Bone Load and Material Properties Summary

Bone: Load and Material Properties

Composition of Bone

  • Type 1 collagen:
    • Makes up 90% of the total collagen in bone.
    • Also present in other connective tissues like tendons, ligaments, menisci, fibrocartilage, and joint capsules.
    • Responsible for the tensile strength of the tissue.

Properties and Loading of Bone

  • Strength and Stiffness: These are important mechanical properties of bone.
  • Cortical vs. Cancellous Bone:
    • Cortical bone is stiffer and can withstand greater stress but less strain compared to cancellous bone.
    • Cortical bone fractures when strain exceeds 2% of its original length, while cancellous bone fractures at a greater length (75%).
  • Modulus of Elasticity:
    • Cortical bone has a high modulus of elasticity (17-25 GPa), similar to wood. It exhibits high stiffness and low compliance.
    • Trabecular bone has a low modulus of elasticity, low stiffness, and high compliance.
  • Bone is not as strong in tension as in compression, and its strength depends on density (mineralization) and the orientation of trabeculae relative to the load.
  • Bone is much stronger when the load is applied along its long axis.
  • Both cortical and trabecular bone can withstand greater stress and undergo less strain in compression than in tension.
  • The physiological response of trabecular bone to increased loading is hypertrophy. If loading is decreased or absent, the trabeculae become smaller and weaker.
  • The rate, frequency, duration, magnitude, and type of loading all affect bone.

Loading Behaviors

  • Bone strength varies depending on the direction of loading (anisotropic).
  • When cortical bone is loaded in compression, longitudinal sections of the bone show the greatest strength.
  • Compressive strength of bone is about 250 MPa, which is greater than concrete (about 4 MPa) or wood (100 MPa) but less than steel (400 to 1500 MPa).

Energy Storage in Bone

  • Varies with the speed of loading (strain-rate sensitivity).
  • Higher the speed of loading, the more energy the bone stores to failure.
  • Implications for fractures: Fast loading results in more energy stored, requiring more energy to be dissipated, leading to more damage.

Loading Behaviors: Wolff’s Law

  • Bone is laid down in areas of high stress and reabsorbed in areas of low stress.
  • Bone adapts to the stresses applied to it and the lack of stress applied to it.
  • Applies to all amounts of loading: too little, too much, or just right.

Appropriate Loading

  • During development, bones can adapt and accommodate mechanical stresses and strains through force transmission.
  • Allows for eventual weight-bearing on legs and alternation in infant bony structure (e.g., hip anteversion).
  • Develops trabecular systems that correspond to the type of loading expected, usually compressive forces, bending, and gravity.
  • The neck of the femur undergoes bending stresses, with the superior aspect experiencing tensile stress and the inferior aspect experiencing compressive stress.

Under-loading Bone: Immobilization

  • Reabsorption occurs.
  • Alteration of trabecular systems (adapting to load or lack thereof).
  • Decreased mineral density.
  • Bones become ‘weaker’.

Non-weight Bearing

  • Microstructural deterioration of cortical and trabecular bone seen following 6 weeks of non-weight bearing (NWB) in otherwise healthy persons.
  • Decreased stiffness and decreased load-to-failure, especially in cortical bone.
  • Decreases persisted (improved but not to baseline) even after 13 weeks of full weight-bearing.

Overloading Bone: Fractures

  • Tensile force: Avulsion fracture.
  • Bending force: Angled or greenstick fracture.
  • Combination produces oblique fracture.
  • Torsion or tensile/bending: Transverse fracture.
  • High force with rapid loading causes compressive fracture.

Wolffe’s Law (Overload): Fatigue Fractures

  • Produced by low repetition of high load or high repetition of relatively normal load (high impact aerobics).
  • Remodeling is outpaced by the fatigue process (not allowed to heal before the next failure or before adaptation to prevent failure can occur).
  • Repeated loadings, either high numbers of low loads (stress fracture) or one application of high load (fracture), can cause permanent strain and bone failure.
  • Bone loses stiffness and strength with repetitive loading as a result of creep strain. Creep strain occurs when a tissue is loaded again and again while the material is undergoing creep.

Applications/Discussion: Development

  • As babies become more upright, the loading on the bone changes to allow for standing, walking, running, etc.
  • Developmental issues or issues with the neuromuscular system can lead to changes in loading the bones and consequences of altered loading.

Applications/Discussion: Stress Fractures

  • Overuse may lead to stress fractures.
  • Pertinent comments the patient has made in the history may point to this.

Applications/Discussion: Wolffe’s Law - Repair and Remodel Bone Spurs & Fractures

  • Heel spur: Relatively sustained tension through plantar fascia onto the attachment site on the calcaneus.
  • Fracture: Callus that forms increases the area around the fracture site, increasing the stiffness and strength of the bone.
  • Pins/screws: Create stress risers where stresses concentrate around the defect, decreasing stress distribution over the site. There is a cycle of decreased energy storage until bone remodels, increasing strength unless the pin/screw is removed, which creates another defect, decreasing strength/stiffness.
  • Bone graft: At donor site changes stresses.

Applications/Discussion

  • Need to understand the relationship of the change to bone as a result of the change in articular cartilage.
  • Need to understand the concept and implications of focal loading.

Applications/Discussion: Osteoporosis

  • Decreased mineral density leads to 'weaker' bones.
  • Need to know the implications for manual therapy with someone with osteoporosis.