Chapter 4: Market Failures: Externalities and Asymmetric Information

Efficiently Functioning Markets

  • Market failures occur when markets do not produce the right amount of a product for society.

  • To achieve an efficient outcome, the following criteria must be met:

    • The market demand curve must reflect the full willingness to pay of every single person participating in the market.

    • The market supply curve must reflect all costs of production incurred by the producers.

  • Efficiency is measured through Total Surplus, which is calculated as:

    • Total Surplus=Consumer Surplus+Producer Surplus\text{Total Surplus} = \text{Consumer Surplus} + \text{Producer Surplus}

Consumer Surplus

  • Consumer Surplus is defined as the difference between what a consumer is willing to pay for a good and what the consumer actually pays in the market.

  • It represents the extra benefit received by consumers when they pay less than their maximum willingness to pay.

  • Consumer Surplus Example (Equilibrium Price = 88\text{ dollars}):

    • Bob: Maximum Price Willing to Pay (MBMB) = 1313\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = 13−8=513 - 8 = 5\text{ dollars}.

    • Barb: Maximum Price Willing to Pay (MBMB) = 1212\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = 12−8=412 - 8 = 4\text{ dollars}.

    • Bill: Maximum Price Willing to Pay (MBMB) = 1111\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = 11−8=311 - 8 = 3\text{ dollars}.

    • Beeja: Maximum Price Willing to Pay (MBMB) = 1010\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = 10−8=210 - 8 = 2\text{ dollars}.

    • Brent: Maximum Price Willing to Pay (MBMB) = 99\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = 9−8=19 - 8 = 1\text{ dollars}.

    • Blessing: Maximum Price Willing to Pay (MBMB) = 88\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Consumer Surplus = 8−8=08 - 8 = 0\text{ dollars}.

Producer Surplus

  • Producer Surplus is defined as the difference between the actual price a producer receives (or producers receive) and the minimum price they would be willing to accept.

  • It represents the extra benefit received by producers when they receive a higher price than their marginal cost (MCMC).

  • Producer Surplus Example (Equilibrium Price = 88\text{ dollars}):

    • Chander: Minimum Acceptable Price (MCMC) = 33\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = 8−3=58 - 3 = 5\text{ dollars}.

    • Chaaya: Minimum Acceptable Price (MCMC) = 44\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = 8−4=48 - 4 = 4\text{ dollars}.

    • Chuck: Minimum Acceptable Price (MCMC) = 55\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = 8−5=38 - 5 = 3\text{ dollars}.

    • Chazen: Minimum Acceptable Price (MCMC) = 66\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = 8−6=28 - 6 = 2\text{ dollars}.

    • Chuma: Minimum Acceptable Price (MCMC) = 77\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = 8−7=18 - 7 = 1\text{ dollars}.

    • Chad: Minimum Acceptable Price (MCMC) = 88\text{ dollars}; Actual Price = 88\text{ dollars}; Producer Surplus = 8−8=08 - 8 = 0\text{ dollars}.

Efficiency Losses and Externalities

  • Efficiency losses, also known as deadweight losses, occur when the market fails to produce the optimal quantity of a good.

    • Underproduction: This occurs when the actual quantity produced is less than the equilibrium quantity (Q2<Q1Q_2 < Q_1). The lost surplus is represented by a triangle between the demand and supply curves to the left of the equilibrium.

    • Overproduction: This occurs when the actual quantity produced exceeds the equilibrium quantity (Q3>Q1Q_3 > Q_1). The marginal cost of production for those extra units exceeds the marginal benefit to consumers, resulting in an efficiency loss.

  • Externalities: An externality is a cost or benefit that accrues to a third party who is external to the market transaction.

    • Negative Externalities: These occur when production or consumption results in costs for third parties. They lead to supply-side market failures where too much of the product is produced (overallocation of resources).

    • Positive Externalities: These occur when production or consumption results in benefits for third parties. They lead to demand-side market failures where too little of the product is produced (underallocation of resources).

Government Intervention for Externalities

  • Governments use various tools to correct externalities and move the market toward the socially optimal output level.

  • Correcting Negative Externalities:

    • Direct Controls: Regulations that limit the amount of activity causing the externality.

    • Pigovian Taxes: Taxes placed on producers to reflect the external cost, shifting the supply curve to the left until it reflects the full social cost.

  • Correcting Positive Externalities:

    • Subsidies to Consumers: Direct payments or vouchers to buyers to increase demand.

    • Subsidies to Producers: Payments to suppliers to reduce the cost of production and increase supply.

    • Government Provision: The government steps in to provide the good directly when the positive externality is large.

Methods for Dealing with Externalities

  • Negative Externalities (Spillover Costs): Results in overproduction and overallocation of resources. Corrections include:

    1. Private bargaining.

    2. Liability rules and lawsuits.

    3. Taxes on producers.

    4. Direct controls.

    5. Market for externality rights (Cap and Trade).

  • Positive Externalities (Spillover Benefits): Results in underproduction and underallocation of resources. Corrections include:

    1. Private bargaining.

    2. Subsidies to consumers.

    3. Subsidies to producers.

    4. Government provision.

Global Perspective: Effective Carbon Rates (2021)

  • Effective carbon rates vary significantly across different nations, representing different levels of intervention regarding carbon externalities. Data from the OECD (Organization for Economic Co-operation and Development) shows the following approximate rates:

    • Brazil: 11

    • China: 1010

    • United States: 2121

    • Japan: 2222

    • Mexico: 3030

    • Germany: 40.540.5

    • South Korea: 5050

    • France: 5555

    • Norway: 6767

    • Switzerland: 6868

Optimal Abatement and the Coase Theorem

  • Society’s Optimal Amount of Pollution Abatement: The optimal level of reduction is found where the marginal benefit (MBMB) of abatement equals the marginal cost (MCMC) of abatement. At this point (Q1Q_1), the social welfare is maximized. If MB>MCMB > MC, more abatement is needed; if MC>MBMC > MB, society is spending too much on abatement relative to the benefit.

  • Coase Theorem: Suggests that if property rights are clearly defined and bargaining costs are negligible, the private sector can bargain to solve externality problems without government intervention.

  • Government's Role: When private bargaining fails, officials must correctly identify the existence and cause of the externality. However, government failure can occur if the intervention leads to further inefficiencies.

Asymmetric Information

  • Asymmetric information occurs when one party to a transaction possesses private information that is not readily available to the other party at a low cost.

  • This imbalance causes scarce resources to be allocated inefficiently and typically requires government intervention.

  • When Sellers Possess Private Information:

    • Examples include the gasoline market (quality and octane) and the licensing of surgeons (ensuring competence).

  • When Buyers Possess Private Information:

    • Moral Hazard Problem: Occurs when a party behaves differently or takes more risks after a transaction is completed because they no longer bear the full costs (e.g., being less careful with a car after buying insurance).

    • Adverse Selection Problem: Occurs when the party with more info (the buyer) chooses to participate in the market in a way that harms the other party (e.g., only those with high risk of illness buying health insurance).

Policy Instruments: Cap and Trade

  • Governments aim to reduce visible pollution by accounting for marginal benefits and costs.

  • Cap and Trade System:

    • Setting a Cap: The government sets a limit on the total amount of emissions allowed.

    • Property Rights: The government assigns property rights to pollute through permits.

    • Market Mechanism: These rights can be bought and sold. Producers who can reduce pollution cheaply will sell their permits to those for whom reduction is more expensive, creating an efficient market-based solution for pollution reduction.