Every Thought Captive: Notes on Taking Your Thoughts Back
Challenging Thoughts
Everything vies for our attention, and our thoughts are intentionally placed to capture our thinking. It's crucial to actively challenge our thoughts, as the Bible warns that our thoughts can take us captive if we don't take them captive first.
The Impact of Thoughts
Our thoughts shape the pattern of our lives. A pattern of distraction can lead to a fragmented, worried, upset, and disconnected existence. Choosing to focus on Jesus rewires our brains, creating new patterns that enable us to choose what is better. The choice is ours whether to conform to the world or submit to God's transforming work through the renewing of our minds, as mentioned in Romans 12.
Introduction to the Book Club
The summer book club will discuss "Every Thought Captive" by Kyle Idleman, a message that is both timeless and timely. The aim is to explore how life would change if we could learn to take every thought captive to be obedient to Christ. This transformation of our minds is not just a theological concept but an experiential reality facilitated by the Holy Spirit.
Meet the Guides
Jamie Snyder, with twenty years of teaching and preaching experience, recently joined Southeast Christian Church in Louisville, Kentucky. He collaborates with Kyle Idleman on sermon content and research. Jamie describes Kyle as authentic and a leader worth following.
Hannah Brencher, based in Atlanta, Georgia, is a writer, author, and mental health advocate. She emphasizes optimizing our minds and living healthy, forward-moving lives. Hannah appreciates the practicality of "Every Thought Captive", as it answers the question of "how" to implement these concepts.
Logistics of the Book Club
The first meeting to delve into section one of the book will be on Wednesday, June 18, at 7:30 PM. Subsequent meetings will be held weekly at the same time. Participants should acquire the book in their preferred format (hardcover, Kindle, audiobook) by the first meeting. Even if you fall behind, attending the club is encouraged due to the book's wealth of concepts and real-life applications.
Interview with the Author: Kyle Idleman
Motivation Behind Writing the Book
"Every Thought Captive" stemmed from a personal journey and observations as a pastor. Kyle noticed that certain scriptures he frequently used were increasingly supported by scientific findings. This led him to explore the intersection of faith and science in bringing about transformation.
Defining "Taking Every Thought Captive"
Kyle clarifies that taking every thought captive does not simply mean stopping negative thoughts. Instead, it involves recognizing habitual thinking patterns, understanding their origins, and assessing their impact on our lives. This process includes:
Interrogating the thought: Where did it come from?
Evaluating its impact: How is it working for me?
Replacing it: Substituting with God's thinking (cognitive reappraisal or transformative thinking).
The Tension Between Effort and the Holy Spirit
Transformation requires both our active participation and the work of the Holy Spirit. Romans 12 emphasizes not being conformed to the world's mold but being transformed by God. We must intentionally resist conforming influences to be in a position to be transformed by the Holy Spirit.
Conforming can be envisioned as a cookie mold, shaping whatever is inside it. Paul advises against passively fitting into the world's way of thinking. Instead, we should identify what is molding us and intentionally resist those influences.
Becoming Curious About Our Thoughts
It's essential to become curious about the origins and impact of our thoughts. Thoughts can become habits, automatically recurring upon waking or before sleep. Kyle shares how his therapist described these thought loops as roller coaster rides, suggesting we need to shut down the amusement park entirely and build a new one.
Committing to this process is a lifelong journey. Neural pathways are established over time, and neuroplasticity allows us to change our brains through intentional thinking.
The Power of Curiosity
Instead of shaming negative thoughts, we should approach them with curiosity. Kyle shares a personal example of realizing he held the belief that asking for help was not an option for him because helpers should not ask for help. Nobody had ever told him this, but he had this idea stuck in his head. This stronghold affected his marriage, parenting, and ministry. He traced the thought back to feeling he should not ask for help as a child.
Another example involves a friend who lost his father in middle school, leading to the thought that "nobody knows how I feel." This thought persisted for decades, creating distance in relationships. Emotional associations, especially from traumatic events, can strongly establish neural pathways.
