Study Notes on Privilege, Power, and Difference
The Origins of Social Trouble and Difference\n\nAllan G. Johnson, Ph.D., argues that social conflict is rooted in systems of privilege and the lopsided distribution of power rather than difference itself. A prevailing cultural myth suggests human beings are naturally afraid of the unknown, yet Marshall Mitchell, who teaches disability studies at Washington State University, observes that children only develop fear of differences as they are socialized into existing structures of prejudice.\n\n# Mapping Identity and the Diversity Wheel\n\nMarilyn Loden and Judy Rosener developed the \"diversity wheel\" to illustrate how social characteristics position individuals within society. The hub of the wheel includes relatively unchangeable traits such as age, race, ethnicity, gender, sexual orientation, and physical ability. The outer ring includes religion, marital status, and class indicators like income or education. While these categories do not reflect an individual's inner soul, they dictate social reality and the material circumstances of one's life.\n\n# The Social Construction of Reality\n\nSociological concepts of race and disability are socially constructed rather than objective biological truths. James Baldwin noted that \"No one is white before he/she came to America,\" emphasizing that racial categories only acquire significance within systems of power. Paul Kivel and Adrian Piper describe how standards for racial classification, such as the \"one-drop rule\" for black ancestry versus the one-eighth requirement for Native American status, were historically designed to preserve white wealth. Similarly, disability is constructed by a dominant group that defines \"normalcy\" to exclude those using aids like wheelchairs, while including those using eyeglasses.\n\n# Mechanisms of Privilege and Oppression\n\nPeggy McIntosh defines privilege as unearned assets granted to individuals based on group membership. This includes unearned entitlements, which are rights everyone should enjoy, and conferred dominance, which gives one group power over another. Quantitative data highlights these disparities: whites represent 85 percent of illegal drug users but less than half of the prison population for drug charges. U.S. Census data shows the average white household has more than 14 times the net wealth of African American households, and men earn 50 percent more than comparable women on average. White income is 44 percent greater than that of African Americans and 60 percent greater than that of Latinas and Latinos.\n\n# The Paradox of Privilege\n\nPrivilege is a social arrangement granted based on perceived categories rather than individual character. Individuals may not \"feel\" privileged because they use their own social group as a reference group; for instance, men compare themselves to other men rather than women. Furthermore, privilege does not guarantee happiness and often creates psychological costs like guilt. Oppression is the flip side of privilege, described by Marilyn Frye as forces that hem people in. Only groups on the losing end of a power dynamic can be oppressed; thus, whites or males cannot be oppressed based on race or gender alone. Allan G. Johnson concludes that these systems are intrinsically linked to the history and expansion of capitalism.