ap comp notes


What political scientists study

  • Quantitative/Empirical

    • people/money (factual & objective)

    • Data from observation, statistics gov’t reports, polls, questionnaires, & surveys, charts, tables, graphs

  • Qualitative/normative

    • Value/opinion statements

    • Speeches, foundational documents, political cartoons, maps, political commentaries

  • Political scientists use Quantitative & Qualitative data to compare & make inferences, generalizations, or arguments.

  • Correlation (not always causation)

    • When there is an apparent association between two or more variables, but the nature of the relationship is unclear.

  • Causation

    • Influence another event

    • A relationship such that a change in one variable produces a change in the second variable (difficult to determine with certainty)

  • Its difficult to determine causation w/certainty, since numerous variables influence political policies or regime stability 

  • Comparing different political systems to determine correlations between judicial decisions and their impact on legislative law-making

  • States

    • Political organizations that combine permanent population w/governing institutions to exercise control over a defined territory w/international recognition

  • Regime

    • Fundamental rules that control access/exercise of political power. Regimes typically endure from gov’t to gov’t. A regime can be democratic or authoritarian. 

  • Government 

    • Set of institutions or individuals legally empowered to make binding decisions for a state

  • Authority

    • Derived from the state’s legitimate right to use power

  • Sovereignty

    • The right & power to govern itself without outside interference; independent legal authority over a population in a particular territory

  • Nation

    • Group of people w/commonalities, including race, language, religion, and ethnicity, with commonalities, political identity & aspiration

    • China 

      • Uighurs, Tibetans, and Han Chinese 

    • Iran 

      • Persians, Azeris, and Kurds

    • Mexico 

      • Mestizo and Indigenous peoples

    • Russia 

      • Russian, Chechen, and Tatar

    • Nigeria  

      • Hausa, Yoruba, and Igbo

    • United Kingdom 

      • Scottish, Irish, English, and Welsh

    • United States 

      • The Navajo


Democracy

Authoritarian

Rule of Law: Law is applied consistently/universally (everyone regardless)

Rule by Law: Law is arbitrarily applied (changing accordingly)


Independent Media - transparency 

State owned/controlled Media

Free/fair elections

Non-competitive/free elections

Policy-making transparency

Policy-making opaqueness

Govt. branch independence

Arbitrary govt. decisions

Political participation

Restricted civil society





  • Transparency: Of government decision making for citizens to see how policies are made and implemented; includes treatment of journalists who seek to investigate and report news critical of government

  • Illiberal Democracy / Hybrid Regime: Like Russia, hold elections w/minimal competition for the ruling party, and civil freedoms are generally eroded

  • One Party States: Like China, mean opposing political parties are barred from exercising control over the government

  • Theocracies: Like Iran, require the state be run by religious authorities

  • Totalitarian: Government significantly restrict citizens’ freedom of movement and employment options (totally in control)

  • Military Regimes: Like Nigeria between the country’s independence and the passage of its 1999 constitution, when military leaders hold senior positions of governing authority, were frequent

  • Democratization: Transition from an authoritarian regime to a democratic regime (also known as political liberalization)

  • More competition, fairness and transparency in elections

  • Universal suffrage for adult citizens

  • Increased citizen participation in the policymaking process

  • Greater transparency

  • Protected civil liberties and civil rights

  • Equal treatment of citizens

  • Establishment of rule of law

  • Democratic Consolidation: Process by which a democratic regime matures in terms of election rules, separation of powers, protection of civil liberties - key is time, stability - goal to be a liberal democracy

  • Changes to look for:

  • PR election system

  • Gender/cultural quotas

  • Independent election commission

  • Freedom of Information Act


  • Power - the ability to control the behavior of others through coercion, persuasion, or leadership

  • Authority - the legal right use that power on behalf of society/government

    • Constitutions

    • Religions

    • Military forces

    • Political parties

    • Legislatures

    • Popular support

  • Sovereignty: ultimate authority over a territory, usually exercised by the government of a state

UNIT 1.6

  • Regime changes can occur when institutional changes are replaced and supported by a large % of the people. Can occur

    • Suddenly

      • Coups

      • Revolutions

    • Slowly

      • Elections

  • Government changes more frequently and easily than regimes and can be

    • Peaceful

      • Elections 

      • Appointments

      • Lines of succession

    • Violent

      • Revolutions or coups d'etat

      • Iran and nigeria 

  • Coup forcible takeover typically led by military

UNIT 1.7

Federal States: divide power among different levels of government to give some local control in social and educational services, while still reserving some powers for the national gov’t

Unitary States: concentrate power at national w/ more uniform policies and potentially more efficient policy making

USA

Powers devolved to local gov’t granted via enacted policies from national legislature

  • Education decisions

  • Local transportation decisions

Mexico - according to constitution states have power to tax

Iran


Nigeria - states have power to tax according to the constitution

UK - no constitutional promises to share power with local gov’ts

Russia

china



  • Multiethnic states - comprised of a population of a variety of ethnic backgrounds

  • The degree to which power is centralized or decentralized can change over time in both federal and unitary states due to:

    • Internal forces

      • Ethnic cleavages

      • Regional protests or discontent

      • National emergency/crisis

    • External forces

      •  Response to supranational organizations (European Union, NATO, OPEC, etc.)