Actionable Steps:
Identify the thought.
Get curious about its origins.
Recognize its impact.
Replace it with God's word.
Normalizing the Conversation
It's crucial to normalize discussions about mental health and remove stigma. All of us are on a mental health journey, and many neural pathways are formed in childhood. It's important to take inventory of our thoughts and understand why we think the way we do.
The Impact of Input
We often underestimate the impact of what we expose our minds to throughout the day. The mere exposure effect suggests that we tend to think about what we are most exposed to. Hannah's book on unplugged hours relates to this, emphasizing the conforming influence of screens and content.
Practical Exercise:
Keep a thought journal to track what you are exposing your mind to, similar to a nutrition journal for healthy eating.
The Interplay Between Anxiety and Anger
Kyle recalls a moment when Hannah was feeling angry and that she may want to pick up a book about anger. When she began to read Every Thought Captive she learned a lot of times anger is just anxiety in disguise.
CS Lewis on Anger
Kyle cites C.S. Lewis, who wrote, "I sat with my anger long enough that she told me her name was Sadness."
Breaking Patterns of Offense
Our thoughts might cause us to take comments from people and start down a neural pathway where we take it personally and have an attitude of "what's this supposed to mean?"
The Story of Kyle's Email With A Harsh Comment
Kyle tells of a time someone in the church sent him a very harsh email. He was going to call the number and lash out, but something made him hold and call the person. Because the individual only saw it was a church number, they thought it was about their son. Turns out the man's son overdosed, so it gave Kyle a different perspective on the situation. God gave him a new neural pathway to take an offensive comment toward me.
Practical Implications
The solution is for us to look at some of those patterns of thinking and responses and ask how we are doing. God has a new way to think about it.
Avoiding Shame and Judgment
Instead of shaming or judging our thoughts, we should approach them with curiosity. The Bible encourages us to ask God to search our hearts and help us understand ourselves. This requires creating space for introspection, free from distractions.
Inviting the Holy Spirit to reveal our anxieties and insecurities is essential. Confession, in the sense of bringing hidden thoughts into the light, can bring healing. Sharing our struggles with others in a community can loosen the grip of strongholds.
Prioritizing Quiet Time
It is key to prioritize quiet time spent with God. A lot of believers would go into quiet time with their cell phones, leading to a distracted nature. Instead, it would be better to place a physical bible on the countertop to promote an alternative, faithful reaction.
Seeking The Proper Source
It is vital to seek the proper source to provide comfort rather than what we think is comfort. When we grab our phones to check-in we are really checking out.
Leveraging Mornings
Kyle shares the importance of giving God your morning. It changes thinking in such a manner that we respond rather than react.
Scientifically:
Your brain is more receptive in the morning so it is a good idea to open up neural pathways. If one took the first 15 minutes of the morning to simply pray through the day, it can shape thoughts throughout the entire day.
In Scripture:
Jesus spent time with God early in the morning in Mark 1.
It is important to be intentional in the morning to give God the morning. Ten to fifteen minutes of intentional thoughts and taking them captive is more than enough during them morning.
There Are No Shortcuts
It is important to understand there will not be any shortcuts to spiritual growth. God will not compete with distractions until the time is silent.
Even with big demands, Jesus had to stop and pray through the night.
It is important to not just read but to think through what God's word is saying and applying it to strongholds.
Saying It Out Loud
Hearing yourself think has power, while speaking your thoughts activates a larger part of the brain. After researching and writing the book, when Kyle reads God's word, he always reads aloud.
Closing Remarks and Prayer
Kyle expresses gratitude to Hannah and Jamie for leading the book club and emphasizes the importance of tearing down strongholds and experiencing freedom through intentional surrender to God. He prays for humility, intentionality, broken molds, and true transformation for the participants.
Jamie encourages viewers to invite friends and family, emphasizing that this journey is for everyone. He expresses belief in the transformative power of the Holy Spirit and hopes participants can look back with gratitude for noticeable ways they have been transformed.