Polypharmacy and Deprescribing – Comprehensive Study Notes

Learning Outcomes

  • Knowledge
    • Describe polypharmacy and its impact on patients.
    • Identify situations warranting exploration of polypharmacy and deprescribing.
  • Skills
    • Confidently sign-post patients for medication reviews.
    • Apply a structured framework for ongoing medication use.
    • Facilitate shared decision-making in prescription management with older adults.
  • Attitudes
    • Promote public awareness of harms from inappropriate polypharmacy.
    • Support the cultural shift that “more drugs ≠ better care” in later life.

What Is Polypharmacy?

  • Simply: concurrent use of multiple medications.
  • Numerical thresholds have evolved as prescribing volumes rise:
    • Historically: 45\ge 4\text{–}5 drugs.
    • NICE NG56 (multimorbidity):
    • Always take a multimorbidity approach if patient has 15\ge 15 regular drugs.
    • Consider if taking 101410\text{–}14 or <1010 plus high ADR risk.
  • Key distinction: appropriate vs inappropriate / problematic polypharmacy—not just pill counts.
    • Example of appropriate: vigorous older adult post-MI + heart failure on 7–8 evidence-based agents.

Epidemiology & Trends

  • Average prescriptions per person ↑ 54 % in 10 years.
  • UK projections (2018): 3 million people managed via polypharmacy for long-term conditions.
  • Proportion on 10\ge 10 drugs: 1.9 % → 5.6 % (1995–2010).
  • One-third of ≥75-year-olds take ≥6 medicines.

Consequences of Polypharmacy

  • Taking 10\ge 10 medicines ⇒ higher hospital admission risk.
  • Adverse drug reactions (ADRs) cause 6.5 % of all UK hospital admissions, occupying 4 % of beds.
  • Prescription workload: 3 chronic diseases → 6–13 different daily drugs; 6 diseases → 18 drugs/day.

Interaction Types

  • Drug–Drug: e.g. cholinesterase inhibitors + anticholinergics (delirium episode 1.02).
  • Drug–Disease: e.g. NSAIDs worsening hypertension.
  • Multimorbidity multiplies interactions: analysis of 12 NICE guidelines found in diabetes guidance:
    • 133 serious drug–drug interactions; 25 (19 %) involved 1st-line agents.
    • 32 serious drug–disease interactions across 11 other conditions.

Prescription Cascade

  • New drug started to treat ADR of another drug.
    • Classic: amlodipine-induced oedema → furosemide prescription.
  • Visualised in OliviaSDON cartoon (Twitter link).

Medications Most Linked to ADR Admissions

  1. NSAIDs 29.6 %
  2. Diuretics 27.3 %
  3. Warfarin 10.5 %
  4. ACE-I 7.7 %
  5. Antidepressants 7.1 %
  6. Beta-blockers 6.8 %
  7. Opiates 6.0 %
  8. Digoxin 2.9 %
  9. Prednisolone 2.5 %
  10. Clopidogrel 2.4 %

Note: drugs provoking subtle presentations (frailty crises, vague malaise) likely under-recognised.


Why Older People Are More Vulnerable

Pharmacokinetic / Physiologic Changes
  1. Absorption
    • ↑ Gastric pH (H!!\text{+}↓) from atrophic gastritis / PPIs.
    • ↓ Gastric emptying.
  2. Distribution
    • ↑ Body fat, ↓ total body water.
    • Fat-soluble drugs (benzodiazepines) ⇒ ↑ volume of distribution ⇒ prolonged t1/2t_{1/2}.
    • Water-soluble drugs (digoxin) ⇒ ↓ Vd ⇒ need lower loading dose.
    • Blood–brain barrier permeability ↑ ⇒ greater CNS ADRs.
  3. Metabolism
    • ↓ Hepatic blood flow ⇒ impaired clearance of high-extraction drugs (e.g. amitriptyline).
    • Polypharmacy ⇒ higher likelihood of CYP450 induction / inhibition.
  4. Elimination
    • Renal mass & flow ↓; eGFR0.5%eGFR \downarrow 0.5\% per year after age 20.
    • Accumulation risk: diuretics, digoxin, NSAIDs.
Representation in Trials
  • Older, frail, cognitively impaired, multimorbid adults & care-home residents are under-represented; included elders usually “healthy”.

