Study Notes: Writing the Analytical Paragraph for Susan Glaspell's Trifles
Analytical Assignment Overview and Dilemma Selection
Core Focus of the Assignment:
The analysis centers on the play Trifles by Susan Glaspell (also referred to as Susan Glasswell / Susan Lasple).
The assignment requires constructing an outline and introductory paragraph evaluating moral and ethical dilemmas presented in the text.
The Two Central Dilemmas:
Dilemma 1: The Actions of the Women (Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters):
The women actively discover, conceal, and tamper with evidence in the Wright household.
Because of their actions, the investigating police officers fail to find any evidence that can be used to convict Minnie Wright.
The dilemma concerns whether their choice to protect Minnie and lie/hide evidence from law enforcement is justified.
Dilemma 2: Minnie Wright's Actions:
Minnie Wright sits in jail for the murder of her husband, John Wright.
The dilemma concerns her primary act of killing John Wright.
Selection Requirement:
Exactly one dilemma must be chosen for the analysis (either the women covering up the evidence or Minnie Wright killing John Wright).
The selection should be based on which situation is better understood, easier to relate to, or preferred by the writer.
Ethical and Moral Evaluation:
Writers must evaluate the chosen actions through an ethical and/or moral lens.
Actions can be categorized as:
Both ethical and moral.
Neither ethical nor moral.
Ethical, but immoral.
Unethical, but moral.
The writer must determine the precise reasons why they view the actions under these designations.
Analytical Elements and Textual Evidence
Selection of Analytical Lens:
To explain and justify the ethical or moral judgment, the writer must choose one specific literary element from four available options:
Historical Setting
Setting
Symbolism
Dynamic Character
Detailed Breakdown of the Four Elements:
Historical Setting:
Time Period: Late 1800s to early 1900s.
Focuses on how the historical era, legal constraints, and societal expectations of women at the turn of the century influence the morality or ethics of the actions.
Setting:
Physical Locations: The isolated farm, the cold environment, the kitchen, and the barn.
Focuses on how the physical spaces where the women uncover clues—and their sharp spatial contrast with the male investigators—drive the actions and ethical judgments.
Symbolism:
Specific Symbols: The bird (canary), the birdcage, and the word "trifles."
Focuses on how these physical and thematic symbols explain the motives, suffering, and moral justification of the characters.
Dynamic Character:
Focuses on the internal and behavioral transformations exhibited by the female characters throughout the play:
Minnie Wright (Minnie Foster):
Past: When she lived in town, she was young, lively, and beautiful; she was involved in a social lodge, sang in church/town choirs, and participated in community social activities.
Married Life: Isolated on the farm, cut off from all former social engagements.
Transformation: Undergoes a massive shift from a vibrant, social woman into a killer.
Mrs. Peters:
Initial Stance: Strictly aligned with legal duty and external ethics; vocalizes that "it's the law, and the law is to punish crime."
Transformation: Experiences a radical shift; ends up hiding the dead bird, lying to the police, and actively participating in the cover-up.
Mrs. Hale:
Initial Stance: Enters without believing or wanting to believe that Minnie is guilty.
Transformation: Realizes fully that Minnie committed the crime, but chooses to protect her anyway due to shared guilt and female solidarity.
Formatting and Paper Layout Guidelines
Assignment Location:
Assignment guidelines and materials are located on Canvas in Chapter 9.
Top Left-Hand Heading Specifications:
Placed at the very top on the left margin of the paper.
Must include four specific lines in exact order:
Line 1: Student Name
Line 2: Instructor Name
Line 3: Class Identifier:
ENG 1123 SCY3(ENG 1123 scy 3)Line 4: Date:
10/21/2026(due date)
Title Formatting:
Skip down exactly one line below the left-hand heading block.
Center the title horizontally on the page.
The title must be the exact name of the literary element chosen for the paper:
Historical SettingSettingSymbolismDynamic Character
Paragraph Architecture and Topic Sentence Construction
Paragraph Formatting:
Skip a line below the centered title.
Indent the first line of the paragraph.
Topic Sentence Function and Core Elements:
The topic sentence serves as the single sentence that provides the complete focus and roadmap for the entire paragraph.
It must synthesize five mandatory elements into one cohesive sentence:
Author's Full Name: Susan Glaspell (or Susan Glasswell / Susan Lasple).
Title of the Work: Trifles.
Selected Literary Element: Historical Setting, Setting, Symbolism, or Dynamic Character.
Ethical/Moral Stance: Explicit evaluative diction demonstrating the writer's position (e.g., "justify," "ethical," "unethical," "moral," "immoral").
Selected Dilemma: Clear identification of the subject—either Minnie Wright (the killing of John Wright) or the women (Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters covering up evidence).
Topic Sentence Models and Analysis:
Provided Baseline Model:
Sentence: "In Susan Glaspell's Trifles, the symbolism used in the play helps to justify the death of John Wright."
Structural breakdown:
Author and Title: "Susan Glaspell's Trifles"
Element: "symbolism"
Ethical/Moral stance: "helps to justify" (demonstrates the writer considers the act morally/ethically vindicated)
Dilemma: "the death of John Wright" (clearly indicates Minnie Wright's dilemma, as she was the cause of his death)
Alternative Model (Variation):
Sentence: "The symbolism used in Susan Glaspell's Trifles helps the reader to understand the ethical and moral actions of Minnie Wright."
Alternative Moral Nuance Example:
Analysis using symbolism arguing that an action was "unethical but moral."
Stylistic Rules and Adaptations:
Writers may adopt the baseline sentence model, reorder clauses, or rephrase it to suit their specific thesis.
When addressing the dilemma of the women, writers are permitted to refer to them collectively as "the women" in the topic sentence and introduce the names Mrs. Hale and Mrs. Peters later in the paragraph, or name them directly from the beginning.