Economic Development and Policy

Economic Development and Policy

Outline of Topics to Cover

  • Factors Leading to Economic Growth

  • Traditional Theories: Capital and Savings

  • Recent Work: Role of Institutions, Culture, Colonialism

  • Implications for Policy

  • The Role of Geography

Understanding Economic Growth

  • Definition: Economic growth refers to a sustained increase in economic prosperity, typically measured by the total goods and services produced in the economy (Gross Domestic Product, GDP).

  • Historical Context: The last two centuries have experienced unprecedented economic growth compared to previous human history.

  • Importance of Economic Growth:

    • Essential for alleviating poverty that has persisted globally, affecting a vast portion of the population even today.

The Importance of Economic Growth

  • Societal Values: Economic growth is not the only metric for a healthy society; it enables improvements in leisure, health, literacy, and environmental protection.

  • Complementarity: Growth and other values (e.g., environmental conservation, social rights) can coexist; economic growth provides resources for addressing societal issues like carbon emissions.

  • Robert Lucas' Insight: The complexity of economic growth raises vital questions about government actions and their implications for human welfare.

Traditional Theories of Economic Growth

  • Key Questions: Why are some countries rich while others are poor? How can poorer economies catch up?

  • Evolution of Economic Thought: Economic growth theories have evolved from emphasizing investment to focusing on technological advancement, human capital, and institutions.

Harrod-Domar Growth Model
  • Main Idea: Capital investment drives economic growth, implying an increase in GDP is proportional to savings designated for investment.

  • Historical Context: Influenced policy, particularly during the Cold War, leading to substantial foreign aid to developing nations (e.g., $14 billion aid in 1985 dollars).

  • Shortcomings:

    • Mechanical investment-growth relationship without considering diminishing returns or the incentives of economic actors.

    • Lack of empirical support for some of its assertions.

Solow Growth Model
  • Key Modification: Introduces diminishing returns to capital investment, suggesting that growth attributable to capital accumulation is only transitional.

  • Long-run Growth Source: Technological progress is the primary driver of sustained long-run growth.

  • Key Prediction: All nations should converge in income levels; poorer countries can grow faster than rich countries if they can adopt technology without barriers.

Evidence of Divergence

  • Contradicting the Solow Model: Some evidence shows divergence in income levels between rich and poor countries since 1960, with the richest countries growing further from the poorest.

  • Statistical Trends:

    • The ratio of GDP per capita between the richest and the poorest countries increased significantly from 1870 to 1990.

Extensions to the Solow Model

  • Augmented Solow Model: Incorporates education and health (human capital) to explain income differences.

  • Big Push Theory: Advocates for coordinated investments across different sectors to overcome “coordination failures” in development.

The Role of Institutions in Economic Growth

  • Institution Definition: Institutions refer to the rules and structures that govern economic and political interactions in a society.

  • Importance: Institutions shape incentives for investment, innovation, and effort, crucial for understanding growth.

  • Acemoglu and Robinson’s Findings: Their research highlights that inclusive institutions promote growth while extractive institutions hinder it.

  • Examples of Economic Institutions:

    • Property rights security, competitive market access, and the ability to organize businesses.

Inclusive vs. Extractive Institutions
  • Inclusive Institutions: Promote broad participation in the economy, enforce property rights, and support development through equitable governance.

  • Extractive Institutions: Centralize power, discourage investment and innovation, and exacerbate economic inequality.

Effects of Colonialism on Institutions

  • Historical Legacy: Extractive institutions established during colonization, particularly in former colonies with high settler mortality, persist today and affect development trajectories.

  • Impact of the Slave Trade: Areas with high slave exports exhibit lower GDP and worse political institutions, leading to economic challenges.

The Role of Geography in Economic Development

  • Geographical Limitations: Geography impacts economic possibilities; landlocked nations, for example, face trade disadvantages.

  • Disease Environment: Malaria and tsetse fly disease environments influence economic growth and state formation in various regions, particularly Sub-Saharan Africa.

Summary and Implications for Policy

  • Long-run Factors: Institutions, culture, and geography critically shape development outcomes.

  • Policy Considerations: Recognizing historical contexts can improve policy formulation, adapting strategies for sustainable economic growth and addressing issues of trust and credibility.

  • Next Steps in Research: Exploration of reforming institutions and understanding their impact on growth will continue in future discussions.