DM838_Lesson_34

Overview of New Perspectives on Paul

  • In 1981, James D.G. Dunn delivered a lecture titled The New Perspective on Paul.

  • Dunn's ideas build upon E.P. Sanders' research and Krister Stendahl's earlier work.

Key Concepts

Critique of Jewish Understanding

  • Dunn asserts that Paul critiques national righteousness or ethnocentrism, not works righteousness.

  • The Jewish belief of exclusivity based on the law is challenged; Jews may see themselves as inherently superior to Gentiles.

  • Dunn argues that the primary issue is sociological, focusing on relationships between Jews and Gentiles rather than soteriological (salvation).

Works of the Law

  • Works of the Law are boundary markers like circumcision, dietary laws, and Sabbath practices that distinguish Judaism.

  • Dunn posits that Paul's message indicates Gentiles can join God's people without these markers.

  • The message of the Pauline gospel includes a "backdoor" into Abraham’s family through faith in Jesus.

Comparison of Perspectives

Stendahl's Two Ways of Salvation

  • Stendahl stated there are two paths to God:

    • Jews benefit from the law and covenant.

    • Gentiles are included through Jesus.

  • Stendahl emphasizes a "double way" of salvation.

Tom Wright's Framework

  • Nicholas Thomas Wright builds on Dunn’s ideas, keeping the same new perspective themes while emphasizing individual salvation aspects.

  • Wright distinguishes between initial justification (God justifying the ungodly) and final justification (based on one’s entire life).

  • Initial justification happens by faith, superseding the works of the law.

  • Final justification denotes what God observes, emphasizing transformative work through the Spirit rather than mere human effort.

Assurance and Final Judgment

  • According to Wright, assurance in faith hinges not on individual works but on the transformative work of the Spirit throughout life.

  • Individuals should reflect on their lives for assurance at final judgment, focusing on personal evidence of the Spirit's work.

  • Wright's stance likens to Augustinian perspectives on justification, differing from Reformation views in certain aspects.

Perspectives on Influencing Figures

  • Dunn and Wright have experienced vilification in certain religious circles despite their contributions.

  • Understanding their backgrounds:

    • Krister Stendahl was a Lutheran minister.

    • E.P. Sanders, often identifying as agnostic, critiques traditional Judaism.

    • James Dunn remains active in Methodist circles, and Tom Wright has held various significant positions, including Bishop of Durham.

  • Dunn's playful personality adds a human aspect to academic discussions, while his views have evolved over time.

Conclusion

  • The New Perspective reinterprets Jewish and Gentile relations in the early church, emphasizing communal belonging over personal righteousness in the context of grace.