Beyond the Veto: Roles in UN Security Council Decision-Making

Institutional Power and Informal Practices

  • The formal framework of the UN Security Council is defined by the UN Charter and the Provisional Rules of Procedure, but day-to-day operations rely heavily on informal practices.
  • Institutional power extends the influence of actors beyond their formal legal privileges, while legitimacy acts as a moderating force on that power.
  • Note 507507 represents an attempt to codify working methods, but a gap remains between these aspirational documents and actual practice.

Dominance of Permanent Members (P5)

  • Permanent members leverage their status through three primary informal avenues: penholding, agenda setting, and the informal veto.
  • Penholding: The "P3" (United States, United Kingdom, and France) dominate the drafting of resolutions. In 20192019, the P3 held the pen for 3030 out of 3939 agenda items (77%77\%, while China and Russia held very few.
  • Informal Veto: P5 members use the threat of a veto during private negotiations to remove specific provisions or block resolutions entirely without casting a formal negative vote.
  • Agenda Setting: P5 members largely determine which items are added to the Council’s agenda, often excluding crises in bordering states or where they are directly involved.

Avenues for Influence for Elected Members (E10)

  • The influence of the 1010 elected members is tied to the Council’s drive for legitimacy through unanimity and regional support.
  • Unanimity as Legitimacy: Drafters prioritize unanimous decisions to ensure successful implementation. Between 20002000 and 20202020, 87%87\% of resolutions passed with support from all 1515 members, allowing E10 members to leverage their votes for concessions.
  • Regional Gatekeeping: Support from states within the region under discussion is highly valued, granting those specific E10 members significant symbolic power.
  • Collective Action: A nascent "E10 culture" involves elected members working as a bloc or in small groups to challenge P3 dominance in drafting and penholding.
  • Diplomatic Capacity: Individual states increase influence through technical expertise, niche diplomacy, and chairing Sanctions Committees.

Influence of the UN Secretary-General and Secretariat

  • The "second UN" (Secretariat) influences decisions despite not having a vote by acting as a technical expert and moral leader.
  • Norm Entrepreneurship: The Secretary-General uses Article 9999 and moral authority to frame issues and introduce conceptual tools like the "responsibility to protect."
  • Technical Expertise: Departments like the Department of Peace Operations (DPO) and the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) provide reports and recommendations that often form the basis of mandate language.

Implications for Reform

  • Formal reform of the UN Charter is currently deadlocked due to the requirement for P5 ratification.
  • Informal reform through changes in working methods, such as co-penholding between P5 and E10 members, offers a viable path for broader participation and improved governance.