Anticholinergic Burden (ACB)

  • 20–50 % of older adults receive ≥1 anticholinergic drug.
  • Effects: dry mouth/eyes, constipation, urinary retention, blurred vision, tachycardia; plus sedation, confusion, hallucinations, functional/cognitive decline.
  • 23 % of dementia patients prescribed anticholinergics.
  • Systematic review: strong negative impact on cognition & physical function; delirium & mortality data limited.
  • ACB Scale
    • Literature 1966–2007 scanned for drugs with anticholinergic activity + cognitive harm.
    • Inter-disciplinary panel scored each drug (mild-moderate-severe).
    • Resources: printable PDF link provided in transcript.

Rationale for Deprescribing / Medicines Optimisation

  • Frail patients may not live long enough to realise preventive drug benefits (e.g. statins).
  • Continue meds giving day-to-day symptomatic relief (analgesia, anti-anginals).
  • Do not stop essential control drugs (antiepileptics, antiparkinsonian) without specialist input.
Common Barriers
  • Reluctance to discontinue another prescriber’s drug.
  • Time constraints.
  • Fear of withdrawal effects.
  • Limited resources / pharmacy access.
  • Patient / family resistance; concern over therapeutic relationship.

Structured Medication Review Protocol

  1. Ascertain All Drugs & indications (include prescriptions, OTC, CAM).
  2. Clarify Actual Use
    • Ask about missed doses in a specific recent period.
    • Explore daily habits without blame.
  3. Pharmacy Collaboration
    • Medication reconciliation, pill counts, contacting community pharmacy.
  4. Risk Stratification for Harm
    • Key predictors: total drug count, past toxicity, >65 yrs, dementia, multimorbidity, multiple prescribers, non-adherence, renal impairment, substance misuse, end-of-life.

Evidence-Based Deprescribing Tools

ToolPurpose & Highlights
STOPP/STARTScreening Tool of Older Person’s Prescriptions / to Alert doctors to Right Treatment. Delphi consensus. Use ↓ inappropriate scripts (ARR 35.7%35.7\%, NNS =2.8=2.8) & ↓ undertreatment (ARR 21.2%21.2\%).
STOPPFrail27 criteria for frail elders with limited life expectancy. Facilitates deprescribing of longevity-focused meds.
Beers Criteria (AGS 2015)US list of PIMs in older adults; originated with 11-member panel (1991).
NO TEARS6-point mnemonic for 10-min GP review: Need, Open questions, Tests, Evidence, Adverse events, Risk reduction, Simplification.
Consultant Pharmacy Services FactsheetsBite-sized deprescribing guides (allopurinol, antihypertensives, antiplatelets, BZDs, bisphosphonates, PPIs, statins, etc.).
Scottish Polypharmacy AppMobile decision support.
NNT.comQuantifies absolute benefits / harms to aid shared decisions.

Ethical, Cultural & Practical Considerations

  • Shift from disease-centric to person-centred care prioritising quality of life.
  • Engage patients/public via campaigns & shared decision aids.
  • Importance of interdisciplinary teamwork (GP, geriatrician, pharmacist, nurse, caregiver).

Curriculum & Competency Links (Highlights)

  • NHS KSF: Communication (Lvl 3–4), PPD (Lvl 1–3), Service Improvement (Lvl 1–2).
  • Foundation Curriculum: Safe prescribing, frailty, multimorbidity.
  • Core Medical / GP VTS / Geriatric Medicine: therapeutics, patient-centred care, long-term conditions, palliative aspects.
  • Dementia Core Skills Framework: Tier 2 pharmacological interventions.

Key Numbers & Formulae at a Glance

  • Hospital ADR admissions=6.5%\text{Hospital ADR admissions}=6.5\%.
  • Bed capacity used by ADRs=4%\text{Bed capacity used by ADRs}=4\%.
  • eGFR0.5%/yeareGFR \downarrow 0.5\%/\text{year} after 20.
  • Polypharmacy rise=54%/10yrs\text{Polypharmacy rise}=54\%/10\text{yrs}.
  • STOPP/START: ARRinappropriate=35.7%ARR_{inappropriate}=35.7\%, NNS=2.8NNS=2.8.

Quick Practical Checklist Before Every Script Refill

  • [ ] Confirm ongoing indication & benefit.
  • [ ] Screen for new ADRs / cascades.
  • [ ] Check renal & hepatic function.
  • [ ] Review ACB score.
  • [ ] Cross-reference STOPP/START or Beers.
  • [ ] Discuss with patient: goals, preferences, life expectancy.
  • [ ] Document plan & monitoring requirements.