Law

LAW NOTES CHAPTER 5

Introduction to Arrests

  • Arrests can occur while a crime is in progress or following a police investigation.

  • Upon arrest, the individual is referred to as an accused, as opposed to a suspect.

  • Legal rights during arrest and trial are established by Sections 7-14 of the Canadian Charter.

  • These rights protect against unfair treatment in the criminal justice system.

    • Section 7: Guarantees life, liberty, and personal security, ensuring government respect for justice principles.

    • Individuals risk losing liberty upon conviction.

    • Includes the right to security from physical and psychological harm.

Limits on Police Conduct

  • Police cannot arrest solely based on a crime; they need reasonable and probable grounds.

  • Upon establishing grounds, police can:

    1. Issue an Appearance Notice: Used for summary conviction or less serious indictable offences, requesting the accused's appearance in court.

    2. Arrest the Suspect: Confines the suspect for serious offences to preserve evidence and prevent flight.

      • Officers can arrest without a warrant if there's reasonable belief of a crime.

      • Officers may use necessary force, but excessive force could lead to legal repercussions.

    3. Obtain a Warrant for Arrest: Used when locating a suspect is difficult. A summons orders the accused’s appearance; if involuntary, an arrest warrant may be issued.

  • Citizens can make a citizen’s arrest if they witness a crime, but must use reasonable force and surrender the suspect to police quickly.

Duties of a Police Officer

  • Responsibilities include:

    • Crime prevention, law enforcement, assistance to victims, maintenance of public order, emergency response, investigation, preserving peace, and laying charges.

  • Officers must maintain accurate logs of events which may serve as evidence.

  • Upon arrest, searching the accused for evidence is mandatory.

    • Searches must be conducted lawfully, adhering to privacy rights.

Body Searches & Evidence Collection

  • Body searches have strict guidelines:

    • Rubber gloves must be worn, and searches must be conducted by officers of the same sex.

    • Conducted only with reasonable grounds of drug possession.

    • Failure to comply with legality can lead to evidence being deemed inadmissible.

  • Following arrest, suspects may be fingerprinted, photographed, or subjected to lineups or DNA sampling, with refusals allowed in most cases except impaired driving incidents.

Policing Structure in Canada

  • Policing functions at three levels:

    • Federal: Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP).

    • Provincial: Ontario Provincial Police (OPP), Surete du Quebec, and the RCMP in other provinces.

    • Municipal: Local departments like Vancouver Police.

  • Police conduct is overseen via legislative, judicial, administrative, and constitutional frameworks.

  • Misconduct can result in evidence being inadmissible, leading to acquittals or civil actions against officers.

Legal Rights Framework

Sections 7-14 of the Charter include:

  • Right to security against unreasonable searches/seizures.

  • Promptly informed reasons for arrest or detention.

  • Right to counsel without delay.

  • Right to a determination of detention validity via habeas corpus.

  • The accused has rights to be tried promptly and is presumed innocent until proven guilty.

Rights During Arrest and Detention

  • Cooperation with police is advised, but remaining silent while waiting for legal assistance is permissible.

  • Police have powers to search without warrants under specific conditions, such as believing a concealed weapon is present.

Rights on Searches

  • Police require a search warrant to enter and search homes, which necessitates reasonable grounds and evidence.

  • Warrants must specify items to be seized; other items found during the search may also be retained under certain conditions.

  • New tele warrants expedite obtaining search warrants via electronic communication.

  • Controlled Drugs and Substances Act allows warrantless searches in certain locations on probable cause.

Summary of Detention Rights

  • Section 9: Right against arbitrary detention.

  • Individuals can legally refuse to answer police questions unless officially arrested.

  • Section 10: Right to know reasons and seek legal counsel immediately upon arrest.

Pre-Trial Release Procedures

  • Release can occur immediately upon arrest or after processing at the station, assuming no risk to public safety exists.

  • Bail may involve conditions like curfews or regular check-ins, especially for serious offences.

Habeas Corpus and Judicial Rights

  • The writ of habeas corpus protects against wrongful detention.

  • Accused must be exposed to trial within reasonable time frames.

Right to Counsel and Legal Processes

  • Section 10b ensures the accused's access to legal aid and counsel without delay upon arrest.

  • Defense has the opportunity to prepare a case based on disclosed evidence from the Crown.

Caution Regarding Plea Bargaining

  • Plea negotiations may pressure innocent defendants to plead guilty.

  • Discounted penalties in plea deals provide cost and time savings for the justice system, but may compromise justice quality.

Final Thoughts

  • Balancing individual rights with public safety is crucial but challenging, with risks of undermining law enforcement or civil liberties.

  • Legal processes, including arrests, searches, and trials, serve to navigate the complexities of justice in Canada.