Mere Christianity Review - Book 1

1. What is the Law of Human Nature?
The Law of Human Nature is the natural sense people have of right and wrong. It tells us how we should treat others, even though we do not always follow it.

2. What can we learn from listening to people argue, according to Lewis?
When people argue, they usually appeal to a standard of right and wrong that they both understand. This shows that people have a natural sense of how they should behave.

3. Explain: “Human beings, all over the earth, have this curious idea that they ought to behave in a certain way, and cannot really get rid of it.”
People naturally believe that there are certain ways they should behave. This shows that the Law of Human Nature is found in people everywhere.

4. What are the two points Lewis seeks to make?

  • People have a common idea of how they should behave.

  • People often fail to follow this standard even though they know it is right.

5. What is Lewis’s point about the Moral Law in this quote?
Lewis says that even people who claim there is no right or wrong still expect others to treat them fairly. This shows that people believe in some kind of Moral Law.

6. How does Lewis respond to people who say that morality is different between cultures?
Different cultures may have different moral rules, but they usually share basic ideas about right and wrong. The differences are mostly in how people apply those ideas.

7. What are the three objections people have to Lewis’s understanding of the Moral Law?

  1. Different cultures have different moral laws.

  2. The Moral Law is simply one of our instincts.

  3. The Moral Law is just a social convention.

8. Define the three objections.

  • Different cultures: People may have different ideas about what is right and wrong.

  • Instinct: The Moral Law is just a natural feeling or instinct, like protecting ourselves.

  • Social convention: Morality is simply a set of rules that society teaches people to follow.

9. What is the difference between physical laws of nature and the Law of Human Nature? Which is descriptive and which is prescriptive?
Physical laws describe what actually happens, such as gravity. The Law of Human Nature is prescriptive because it tells people how they ought to behave.

10. Explain the quote about the Moral Law not being like the Law of Gravitation.
The Moral Law does not just describe what people do; it tells us what people should do. We can recognize that something is wrong even when it is not simply inconvenient.

11. Define the Religious View and Materialist View.

  • Religious View: The belief that there is a Mind or God behind the universe.

  • Materialist View: The belief that matter and physical forces are all that exist.

12. What does Lewis mean when he says there is a mind behind the law?
He means that the Moral Law points to an intelligent Mind or God who is behind the universe and its moral standards.

13. Why do we have cause to be uneasy?
We know the Moral Law exists, but we often fail to follow it. This makes us aware of our mistakes and guilt.

14. When does Christianity begin to speak? Why?
Christianity begins to speak when we realize that we have done wrong and cannot perfectly follow the Moral Law. It explains how we can be forgiven and have a relationship with God.

15. How does Lewis argue that the Moral Law indicates a transcendent cause?
The Moral Law is greater than our personal opinions and preferences. This suggests that its source comes from something beyond the physical world.


Basic Tenets of Natural Law

16. What are the two views of what lies behind the Moral Law?
The Materialist View says there is only matter and physical forces. The Religious View says there is a Mind or God behind the universe and the Moral Law.

17. What is the most basic command of the Natural Law?
The basic command is that people should act rightly and treat others fairly instead of being selfish.

18. What does it mean to be good, and what does it mean to be evil?
Something is good when it fulfills its intended purpose. Evil is a lack or corruption of what is good.

19. If God created everything, why did He create evil?
God did not create evil as a separate thing. Evil comes from the misuse of free will and is a corruption or lack of goodness.

20. What are the three characteristics of the Natural Law?

  • Permanent

  • Unchanging

  • Universal

21. How do we come to know the Natural Law?
We come to know it through human nature and our conscience, which helps us recognize right and wrong.

22. Why is it difficult for us to truly know the Natural Law?
Our selfishness and desires can make it difficult to recognize and follow what is truly right.

23. Is the Natural Law Catholic dogma? Yes or No, and explain.
No. The Natural Law is not uniquely Catholic because people from many different cultures and religions recognize basic ideas of right and wrong.

24. Where can we find a summary of the Natural Law directly revealed by God? Why do we have trouble discerning the Natural Law?
We can find a summary of it in the Ten Commandments. We have trouble following it because our selfishness and desires can influence our understanding of right and wrong.


The Crocodile and the Axe Murderer

25. What problem do atheists have when arguing that torturing little children is objectively wrong?
Without God or an objective Moral Law, it is difficult for atheists to explain why something is absolutely wrong instead of simply something that people dislike.

26. What is the happiness standard or utilitarianism?
Utilitarianism says an action is morally good if it creates the greatest amount of happiness for the greatest number of people.

27. What is deficient in this standard? Can a materialist worldview produce the basis for an objective Moral Law?
Utilitarianism cannot always explain why something is wrong if it produces more happiness. A materialist worldview can describe how people behave, but it cannot fully explain why people ought to behave in a certain way.


Vocabulary

28. Define the following terms:

Moral Relativism: The belief that there is no absolute right or wrong and that morality depends on culture or personal beliefs.

Utilitarianism: The belief that the best action is the one that creates the greatest happiness for the greatest number of people.

Eternal Law: The order of creation that reflects God's will and purpose and never changes.

Evil: A lack, corruption, or spoiling of something that is good.

Good: Something that fulfills its intended purpose or design.

Instinct: A natural behavior or feeling that happens without being taught or carefully reasoned.