Beyond the Veto: Roles in UN Security Council Decision-Making
- The formal framework of the UN Security Council is defined by the UN Charter and the Provisional Rules of Procedure, but day-to-day operations rely heavily on informal practices.
- Institutional power extends the influence of actors beyond their formal legal privileges, while legitimacy acts as a moderating force on that power.
- Note 507 represents an attempt to codify working methods, but a gap remains between these aspirational documents and actual practice.
Dominance of Permanent Members (P5)
- Permanent members leverage their status through three primary informal avenues: penholding, agenda setting, and the informal veto.
- Penholding: The "P3" (United States, United Kingdom, and France) dominate the drafting of resolutions. In 2019, the P3 held the pen for 30 out of 39 agenda items (77%, while China and Russia held very few.
- Informal Veto: P5 members use the threat of a veto during private negotiations to remove specific provisions or block resolutions entirely without casting a formal negative vote.
- Agenda Setting: P5 members largely determine which items are added to the Council’s agenda, often excluding crises in bordering states or where they are directly involved.
Avenues for Influence for Elected Members (E10)
- The influence of the 10 elected members is tied to the Council’s drive for legitimacy through unanimity and regional support.
- Unanimity as Legitimacy: Drafters prioritize unanimous decisions to ensure successful implementation. Between 2000 and 2020, 87% of resolutions passed with support from all 15 members, allowing E10 members to leverage their votes for concessions.
- Regional Gatekeeping: Support from states within the region under discussion is highly valued, granting those specific E10 members significant symbolic power.
- Collective Action: A nascent "E10 culture" involves elected members working as a bloc or in small groups to challenge P3 dominance in drafting and penholding.
- Diplomatic Capacity: Individual states increase influence through technical expertise, niche diplomacy, and chairing Sanctions Committees.
Influence of the UN Secretary-General and Secretariat
- The "second UN" (Secretariat) influences decisions despite not having a vote by acting as a technical expert and moral leader.
- Norm Entrepreneurship: The Secretary-General uses Article 99 and moral authority to frame issues and introduce conceptual tools like the "responsibility to protect."
- Technical Expertise: Departments like the Department of Peace Operations (DPO) and the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) provide reports and recommendations that often form the basis of mandate language.
- Formal reform of the UN Charter is currently deadlocked due to the requirement for P5 ratification.
- Informal reform through changes in working methods, such as co-penholding between P5 and E10 members, offers a viable path for broader participation and improved governance.