  • Strengths:
    • Effective for improving and modifying severe behavior problems.
    • Helps children with autism "learn how to learn," such as developing the ability to sit in a chair for extended periods.
  • Weaknesses:
    • Does not always improve cognitive or social abilities.
    • Risk of satiation: Children may stop caring about the reinforcement (e.g., beads or high-fives) after repeated trials.

The Lovaas Model and Mastery Criteria

  • Model Overview: The Lovaas model includes DTT and systematically intersperses newly acquired skills with existing ones.
  • Expansion Trials: These involve increasing the number of previously learned directions given to the child before returning to the new target direction (e.g., the command "run").
  • Mastery Thresholds: A skill (like the action "run") is typically considered mastered when the child responds correctly between 80%80\% and 100%100\% of the time across two separate sessions, involving at least four other acquired instructions.

Clinical Example: Layla and the Use of Reinforcement

  • Scenario: A session with a child named Layla using beads as a primary reinforcer.
  • Instructional Cycle:
    • Instructor: "Layla. Do this." (Instructor waves).
    • Layla waves.
    • Instructor: "Yes. That's waving. Good job."
    • Instructor: "Layla, do this." (Instructor puts arms up).
    • Instructor: "Good work."
  • The Role of the Pause: The instructor pauses at the end of the cycle to give Layla the beads. The beads serve as the "bigger reward" that bridges the interval between trials.
  • Goal Interpretation: The imitation (e.g., waving) is intended to build the foundational skills needed for later communication and verbal imitation (e.g., learning to say "mama").

Challenges with Generalization and Prompt Dependence

  • Prompt Dependence: This occurs when a child becomes reliant on prompts to initiate an action.
    • Example: A child standing at a door and refusing to walk through until they receive a physical tap or verbal nudge.
  • Contextual Limitation: If therapy only happens in a specific room, the child may only perform the skill in that room.
  • Strategic Solutions:
    • Therapists should move sessions to the playground, classroom, front office, or waiting room.
    • Practice skills with different people (e.g., administrative staff or other therapists).
    • Parental Involvement: Parents must be trained to implement techniques in different venues (e.g., at home or in public) so the skill is not confined to the child's bedroom or the clinic.

Prompting Hierarchy and Fading

  • Types of Prompts (from most to least intrusive):
    1. Physical: Moving the student's body (e.g., hand-over-hand). Gentle touches are preferred over full physical guidance when possible.
    2. Modeling: Demonstrating the task for the child to imitate.
    3. Gestural: Pointing, nodding, or smiling.
    4. Verbal: Using a word, sentence, or specific sound script.
    5. Visual: Using a picture or written text.
  • Prompt Fading: Prompts must be faded as quickly as possible. Providing prompts longer than necessary prevents the child from using the skill independently in response to natural cues.

Developmental Milestones and Study Resources

  • 16 by 16 Handout: Guidelines stating that children should learn at least 1616 gestures by 1616 months of age.
    • Example Milestone: A child should be able to shake their head "no" at 99 months.
  • Play Milestones: Documentation for understanding what is age-appropriate (e.g., for a 2.52.5-year-old child).
  • Language Milestones: Resources for tracking typical language progression.

Questions & Discussion

  • Question on Session Duration: A participant noted that some sessions are scheduled for 33 to 66 hours, which can be excessive for a small child (e.g., a 2.52.5-year-old). The speaker agreed, stating they have successfully met goals in 2525 minutes to an hour and advocated for shorter, more effective sessions.
  • Question on IEP (Individualized Education Program) Locations: There was a discussion regarding whether therapy must take place in a speech room.
    • The speaker noted that IEPs usually specify "group or individual" and a duration (e.g., 3030 minutes) but rarely mandate a specific room.
    • Practitioners are encouraged to move therapy to the playground or other settings to promote generalization, though some schools may assume the speech room is the agreed-upon location.