E
Boston Massacre Discussion
Introduction to the Boston Massacre
Historical context: The Boston Massacre is a significant event with varying perspectives.
Acknowledgement of uncertainty: "Like many historical events, we don't know exactly what happened."
Emphasis on eyewitness accounts being the primary source of information.
Eyewitness Assignment
Previous assignment concept: Students were asked to reflect on an event in their life and interview another person about it to see differing perspectives.
Example given: Interviewing about a trip to Disney World; child may remember joy and fantasy, while the parent remembers logistical challenges and expenses.
Key Objective for Students
Students must read testimony and determine who is at fault for the Boston Massacre in a one to two-page paper.
Clarification on taking a position: Each student must choose either the colonists or the soldiers, not both.
Paper Structure
Suggested format:
Opening paragraph: Background information and a clear thesis statement (e.g. "The colonists are at fault.").
Paragraphs on reasoning: Evidence supporting the chosen position.
Conclusion: Summarize the argument.
Importance of clarity in argumentation without ambiguity.
Efficiency in writing: The paper is worth 25 points, thus should require a reasonable amount of time (suggested insight: a couple of hours).
Historical Context of the American Revolution
Outline of Key Events
Referred to a previous outline discussing the origins of the American Revolution.
Mentioned John Adams’s reflections on the changes in American society before 1776.
Important Influences
The Great Awakening: Increased questioning of authority and deference.
The Enlightenment: Ideas about life, liberty, and property began changing mindsets in the colonies.
Salutary Neglect: British policies that allowed American self-governance, leading to tension when Britain attempted to reassert control.
Key Complaints of American Colonists
Categories of Complaints
Taxes: Both direct and indirect taxes were contested.
Representation: Discussion of virtual vs. actual representation.
General Search Warrants: Termed writs of assistance; allowed for extensive searches by customs officials.
Vice Admiralty Courts: Military courts bypassing juries, leading to unfair trials.
Timeline of Events
Discussion of the Proclamation Line of 1763: Resentment from wealthy land speculators due to restrictions on western expansion.
Sugar Act: Lowered molasses tax but aimed at stopping smuggling, angering merchants.
Stamp Act: Required printed materials to carry a stamp, leading to boycotts and its eventual repeal.
Townshend Acts: Taxes on consumer goods led to organized boycotts and increased tensions.
Establishment of military presence in the colonies by 1768.
The Boston Massacre
Background Information
Incident occurred in March 1770; only a few casualties but significant in propaganda.
Crispus Attucks: Noted as the most famous victim, a runaway slave; the reasons for his notoriety discussed.
Events Leading to the Boston Massacre
A British soldier encountered a 13-year-old apprentice (wigmaker's apprentice) leading to insults and a mob formation.
Despite the soldier's initial attempts to remain composed, escalating tensions led to the soldiers calling for backup as the crowd grew aggressive.
Execution of Orders: Soldiers charged their bayonets but did not initially receive an order to fire from their officer.
Chaotic Outcome
One soldier fired into the crowd, leading to a chaotic response and multiple civilians being killed or injured.
Differing perspectives on the event:
Colonel perspective framed by Paul Revere and other propagandists.
Colonists portrayed as peaceful protestors, thus stirring public sentiment against the British.
Implications
While the event was depicted as unprovoked aggression by the British, the reality included hostility from civilians who were involved in provoking the soldiers.
Development of Colonial Unity and Resistance
Committees of Correspondence
Formed to exchange information and coordinate resistance against British policies and legislation.
Tea Act of 1773
Aimed to aid the struggling British East India Company, modifying tea prices and allowing direct sales to merchants.
Anger from established merchants and disruptions in established trade networks.
Boston Tea Party
Protest manifested in the destruction of 340 chests of tea in Boston Harbor by disguised colonists.
Coercive Acts (Intolerable Acts)
In response to the Boston Tea Party, these five punitive measures were enacted to assert control over Massachusetts:
Closure of Boston Harbor.
Suspension of the Massachusetts colonial assembly.
Transfer of trial rights for criminals to London.
Enforcement of the Quartering Act requiring colonists to house British troops.
Immunity of British soldiers from colonial laws.
Continental Congress and Revolutionary Sentiment
First Continental Congress (1774)
Unity among colonies to address grievances with British governance; discussions included varying perspectives from different regions (New England vs. South).
Second Continental Congress
Convened in response to growing unrest and military readiness among colonies, notably in Boston.
Emergence of Loyalists
About one-third of the population remained loyal to the British crown.
Social Composition of Loyalists: Wealthy individuals in the North favored stability, while the poor in the South often aligned against wealthier planters.
Significance of Events Leading to Armed Conflict
The refusal of both parties to compromise and increasing militarization led eventually to the outbreak of war.
Lexington and Concord: The first military engagements leading to the American Revolution, with notable figures like Paul Revere playing crucial roles in alerting colonists to impending battles.
Conclusion of the Lecture
Anticipation of future discussions on the revolution, with assignments and preparations outlined for students, including a quiz and an impending paper.