Chapter 4: Market Failures: Externalities and Asymmetric Information
Efficiently Functioning Markets
Market failures occur when markets do not produce the right amount of a product for society.
To achieve an efficient outcome, the following criteria must be met:
The market demand curve must reflect the full willingness to pay of every single person participating in the market.
The market supply curve must reflect all costs of production incurred by the producers.
Efficiency is measured through Total Surplus, which is calculated as:
Consumer Surplus
Consumer Surplus is defined as the difference between what a consumer is willing to pay for a good and what the consumer actually pays in the market.
It represents the extra benefit received by consumers when they pay less than their maximum willingness to pay.
Consumer Surplus Example (Equilibrium Price = \text{ dollars}):
Bob: Maximum Price Willing to Pay () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Barb: Maximum Price Willing to Pay () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Bill: Maximum Price Willing to Pay () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Beeja: Maximum Price Willing to Pay () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Brent: Maximum Price Willing to Pay () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Blessing: Maximum Price Willing to Pay () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Producer Surplus
Producer Surplus is defined as the difference between the actual price a producer receives (or producers receive) and the minimum price they would be willing to accept.
It represents the extra benefit received by producers when they receive a higher price than their marginal cost ().
Producer Surplus Example (Equilibrium Price = \text{ dollars}):
Chander: Minimum Acceptable Price () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Chaaya: Minimum Acceptable Price () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Chuck: Minimum Acceptable Price () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Chazen: Minimum Acceptable Price () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Chuma: Minimum Acceptable Price () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Chad: Minimum Acceptable Price () = \text{ dollars}; Actual Price = \text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = \text{ dollars}.
Efficiency Losses and Externalities
Efficiency losses, also known as deadweight losses, occur when the market fails to produce the optimal quantity of a good.
Underproduction: This occurs when the actual quantity produced is less than the equilibrium quantity (). The lost surplus is represented by a triangle between the demand and supply curves to the left of the equilibrium.
Overproduction: This occurs when the actual quantity produced exceeds the equilibrium quantity (). The marginal cost of production for those extra units exceeds the marginal benefit to consumers, resulting in an efficiency loss.
Externalities: An externality is a cost or benefit that accrues to a third party who is external to the market transaction.
Negative Externalities: These occur when production or consumption results in costs for third parties. They lead to supply-side market failures where too much of the product is produced (overallocation of resources).
Positive Externalities: These occur when production or consumption results in benefits for third parties. They lead to demand-side market failures where too little of the product is produced (underallocation of resources).
Government Intervention for Externalities
Governments use various tools to correct externalities and move the market toward the socially optimal output level.
Correcting Negative Externalities:
Direct Controls: Regulations that limit the amount of activity causing the externality.
Pigovian Taxes: Taxes placed on producers to reflect the external cost, shifting the supply curve to the left until it reflects the full social cost.
Correcting Positive Externalities:
Subsidies to Consumers: Direct payments or vouchers to buyers to increase demand.
Subsidies to Producers: Payments to suppliers to reduce the cost of production and increase supply.
Government Provision: The government steps in to provide the good directly when the positive externality is large.
Methods for Dealing with Externalities
Negative Externalities (Spillover Costs): Results in overproduction and overallocation of resources. Corrections include:
Private bargaining.
Liability rules and lawsuits.
Taxes on producers.
Direct controls.
Market for externality rights (Cap and Trade).
Positive Externalities (Spillover Benefits): Results in underproduction and underallocation of resources. Corrections include:
Private bargaining.
Subsidies to consumers.
Subsidies to producers.
Government provision.
Global Perspective: Effective Carbon Rates (2021)
Effective carbon rates vary significantly across different nations, representing different levels of intervention regarding carbon externalities. Data from the OECD (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development) shows the following approximate rates:
Brazil:
China:
United States:
Japan:
Mexico:
Germany:
South Korea:
France:
Norway:
Switzerland:
Optimal Abatement and the Coase Theorem
Society’s Optimal Amount of Pollution Abatement: The optimal level of reduction is found where the marginal benefit () of abatement equals the marginal cost () of abatement. At this point (), the social welfare is maximized. If , more abatement is needed; if , society is spending too much on abatement relative to the benefit.
Coase Theorem: Suggests that if property rights are clearly defined and bargaining costs are negligible, the private sector can bargain to solve externality problems without government intervention.
Government's Role: When private bargaining fails, officials must correctly identify the existence and cause of the externality. However, government failure can occur if the intervention leads to further inefficiencies.
Asymmetric Information
Asymmetric information occurs when one party to a transaction possesses private information that is not readily available to the other party at a low cost.
This imbalance causes scarce resources to be allocated inefficiently and typically requires government intervention.
When Sellers Possess Private Information:
Examples include the gasoline market (quality and octane) and the licensing of surgeons (ensuring competence).
When Buyers Possess Private Information:
Moral Hazard Problem: Occurs when a party behaves differently or takes more risks after a transaction is completed because they no longer bear the full costs (e.g., being less careful with a car after buying insurance).
Adverse Selection Problem: Occurs when the party with more info (the buyer) chooses to participate in the market in a way that harms the other party (e.g., only those with high risk of illness buying health insurance).
Policy Instruments: Cap and Trade
Governments aim to reduce visible pollution by accounting for marginal benefits and costs.
Cap and Trade System:
Setting a Cap: The government sets a limit on the total amount of emissions allowed.
Property Rights: The government assigns property rights to pollute through permits.
Market Mechanism: These rights can be bought and sold. Producers who can reduce pollution cheaply will sell their permits to those for whom reduction is more expensive, creating an efficient market-based solution for pollution reduction.