      • Growing due to globalization

      • Threats from other countries

  • Supranational organizations: nations are not totally sovereign. Can be international or regional. States pool sovereignty to gain political, economic, or social clout - Nations that band together to achieve a greater goal (lose sovereignty in the process)

Chinese constitution established it as unitary government

  • But, claims to have autonomous regions and constitutional protections of language and religious rights of ethnic minority residents in those regions

    • Uighur Muslims in Xinjiang

    • Tibetan Buddhists in Tibet

  • Despite stated regional autonomy, china’s national gov’t maintains its sovereignty in those regions

  • Uses coercion and brute repression to minimize chances that separatist movements will threaten china’s sovereignty in those multiethnic ___

    Pros and cons of federal system

Pros

Cons

Makes it easier to govern a large country (physically largest countries usually fed, not china)

Lack of uniformity in policy (ex: voting registration requirements, education requirements.)

Better accommodates regional differences

Gov’t can’t can’t act as quickly as unitary

Helps guard against concentration of political power

If regional boundaries correspond to deep social divisions, federalism reinforces those divisions

Federal and Unitary Systems

  • Legitimacy: General belief that government has the right to rule and exercise authority (popular acceptance of authority)

  • Political efficacy: A citizens belief that their actions can impact the government (I have power and a voice)


Types of Legitimacy

  • Traditional

  • Tradition

  • Religious heritage

  • Rational-Legal

  • Popular elections

  • Constitutional provisions

  • Governmental effectiveness

  • Economic growth

  • Other

  • Ideology (ideal doesn’t change ‘make america great again’)

  • Charismatic/nationalism

  • Dominant political party’s endorsement

Devolution: Delegation of power to regional governments by the national government

  • Strengthen legitimacy by promote policy innovation

  • More competition

  • Local solutions to local problems

  • Representation to ethnic groups

HOWEVER

  • Weaken legitimacy by making contradictory policies

  • Complicate policy making

  • Allowing inequality

  • Increasing competition

  • Emphasizing local tensions

Can Undermine Legitimacy:

  • Increase in corruption

  • Reduced electoral competition/serious problems (poor economy/social conflicts

Political Stability

  • Political participation like protests can force change in order to maintain/enhance stability

Corruption

  • Misuse of government authority

  • Not handling it can threaten and undermine stability

  • Can reduce ability of state to attract foreign investment to improve economic growth


  • Since WWll, several international organizations (like International Monetary Fund - IMF - and the World Bank)  arose to help poor countries develop

  • Development should focus on the “poorest of the poor”

  • Economist/philosopher Amartya Sen argued neither growth nor poverty alone were adequate goals but rather the development of anywhere in the world should be enhancing the capabilities of individuals to lead fulfilling lives

  • Sen also argued freedom is essential - his theory became the leading conceptualization of development (HDI) by the United Nations

  • A country with lower education and higher income will have a similar score to a country with higher education and lower income on the HDI scale

  • All six countries in the course all are ranked in the top 12 of countries for GDP levels

  • GDP criticisms: does not take into account how many people are living in the country, the existence of underground black market markers - GDP only relies on government recorded data which may be insufficient

  • A high rate of income inequality is associated with greater poverty and has a negative effect on the equality in a democracy

  • The higher the score on the Gini index, the bigger the gap between the rich and the poor

  • Political rights scores in Freedom House are based on free and fair elections, pluralism, and participation

  • Lower scores on Freedom House associate with higher levels of political freedom

  • Democratic Consolidation: Process in which a regime has developed stable democratic institutions and significant protections of civil liberties and is unlikely to revert to authoritarianism

  • Grand corruption occurs at the highest levels of society - significant harm that goes unpunished

  • The Corruption Perceptions Index measures people's experiences in encountering corruption - scored on a scale of 0-100 (0=absolute corruption, 100=clean government)

  • Strong state: state capable of providing necessary government services to citizens

  • Failed state: state that lost control over all part of its territory

  • Fragile State’s Index includes: (12 factors total)

  • Social indicators

  • Economic indicators

  • Political indicators

  • Cohesion indicators

  • FSI measures all twelve indicators then adds and weighs them equally