Rawls Slides(1)

Liberalism: John Rawls, A Theory of Justice

I. Introducing Rawls

John Rawls is a crucial figure in modern political philosophy, particularly regarding the concept of justice. His work challenges the traditional notions of utilitarianism and seeks a framework for justice that emphasizes fairness and equality among individuals.

II. Elements of A Theory of Justice

The Hypothetical “Social Contract”

Rawls proposes a conceptual framework for justice, which hinges on the idea of a social contract. This social contract is hypothetical, allowing individuals with diverse interests to come together in a mutually agreed-upon framework that respects everyone's rights and aspirations.

The Original Position & the Veil of Ignorance

At the heart of Rawls' theory is the Original Position, an imaginative construct in which rational individuals determine principles of justice without any knowledge of their future social status or personal characteristics. This is facilitated by the Veil of Ignorance, ensuring that no biases influence the decision-making process. By stripping away knowledge of one’s own place in society, this thought experiment encourages fairness and impartiality in establishing the principles that will govern social cooperation.

III. The Requirements of Reason: The Two Principles of Justice

1. LIBERTY

Rawls asserts that each individual possesses equal rights to extensive liberties that are compatible with the liberties of others. Key liberties include:

  • Freedom of Speech: The right to express opinions without censorship.

  • Freedom of Assembly: The right to gather collectively for peaceful purposes.


  • Protection from Arbitrary Arrest: Legal safeguards against unjust detention.Notably, exceptions from the basic structure of liberties can include the freedom to own means of production and engage in contracts without restrictions.

2. EQUALITY

  • Equality of Opportunity: All individuals should have fair opportunities to attain positions and roles within society. This necessitates equitable access to resources, education, and social networks that enable skill acquisition.

  • The Difference Principle: This principle articulates that any socio-economic inequalities must be structured in a way that benefits the least advantaged members of society, thereby promoting social justice and welfare.

IV. Some Questions about "Justice as Fairness"

Several critical questions arise in the exploration of Rawls' principles of justice:

  • Are the principles truly universal and egalitarian, grounded in rational justification?

  • Do the principles reflect a political framework rather than a metaphysical one?

  • What aspects constitute the "basic structure of society" according to these principles?

Who is John Rawls (1921-2002)?

John Rawls was an American philosopher renowned for his influential contributions to political philosophy, particularly during his tenure at Harvard University. His landmark works include A Theory of Justice (1971) and Political Liberalism (1993). Rawls emphasized the importance of justice in philosophical discussions and introduced the concept of Ideal Theory, which defines moral standards in just interactions, instead of merely addressing remedial injustices.

Elements of A Theory of Justice

Social Contract

The social contract proposed by Rawls is theoretical, establishing a consensus among individuals pursuing varied self-interested goals rather than purely altruistic ones. This approach seeks to legitimize governance through the collective agreement on fundamental principles.

Original Position and the Veil of Ignorance

The Original Position revitalizes classical social contract theories by placing rational agreement on the principles that will govern society as the priority. Decisions appearing behind the Veil of Ignorance, devoid of individual biases, help ensure that the resulting principles are fair and just.

On the “Veil of Ignorance”

Under the Veil:

  • Decision-makers have no awareness of their social position, abilities, personal assets, or societal conditions.

  • This lack of knowledge prevents biases and self-interest from skewing the principles of justice.

The Requirements of Reason: Two Principles of Justice

1st Principle: LIBERTY

The first principle guarantees equal rights to liberties, which should not infringe upon the rights of others.

2nd Principle: EQUALITY

  • Equality of Opportunity: All societal roles should be accessible to everyone, fostering fairness.

  • The Difference Principle: Advocates for inequalities only if they lead to the betterment of the least advantaged, promoting a just and equitable society.

More on the Two Principles

The two principles have a lexical ordering, with liberty taking precedence over equality. This ordering emphasizes that while equality of opportunity is crucial, individual freedoms remain paramount. The push for equality of opportunity includes provisions for skill acquisition, which is essential for a fair meritocracy and potentially more equitable than the strict application of the Difference Principle.

Questions persist regarding the universality, logical consistency, and metaphysical foundations of these principles, as well as the comprehensive definition of justice inherent within the social structure.