Lacy and Simon

  • Argue that competition between newspapers is good

‘Two newspapers in a market mean that there is more space devoted to news. Even if a majority of the news is somewhat duplicated, having more reporters covering a market increases the possibility of a reporter uncovering information that would be useful in the intellectual market.’

  • They criticise Curran and Seaton

Lacy and Simon argue that if you have competition between newspapers then there is increased…​

  • financial commitment ​to the newsgathering budget​

  • diversity of editorial content ​

  • competition among individual reporters to get stories (perhaps a more interesting read or more likelihood of rule-breaking?)​

  • sensational coverage (not always a good thing) –to out-shock each other?​

  • diversity of economic competition

In Lacy’s and Simon’s overview of economic theory and research into the US daily newspaper press, we find that rivalry between media inevitably will result in quality increase.

Media in competitive markets cannot escape from increasing their editorial budgets to keep a reasonable market share to survive.

According to Lacy and Simon, this necessity contributes to quality: ‘The increase in quality is necessary for the newspaper to attract readers from its competitors.

Newspapers competing for the same readers must match the quality of the competing newspaper in most areas and differentiate themselves in other areas to attract readers.’