Sonic Intolerance, Gentrification, and the Acoustic Politics of Race

Sonic Racism, Intolerance, and the Murder of Jordan Davis

  • Aural Dimensions of Segregation and Racism:

    • Segregation, racial boundaries, and racial animus are audible phenomena within urban and shared spaces.
    • Sonic intolerance refers to an aggressive unwillingness to coexist with certain sounds or auditory cultures, and it can escalate into lethal violence.
  • The 2012 Florida Gas Station Shooting:

    • In 2012, 17-year-old Jordan Davis and a group of friends pulled into a Florida gas station in a Jeep.
    • A gas station stop typically lasts an average of 3 to 5 minutes, functioning as a shared public zone where transient, loud sounds routinely come and go.
    • Michael Dunn, a white adult male who was also fueling his vehicle, walked over to the teenagers' vehicle and demanded that they turn down their music.
    • The teenagers refused to comply, asserting that the gas station was a shared public space.
    • Dunn responded by opening fire directly into the Jeep, murdering 17-year-old Jordan Davis.
  • Racialized Framing and Space Reclamation:

    • The media dubbed the legal proceedings the "loud music trial," trivializing the confrontation as a mere dispute over volume rather than an act of racial policing.
    • The teenagers were listening to hip-hop, specifically a song by Lil Reese, which Dunn subsequently denigrated as "rap crap."
    • The confrontation centered on how young Black men utilized sound to occupy physical and social space.
    • Dunn's violent reaction was propelled by rigid personal beliefs regarding racial hierarchies, who has the right to occupy public spaces, what communities are allowed to sound like, and what cultural expressions are permissible in public.

The Sonic Color Line and Sonic Gentrification in Los Angeles

  • Scholarly Background of Jennifer Lynn Stoever:

    • Jennifer Lynn Stoever (identified in sound studies also as Jennifer Stover) is a sound studies scholar and sound historian teaching at Binghamton University.
    • She grew up in Southern California, one of the most culturally diverse regions in the United States, and was an early fan of hip-hop music.
    • Her observations at concerts and nightclubs led to her conceptualization of the "sonic color line."
    • She is the author of The Sonic Color Line and serves as the editor-in-chief of the sound studies publication Sounding Out.
  • Downtown Los Angeles Urban Transition (2006–2007):

    • Around 2006 or 2007, Downtown Los Angeles underwent rapid gentrification.
    • Historically, the area served as a neighborhood where low-income Brown residents lived.
    • Industrial factories and vacant commercial office buildings were renovated into high-end lofts and condominiums, accelerating the displacement of unhoused individuals from Skid Row.
  • Acoustic Deterrence and Hostile Architecture:

    • Following an Isaac Hayes concert at the Hollywood Bowl, Stoever was stranded in Downtown Los Angeles late at night waiting for a municipal bus.
    • At 2:00 AM, high-volume classical music was being blasted through exterior building doorways.
    • This audio deployment functioned as a form of hostile architecture, utilizing sound deliberately as an acoustic deterrent to prevent unhoused people from resting or sleeping in doorways.
    • Because the audio being broadcast was high-volume classical music, it was culturally insulated from being categorized as "noise."
    • The classical genre bolstered the perceived elite class standing of the residential property while operating simultaneously as an aggressive, exclusionary, "keep-out" barrier.
  • Mechanisms of Sonic Gentrification:

    • Sonic gentrification occurs when affluent white residents move into historically marginalized neighborhoods and assert unilateral authority to define what constitutes legitimate sound versus illegitimate "noise."
    • Incoming residents operate under the assumption that an established neighborhood must conform to their personal auditory expectations, refusing to adapt to the preexisting sonic ecology of the community.

Racial Politics and Cultural Soundscapes: The Marcus Garvey Park Drum Circle

  • Historical Significance of the Drum Circle:

    • In Harlem, New York City, an outdoor community drum circle met regularly on Sunday afternoons at Marcus Garvey Park.
    • The drum circle was established in the late 1960s, having originated directly out of the Black Power Movement and the Black Arts Movement.
  • Gentrification and Noise Complaints (2007):

    • By 2007, surrounding properties were refurbished into luxury condominiums, triggering steep rent increases and an influx of white, middle-class residents into a neighborhood that was historically Black and Puerto Rican.
    • New condominium owners fixated on the traditional drum circle as an auditory nuisance, filing repeated noise complaints with their condominium board and the police department.
    • This confrontation serves as a primary example of how explicit racial disputes over community belonging, historical presence, and spatial sovereignty frequently manifest under the guise of municipal noise debates.

Historical Urban Displacement and Acoustic Erasure in New York City

  • Post-War Puerto Rican Migration (1940s):

    • The post-World War II period saw significant demographic shifts in New York City as Puerto Ricans migrated from Puerto Rico to the mainland.
    • White residents articulated their racial and cultural anxieties through public discourse, including letters to The New York Times, pejoratively referring to the city's changing soundscape as an "audio slum."
  • Tony Schwartz and the Destruction of San Juan Hill:

    • Tony Schwartz was an urban sound artist who lived during the 1940s in Hell's Kitchen, adjacent to the planned redevelopment zone for Lincoln Center.
    • Schwartz documented the total destruction and displacement of San Juan Hill, a predominantly Black and Latino working-class neighborhood that was razed to construct Lincoln Center.
    • Schwartz captured street-level recordings of community members, including residents who observed that while outside street dancing was condemned by outsiders as "terrible and disgusting," those same outsiders engaged in identical dancing within private, paid nightclubs.
    • Schwartz utilized a dedicated radio show to broadcast his field recordings, arguing that the city was annihilating thousands of grassroots musical performances taking place nightly to build an exclusive venue hosting a single, elite performance per night.
  • Power Dynamics of Urban Noise:

