Module 9B

Definition & Core Functions of Political Parties

  • Classic definition (Giovanni Sartori): “Any political group that presents at elections and is capable of placing, through elections, candidates for public office.”
  • Key democratic functions
    • Recruiting leaders & candidates
    • Structuring voter choice (“organising our choice during elections”)
    • Instruments of governance once in power
    • Mobilising citizens & linking them to institutions
    • Overall: viewed as essential to modern democracy

Organisational Typologies of Parties

  • Cadre (elite‐based) vs. Mass (movement‐based)
    • Cadre parties: 19th-century parliamentary creations; loose coalitions of local elites; primary role = electoral machine.
    – Canadian exemplars: historic Conservative & Liberal parties.
    • Mass parties: Emerged from working-class mobilisation; large dues-paying memberships; organise members’ social life (e.g.
    socialist “summer camps” in Europe).
    – Canadian cases: NDP (labour union roots); Parti Québécois (PQ) as most successful mass party via Québec nationalist movement.

  • Ideological vs. Catch-All
    • Ideological: Programmatic, doctrine-driven (socialist, nationalist, populist).
    – In Canada: Greens, NDP, nationalist parties, Reform Party (populist).
    • Catch-All: Pragmatic, electorally flexible, target the median voter.
    – In Canada: Liberal Party; pre-2000 Progressive Conservatives.

  • Brokerage Parties (Canadian specialty)
    • Definition: Seek to bridge multiple, often conflicting, interests by promising targeted benefits across groups/regions.
    • Distinct from catch-all: do not focus single-mindedly on median voter; instead assemble cross-regional coalitions.
    • Rationale in Canada:
    – Vast geography + strong regional/linguistic cleavages ⟶ need cross-Canada coalition to win.
    – Claimed to help national unity & social stability.
    • Normative debate:
    – Pro-brokerage (e.g., Bill Cross): necessary glue in divided federation.
    – Anti-brokerage: reinforces territorial cleavages, blunts ideological/class conflict, stifles “creative politics” (class-based).

Party-System Concepts & Tools

  • Party System: Stable pattern of competition among two or more parties over time—covers number of parties, salient issues, cleavages, organisational forms.
  • Duverger’s Law: Under single-member plurality (SMP) systems, competition should converge to two parties.
    • USA = textbook case.
    • Canada = partial exception; nationally multiparty, but regionally often 22 competitive parties per province.
  • Extended Canadian criteria: Scholars also track leadership selection rules, party–citizen linkages, discourse, ties to interest groups.
  • Alignment: Long phase with stable inter-party pattern.
  • Realignment: Critical election(s) upsetting previous alignment; new parties rise, others fall.

Chronology of Canadian Party Systems (1867-Present)

1. First Party System (c. 1867-1917)
  • Structure: 22‐party dominance (Conservative, Liberal) ≈ 95%95\% vote share.
  • Origins: Cadre parties formed inside Parliament; labels loose—candidates could run “Independent Conservative/Liberal.”
  • Leadership: Chosen by parliamentary caucus.
  • Hallmarks:
    • Patronage politics used to reward supporters (jobs, contracts).
    • Core issue = National Policy (tariffs protecting central Canada) vs. Free Trade w/ USA.
    • Conservatives = tariff; Liberals = free trade (hence early western support).
  • Signs of Strain (1910s): Growth of regional & agrarian protest, birth of Progressive Party opposing tariffs & patronage → foreshadows realignment.
2. Second Party System (c. 1921-1957)
  • “Two-and-a-Half” model: Conservatives + Liberals ≈ >75%>75\% vote; minor parties (Progressives, early CCF) present.
  • Liberal dominance: Leaders Mackenzie King & Louis-St-Laurent.
  • Organisation: Extra-parliamentary structures modest but expanding.
  • Ministerialism: Strong regional cabinet ministers (e.g., C. D. Howe in Ontario; Lapointe in Québec).
  • Economic discourse: Shift from laissez-faire → Keynesianism (post-Depression, WWII, Rowell–Sirois Commission).
  • Pivotal 1957 election: John Diefenbaker (Sask.) breaks Liberal hold, attracts western + some Québec support.
3. Third Party System (c. 1962-1993)
  • Still “Two-and-a-Half,” but stronger NDP (successor to CCF, labour alliance).
  • Liberal hegemony under Pierre Trudeau, yet waning west support; party anchored in Québec/Ontario/Atlantic.
  • Professionalisation:
    • Delegate leadership conventions (live floor deals, multiple ballots).
    • TV debates, campaign marketing, stricter finance disclosure.
  • Policy arc:
    • Early–mid 1960s: expansion of welfare state (Medicare).
    • Late 1970s-80s: fiscal crisis ➜ neoliberal challenge (deficit, debt, privatisation, free-trade debate).
  • Conservative coalition under Brian Mulroney (1984, 1988): Québec–West alliance proves fragile—Meech Lake, patronage scandals, Bombardier jet contract alienate West.
4. Fourth Party System (1993-c. 2011) – Multiparty, Regionalised
  • 1993 landslide: Progressive Conservatives collapse from majority to 22 seats.
  • Main regional players:
    • Bloc Québécois = Official Opposition, sovereigntist.
    • Reform Party (later Canadian Alliance) dominates West, populist.
    • Liberals sweep Ontario + Atlantic, retain power under Jean Chrétien.
  • Institutional changes:
    • Greater PMO centralisation (“presidentialisation”).
    • Declining party memberships → “virtual parties” enabled by tech.
    • Campaign finance reform: ban on corporate donations, public subsidies.
  • Policy frame: Neoliberal retrenchment—1995 Chrétien/Martin budget, deep transfer cuts, austerity across provinces.
5. Tentative Fifth Party System? (c. 2011-present)
  • 2011 “Orange Wave”: NDP official opposition; Liberals fall to third.
  • 2015 Justin Trudeau win restores Liberal plurality/majority; subsequent minority in 2019 & 2021.
  • Scholarly dispute: Whether a stable new alignment has formed remains unclear—still volatile electorate.

