Risk Representation: Social representations theory Lecture 3
Introduction As we’ve noted, risk perception field focuses on: – Certain errors/biases in the public’s risk perceptions, compared to expert assessments – Certain pre-specified dimensions of the risk itself (e.g. dread, controllability & preventability) – Certain demographic trends in risk perception However, it tells us little about the patterns of meaning /content of thought pertaining to a given risk
Introduction Require theories and methods other than those contained in the psychometric model, if want to know how people conceptualise the threats they face naturalistically

The Social Representations Approach Social representations theory (SRT) is a social psychological theory for studying lay people’s uptake of societal phenomena, especially new phenomena (Moscovici, Duveen & Macey, 2008)
The Social Representations Approach Conceptualised by Serge Moscovici in the 1960s, social representations theory (SRT) aims to provide a systematic, scientific study of ‘commonsense’ thinking SRT = scientific study common sense. There is no scientific study of common sense
Definition of a Social Representation Widespread ‘ensemble of thoughts and feelings’ about a given phenomenon akin to a ‘lay theory’ or ‘lay explanation’ – this collection thoughts/feelings can be expressed by individuals but is underpinned by socio-cultural, historical and groupspecific ideologies. eg how freudian theory which is from vienna assimilitated into french society, same think howpsychoanalysis assimilitated into french society lakin to a catholic confession. Communists thought psychoanalysis was too individualist. An individual is a product b their system around them.
Scope of SRT SRT provides a systematic study of people’s common sense thinking, which involves examining: 1. where it ORIGINATES 2. what FORM it takes i.e. the CONTENTS of such thinking 3. what FUNCTIONS it serves for those who ascribe to it
1. ORIGIN of the social representation Scientific ideas, filtered through the mass media, are posited to provide the seeds of lay representations of many risks this is particularly so for health risks where medics tend to identify the threats (e.g. risk from what was originally termed GRID, now AIDS as it was associated with gay people) and the media popularises it WHICH OTHER RISKS DOES/DOESN’T THIS ORIGIN APPLY TO?
ORIGIN The content of many social representations originates in the ‘reified’ universe (e.g. science) and circulates thereafter in the more ‘consensual’ universe (the mass media and lay thinking) (Moscovici, 1984) The public or publics tend to get to know about the risk once the media convey the ‘reified’ knowledge to their audiences
"Human beings generate representations not so much by a reasoning or computing process as by a process of communicating…". (p.951) (Moscovici, 1984 `The myth of the lonely paradigm: a rejoinder’, Social Research, 51, 939-969) not just the media, but also social clubs, pubs etc
SRT can appear to postulate a top-down mechanism, where ideas are communicated ‘down’ from science, via the media, into lay thinking However, in emphasising that representations are shaped in the process of communicating, the theory recognises that people play a role in creating the common sense ideas that circulate
2. FORM taken by the social representation Two processes are at work in forming the representation: a. Anchoring = The new, potential danger is assimilated in terms of seemingly similar known dangers
past ideas are imposed upon the new event that needs to be understood (e.g. 2009/10 Swine Flu was anchored to the Spanish Flu of 1918 as a way of trying to assimilate/understand it) CONSEQUENCES? They thought it was gonna be way worse than it actually was. Monkeypox
b. Objectification The new danger is also assimilated in terms of the symbols, metaphors and images held within the groups apprehending the new event Event which needs to be understood is linked to symbols, metaphors and images to make it more concrete. eg the imag eof a polar bear on melting iceberg, the image of forest burning, flooding
People transform links to past ideas (which anchoring sets up) into concrete mental content, to allow themselves to apprehend the new event (e.g. Matron in MRSA (see Washer, Joffe & Solberg 2008, Joffe, Washer & Solberg, 2011)) Matron came up s the solution for mrsa, perticular figures sometimes emoboidy what could solve a crisis. CAN YOU THINK OF SYMBOLS OF OTHER MASS RISKS?
