Economic Systems
Economic Systems
Why America's Economic Success?
- "Land of opportunity" - success through hard work, regardless of background.
- Open land, natural resources, uninterrupted immigration.
- Free enterprise - freedom and flexibility to pursue business ideas.
- Promotes economic growth.
What is an Economic System?
Economic systems must answer three questions:
- What to produce?
- How to produce?
- For whom to produce?
Different Kinds of Economic Systems
- Traditional
- Command or Planned Economy
- Free Market or Pure Capitalism
- Mixed Economies
Traditional Economic System
- Traditions, customs, belief systems, and inheritance determine the answers to the three economic questions.
- Prevalent in underdeveloped areas (South America, Africa, Asia).
- The World Bank estimates prevalence among 400 million indigenous people.
- Operates through bartering and trading with little surplus.
- Most produce only enough to keep their families alive.
- Surplus may go to a landowner or ruling authority.
- Based on subsistence-based agriculture.
Command or Planned Economy
- The central government or authority determines the answers to the three economic questions.
- The central government owns and manages the economic resources.
- The government is the final authority on decisions regarding production, utilization, and allocation of revenues.
Socialism and Communism
- Socialism:
- Belief that democratic means should distribute evenly throughout society.
- The working class should take over and run things collectively.
- Focuses on the economic system.
- Communism:
- Centrally planned economy with economic and political power in the hands of the central government.
- Requires strict obedience (authoritarian).
- The idea that society should not have classes.
- An extreme form of socialism that shapes both the economic and political systems.
- Example: Former Soviet Union (1920s-1991) - Collectives, heavy industry.
Examples of Command Economies
North Korea
- Central government and economy under the control of the communist Korean Workers’ Party.
- Determined to maintain control.
- All natural resources, railroads, aviation, transportation, postal and communicational institutions, major factories, businesses, ports and banks are owned by the state.
- Permits limited personal ownership (savings, home appliances, everyday items).
- Individuals can dispose of personal belongings, and inheritance is allowed.
- No personal ownership is allowed of the factors of production.
Disadvantages of a Planned Economy
- Central planners cannot effectively coordinate production, leading to shortages and surpluses.
- Valuable resources are not used efficiently.
- Innovation and productivity are stifled.
Free Markets or Capitalism
- What to produce?
- The competitive market determines what to produce (“the invisible hand”).
- Very limited government involvement (“Laissez-faire”).
- The market will produce goods that can be sold at a profit.
- Consumers vote with dollars.
- Producers must adapt to the changing environment.
- How to produce?
- Firms have an incentive to minimize costs due to competition and the desire to make a profit.
- Efficient production methods are employed; resources tend to be allocated efficiently.
- Technology and innovation are instrumental to success.
- For whom to produce?
- Those willing and able to pay.
Adam Smith
- (1723-1790): Offered an explanation of how a market economy works.
- Authored The Wealth of Nations.
- Called for laissez-faire, meaning "let them do (as they please)."
- Insisted that the government leave individuals as free as possible to pursue their own interests.
- Businesses could provide goods and services needed without government direction.
- Individuals pursuing their own interests make decisions that ultimately benefit the nation.
- The “invisible hand” guides a nation’s resources to their most productive use.
Free Market - Advantages
- Resources are allocated efficiently (productive as well as allocative efficiency).
- Freedom of enterprise (own your own business).
- Freedom of economic choice (buy what you want, work where you want).
- Encourages innovation and new technology.
- Variety of goods.
- High degree of customer satisfaction.
Free Market - Disadvantages
- The benefits of competition can be eroded by monopoly power.
- Inequitable distribution of income (land and capital owned by the few).
- The young, old, disabled, and poor are not able to pay for goods and services.
- Market failure can occur due to a lack of information, and not all costs (pollution) or benefits (public health) are properly accounted for.
Mixed Economies
- Most economies are mixed economies.
- Tradition, government, and markets each answer some of the WHAT, HOW, and FOR WHOM questions.
- There is often so much overlapping that it’s hard to define the economy.
America’s Mixed Economy
- A mixture of command and free market systems.
- Government involvement in the economy is acceptable in varying degrees.
- Government might own key industries such as transportation and communication.
- Government provides safety nets for the disadvantaged.
- Government regulates and/or protects against market failures.
- Government helps stabilize the economy through fiscal and monetary policy.