Party Leadership Selection – Evolution

  • Original model: Caucus selection (MPs choose).
  • Delegate conventions (20th c.): Riding members elect pledged delegates; multi-ballot floor alliances; guaranteed seats for some groups (e.g., Liberal youth wing).
  • Modern trend: One-Member-One-Vote (OMOV)
    • Live or ranked-ballot electronic/remote rounds.
    • Liberal Party briefly introduced “supporter” category (2011) – no membership fee required.
  • Leadership review: Post-election conventions vote on confidence.
    • Informal legitimacy threshold ≈ 70%70\% support; below that, leader pressured to resign.

Candidate Nomination Mechanics

  • In principle: Local riding association holds nomination meeting; members pick nominee.
  • De facto national veto: Party leader must sign nomination papers—can block controversial winners.
  • Star candidates: HQ may parachute high-profile figures into “safe” seats, discouraging open contest.
  • No-contest ridings: Sometimes parties have no volunteers; placeholders recruited.
  • Incumbent protection: Sitting MPs usually shielded from nomination challenges unless scandal.
The Ruth Ellen Brosseau Case Study – “Placeholder to Popular MP”
  • 2011: Ottawa bartender, NDP sympathiser, doesn’t reside in Québec; listed as candidate in rural, francophone Berthier–Maskinongé (party expected no chance).
  • During campaign she vacationed in Las Vegas; yet “Orange Wave” sweeps her to victory.
  • Learns French, engages constituents, gains local affection; re-elected 2015 despite NDP drop; later defeated but remains in riding—illustrates quirks of candidate selection + regional surges.

Links to Broader Principles & Real-World Relevance

  • Duverger’s Law vs. Canadian exception: Highlights interaction between electoral rules & regional cleavages.
  • Brokerage vs. Ideological models: Speaks to debates on national unity vs. programmatic clarity.
  • Keynesian → Neoliberal shift: Mirrors global economic paradigm change; Canada follows but with regional twist (western populism, Québec sovereignty).
  • Leadership & nomination reforms: Reflect push for internal party democratisation, cost control, digital engagement—yet centralisation persists via leader veto.
  • Ethical dimension: Patronage legacy & finance reforms reveal tension between inclusivity, influence, and corruption prevention.

Numerical & Formal References

  • First system vote share: ≈95%\approx95\% split between two parties.
  • Two-and-a-half definition: top two parties ≥75%\ge75\% vote; third party presence.
  • Two-party criterion (Duverger): ≥90%\ge90\% vote for two parties.
  • Leadership legitimacy informal threshold: ≈70%\approx70\% renewal vote.
  • Election years of note: 1984,1988,1993,2011,20151984, 1988, 1993, 2011, 2015.

Potential Exam Triggers / Synthesis Points

  • Contrast catch-all vs. brokerage; provide Canadian examples.
  • Explain how realignments overlapped with economic paradigm shifts (tariff policy, Keynesianism, neoliberalism).
  • Assess whether Canada today fits Duverger’s prediction at national vs. regional level.
  • Discuss pros/cons of OMOV vs. delegate conventions with historical cases.
  • Evaluate impact of finance reforms on party organisational health (membership decline, “virtual parties”).