Notes Polk Part II

1. The Mexican-American War (1846-1848)

  • America defeated Mexico in a decisive war.

2. President Polk's Decision

  • Reasons for war included territorial expansion and disputes over Texas.

  • Polk's decision to not seek re-election in 1848 was unexpected.

  • Speculation surrounds his health, notably gastrointestinal issues.

3. Election of 1848

  • Democrats: Nominated Lewis Cass, former Senator and Secretary of War, who narrowly lost to Polk in 1844.

  • Whigs: Nominated Zachary Taylor, a military hero with no political experience.

  • Free Soil Party: Nominated former President Martin Van Buren, opposing the expansion of slavery into the western territories.

    • Not abolitionists; accepted slavery in the South but sought to limit its spread.

4. Stance on Slavery by Major Parties

  • Democrats and Whigs avoided taking a firm position on slavery to appeal to voters from both the North and South.

5. Campaign Issues

  • Emphasis on candidate personalities rather than substantive political issues.

  • Taylor’s popularity as a war hero impacted Whig campaigning.

6. The Mexican Cession

  • Question arose regarding the status of slavery in territories ceded by Mexico.

7. Proposed Solutions to Slavery Issues

  • 1. Wilmot Proviso

    • Proposed banning slavery in all territories acquired from Mexico.

    • Confrontation around Congress's authority to regulate slavery was crucial,

    • Historical precedence: Northwest Ordinance of 1787 excluded slavery in the Northwest Territory.

  • 2. Extension of the Missouri Compromise

    • Advocated maintaining the line established by the Missouri Compromise of 1820 to limit slavery.

    • Supported by Polk but met with opposition from Free Soilers and Conscience Whigs.

  • 3. Popular Sovereignty

    • Proposed by Senator Stephen Douglas as a balance between pro and anti-slavery factions.

    • Enabled settlers to decide on the legality of slavery in their territories through voting.

    • Attempted to alleviate North-South tensions while avoiding positions on slavery.

8. Constitutional Argument

  • John C. Calhoun and the Fire Eaters claimed Congress could not restrict slavery in the territories, equating slaves to property under the Constitution.

9. Election Results of 1848

  • Zachary Taylor (Whig) emerged victorious in the 1848 presidential election, largely drawing support due to his military fame.

10. The Mexican Cession as a Continued Issue

  • The question around the status of the Mexican Cession, alongside inequalities in representation and governance, posed challenges leading to the Compromise of 1850.