Anchoring and objectification processes produce either alarm or complacency in ‘common sense’ regarding the new phenomenon: e.g. if Covid-19 was anchored to SARS, which killed 800 people worldwide, it would not have been seen as alarming e.g. if MRSA objectified in authoritative matron figure, could allay fear – but she was seen as absent. Amplificiation and attenuation
3. FUNCTIONS served by people’s social representations I. Identity-protection people are motivated to represent events in a way that protects the self and in-group from threat this is a form of symbolic coping, no less important than material coping, in the face of danger (see Wagner, Kronenberger & Seifert, 2002) eg Ebola was connected to Africa , aids to gay people, we symbolically cope by associating the danger with another continent, social group, optimism bias,
II. Status quo maintenance: SRT maintains the dominance of certain ideas and groups (see Jost, Ledgerwood & Hardin, 2010) African with traditional medicine, the west thought to helped them with modern medicine. Ebola has been spreading in Africa
III. Facilitates communication: allows people to converse since they hold the same frames of reference
Three major differences between cognitive theories and SRT Epistemological The nature of knowledge, its presuppositions and foundations Concern with context Group vs individualbased
The epistemological position of SRT Can think of theories of risk in terms of Lupton’s (1999/2024, Risk, London: Routlege) distinctions
Realist perspective Most common way in which risk is addressed is from a realist perspective – cognitive science has adopted this position: – Holds central the calculation of the ‘real’ seriousness of the risk – Looks at whether lay people ‘understand’ its ‘real’ seriousness
Critique “ill-masked contempt for lay people’s lack of what is deemed to be ‘appropriate’ or ‘correct’ knowledge of the risk” (Lupton, 1999, p.19) ‘cognitive science does not generally take into account the symbolic meanings, created through the social world, that humans give to things and events. Perception is limited to how humans see and understand the world through their senses and brainfunctioning, without acknowledging the ways in which cultural conceptual categories mediate judgement.’ (Lupton, 1999, pp.22-23)
Constructionist perspective Another way in which risk is addressed is from a constructionist perspective, termed the sociocultural perspective by Lupton, sees risk as having become a central cultural and political concept – “Those who have adopted social constructionism…tend to argue that a risk is never fully objective or knowable outside of belief systems and moral positions” (Lupton, 1999, p.29) Risk is not an objective phenomenon but one that is constantly constructed as part of social interaction and the formation of meaning
Critique Bodily/visceral experience is denied – deaths in holocaust/genocides; experience of illnesses such as Covid-19 and of earthquake
Between the realist and constructionist perspective The social representations approach falls between these two poles – it is what Lupton (1999) terms a ‘weak constructionist’ theory Those working in the SRT field tend to assume that although there is usually a material basis to what are deemed risks, yet how people engage with the risk is socially constructed
Following from this, SRT focuses on the contents of people’s risk-related thinking without reference to the ‘reality’ of the risk The concern is not with the accuracy of the representation but with what meanings people attach to a given risk and the functions of such meanings for them, for others and for the society
Concern with context/messages in the social environment Such meanings result from the interplay between media messages and how people engage with the risk This interplay can: Create or avert a health or safety scare Get people to take, or prevent them from taking, precautions Indicate who the in/out-groups are in a given society eg for aids, a heterosexual man may not take precautions as they are not gay. ANything largeoy blamed on the outgroups of society
Group-based representations SRT is far less focused on the individual than cognitive theories=> The aim of a number of studies is to examine how particular groups or cultures view a given risk versus focusing on individual differences
Following from these three foci, in practice, what does a SRT-based study of a risk examine? Exploration of the content of what people say about threats (versus numerical estimates of chances of being affected or relative chances of being affected for self’ vs others’) => Focus on the messages that exist in the environment (rather than purely on individual cognitions) Focus on widespread, group-based representations of the threat (in the place of mean OB levels, individual heuristics, personalities of risks)
Methods used Diverse methods used, often in same study – interviews, questionnaires, free association tasks, content analysis of media, individual cognitions
Are both quantitative and qualitative traditions of research within the SRT domain former = often to establish how much consensus there is in a given population, regarding a certain idea e.g. Green, Krings, Staerklé et al. (2010) Keeping the vermin out: Perceived disease threat and ideological orientations as predictors of exclusionary immigration attitudes. Journal of Community and Applied Social Psychology, (20) 4, 299-316
e.g. in study MRSA participants prompted to write in each box any word, image or feeling that came to mind upon hearing the term ‘MRSA’ latter = concern with contents of the meanings of the phenomenon made by different groups Joffe, H & Elsey, J. (2014). Free Association and the Grid Elaboration Method. General Review of Psychology, Vol. 18, No. 3, 173–185
Critique of SRT Lack of linear, predictive theorising and falsification (Fife-Shaw, 1997) => adopts `qualities of an article of faith’ (FifeShaw, 1997) since cannot be proven wrong (not falsifiable)
Rejoinder Science is concerned with the systematic production of knowledge, yet being systematic to be faithful to the data not to satisfy dominant criteria of `good science’
Instead of assuming that the natural sciences should form the prototype for all scientific enquiry, propose: work becomes scientific by adopting methods appropriate to its subject matter (Silverman, 1993)
In this case the subject matter is a: “network of interacting concepts and images whose contents evolve continuously over time and space” (Moscovici, 1988, `Notes towards a description of social representations’, European Journal of Social Psychology, 18, 211-250 p.220)
Rejoinder Furthermore, the very aspiration of prediction is not uniform across the sciences Sarewitz (2010) calls for more sciences to abandon it Sarewitz, D. (2010). World view: Tomorrow never knows. Nature, 463, 24.
->The power of a concept lies in the interpretation it allows: Is it plausible & robust? Does it incorporate the possibility of revision and expand knowledge? (Silverman, 1993)
Why use SRT? A strength of the social representations framework as a theory of public engagement lies in its ability to see members of the public’s accounts of a given risk as forms of knowledge in their own right rather than as deficient forms of scientific knowledge (see Duveen, 2008)
Why use SRT? A theory of: 1. how these ‘common sense’ notions are formed 2. their content 3. the functions they serve is particularly useful for policy makers seeking to understand how risk-related thinking ‘works’ and might be challenged and changed E.g. the matrons and msra, they symbol of the matron would have been important to people and it made them feel threatened ina hospital enviroment.
Why use SRT? o On a practical note, the more naturalistic studies often carried out within the SRT rubric have advantages for interventions: “one must understand the behavior from the perspective of the population for whom the interventions are being developed. Once understood this way, these … can serve as the basis for messages” (Fishbein & Cappella, 2006), practicial to do this studies as you understand the public’s perspective
Concluding comments: What is a `social representation’? In a nutshell: A widespread way of thinking about a phenomenon (e.g. MRSA) that originates in communication between different institutions (e.g. science, the mass media) and individual minds; whose form is dominated by how it is anchored and objectified; which functions to protect the identity of the person representing the phenomenon/maintain the status quo/facilitate communication
Concluding comments Very different from cognitive models of risk perception epistemologically and otherwise Can be critiqued, but this needs to be set against its utility as a theory Having heard this lecture, can you suggest a few interesting studies using this theory to explore a risk issue?