    • Auditory regulation reflects structural power: it dictates who has the authority to make sound, who controls urban acoustics, and who is forced to endure disruptive noise.
    • Massive municipal and infrastructure projects, such as the construction of Lincoln Center or the Cross Bronx Expressway, generate intense, disruptive, long-term construction noise.
    • These intrusive industrial sounds are treated as civic necessities that communities are expected to tolerate under the rhetoric of universal public progress, even though the infrastructure frequently serves only privileged populations while disenfranchising marginalized neighborhoods.

Communal Sound, Resistance, and the Genesis of Hip-Hop

  • Cross-Cultural Auditory Dialogue in 1940s Harlem:

    • During the 1940s, Black and Puerto Rican residents in Harlem actively navigated shared public space and acoustic boundaries through community dialogues.
    • The Amsterdam News published articles encouraging Black community members to exercise auditory tolerance toward Spanish accents.
    • The paper reminded readers of the Great Migration, noting that when Black residents moved north from the American South, they had faced severe discrimination for their Southern accents and vernacular speech; thus, Spanish speech should not be delegitimized or branded as noise.
  • Hip-Hop as Auditory Reclamation in the 1970s Bronx:

    • The emergence of hip-hop in the South Bronx during the 1970s served as an auditory reclamation strategy for disenfranchised Black and Puerto Rican youth.
    • Pioneering figures such as Africa Bambata assembled heterogeneous sound sources to forge solidarity and community identity.
    • These sonic collages drew from television broadcasts, European electronic music (notably Kraftwerk), and maternal record collections.
    • This creative acoustic production provided an alternative vision of communal life that countered mainstream characterizations of the area as the "burned-out Bronx."
    • The culture popularized communal chants and expressions such as: "Bronx runs to the planet Bronx. Don't stop."

Contemporary Sonic Policing: The North Carolina Case Study

  • The Incident:

    • As documented by The Washington Post in a May report, a Black female physician in North Carolina was celebrating major personal milestones inside her own home.
    • She had recently learned of her pregnancy and had been awarded a prestigious cardiology fellowship.
    • On a Saturday afternoon at 3:00 PM, she played a Spotify playlist featuring 1990s hip-hop music, including tracks by Juvenile, Notorious B.I.G., and Puff Daddy.
    • Specific lyrics playing included lines from Juvenile's track: "Girl, you look good. Want your back, that thang up. You the big fine woman. Want your back, that thang up."
    • After playing the music for approximately one hour while dancing and celebrating, she turned the music off and sat down to watch the television news.
  • Law Enforcement Intervention and Sonic Surveillance:

    • Shortly after turning off the music, police officers arrived at her residence and knocked abruptly on her door due to noise complaints made by her neighbors.
    • The neighbors entirely bypassed direct interpersonal communication—such as knocking on her door, acknowledging the weekend daytime context, or establishing neighborly rapport—and resorted immediately to municipal policing.
    • The police intervention produced profound fear within her private home, signaling that despite her advanced educational pedigree and socioeconomic standing, her white neighbors did not accept her presence and were actively surveilling her auditory footprint.
    • This reflects the psychological process of auditory fixation: when individuals hold racial or social biases, they actively attune to, monitor, and subjectively amplify specific sounds, using them as pretexts for exclusion.

Toward an Ethics of Listening and Sonic Inclusiveness

  • Deconstructing Auditory Reactions:
    • Transitioning from sonic prejudice to sonic inclusiveness demands that individuals interrogate their internal, unexamined reactions to everyday environmental sounds.
    • Individuals must critically assess why certain sounds trigger immediate agitation, such as a neighbor playing a specific genre of music or a neighbor hosting a social gathering in a front yard rather than an enclosed backyard.
    • Sound serves as an immediate trigger for deeply entrenched beliefs regarding race, class, and social propriety; simultaneously, ingrained racial and class prejudices dictate how individuals interpret the sounds they hear.
    • Interrupting automatic auditory assumptions is essential for creating equitable, shared urban environments.

The Subjectivity of Noise and Sonic Preference

  • Redefining Noise:

    • Noise is conventionally defined as any sound that an individual listener dislikes; conversely, that exact same acoustic frequency may be deeply enjoyed by someone else.
    • Acoustic preferences demonstrate that volume and distortion are frequently sought out rather than rejected.
  • Aesthetic and Urban Loudness:

    • While an electric guitar is capable of producing an entirely pure, clean tone, musicians intentionally route the signal through feedback, distortion, and fuzz boxes to generate buzziness and noisiness.
    • Within urban environments, people deliberately seek out high-volume spaces, choosing to dance in loud venues or converse within packed, noisy bars.
    • Whether a sound is processed as intolerable noise or as enjoyable stimulation depends predominantly on human attitude, cultural context, and social conditioning.

Program Information

  • Host and Production:
    • Presented by Anne Strangeshamps.
    • Produced by To the Best of Our Knowledge, broadcast via Wisconsin Public Radio and PRX.
    • Features sound studies scholar Jennifer Lynn Stoever and author/philosopher David Rothenberg.