September 7th Reading SMAD
Chapter 2: The Evolution of Media Technology
1. Main Idea of the Chapter
Technology is an important part of every form of mediated communication.
media tech not does develop independently
Technology is influenced by:
Media industries — how companies choose to use and develop technology.
Users — whether people adopt technology and how they use it.
Government — how technology is regulated.
Technology can create major social changes, but people and society also shape how technology develops.
2. History of Media Technology
Early Communication
For most of human history, communication was primarily face-to-face and oral.
Humans later developed:
Cave artwork
Stone carvings
Clay tablets
Bamboo and papyrus writing
Numbers
Written language
Paper and Printing
Around 100 CE, papermaking developed in China.
Around 600, printing using carved wooden blocks began in China.
Around 800, books were printed using wooden blocks.
Around 1000, movable clay type was used in China.
Around 1200, movable metal type was developed in Korea.
Around 1450, Johannes Gutenberg developed the modern hand-operated printing press with movable type in Germany.
Growth of Media Technology
During the 19th century, technological development became much faster.
Important developments included:
Newspapers
Telegraph
Photography
Telephone
Sound recording
Electric light
Motion pictures
Radio
During the 20th century:
Television developed.
Computers developed.
Cable television expanded.
The internet emerged.
During the 21st century:
Smartphones
Social media
Streaming
Tablets
Wearable technology
Virtual reality
Smart speakers
3. New Media Usually Do NOT Destroy Old Media
One important point in the chapter is that new media usually add to older media rather than completely replacing them.
Examples:
Radio did not destroy print.
Television did not destroy radio.
The internet did not destroy television.
Instead, different forms of media have accumulated, creating a more complicated media environment.
4. Technological Determinism vs. Social Constructionism
These are two major ways scholars think about the relationship between technology and society.
Technological Determinism
Technology is viewed as an important cause of social change.
Technological developments can have effects that people did not intend or fully understand.
This approach places greater emphasis on the power of technology.
Basic idea:
Technology → Social change
Criticism:
Critics argue that this approach can ignore human agency.
Technology is made of inanimate objects, so humans make choices about how technology is developed and used.
Social Constructionism
Social constructionism emphasizes the role of people and social forces.
Humans decide how technologies are developed and used.
Technology is influenced by:
Cultural values
Economic pressures
Laws and regulations
Users
Social practices
Basic idea:
People + society → Technology
Social constructionists still recognize that technology matters, but they emphasize that technology and society influence each other.
Important point:
The chapter says these two approaches should not necessarily be viewed as complete opposites.
Most scholars fall somewhere between the two extremes.
5. Materiality of Technology
The physical characteristics of technology matter.
Examples of physical media technology:
Phones
Screens
Keyboards
Paper
Even things that seem nonphysical have a material foundation.
Example: The Internet
The internet is not literally an invisible “cloud.”
It depends on physical infrastructure such as:
Cables
Servers
Buildings
Equipment
Why materiality matters
Each medium has different capabilities and limitations.
For example:
Medium | What it can mainly provide |
|---|---|
Text and pictures | |
Radio | Sound and live communication |
Film | Sound, pictures, and video |
Television | Sound, pictures, video, and live programming |
Internet | Text, sound, pictures, video, live content, and interactivity |
The internet is especially different because it can combine many forms of media and allow interaction.
6. Autonomous Technology
Langdon Winner used the term “autonomous technology.”
The idea is that technology can sometimes appear to develop beyond people's ability to control it.
People create technology.
However, technology can have unintended consequences.
Complex technological systems can become difficult to control.
The chapter gives:
Artificial intelligence
Machine learning
Algorithms
as examples of technologies that can potentially have effects that their creators do not completely understand.
7. Technological Momentum
Thomas Hughes developed the idea of technological momentum.
When technology is new:
People have greater control.
There are many possible ways it can develop.
Creators and users negotiate how it should be used.
As technology becomes established:
It becomes standardized.
People become accustomed to it.
Institutions and industries develop around it.
It becomes harder to change.
Example:
The chapter compares this to a boulder rolling down a hill:
At first, humans have to push it.
Once it begins moving, its momentum makes it harder to stop or redirect.
8. Medium Theory
Medium theory focuses on the idea that the medium itself can influence society, not just the content carried by the medium.
Medium theorists believe:
Media are more than simple channels for messages.
The characteristics of a medium can affect how people experience and understand the world.
Media technology can influence social life.
9. Marshall McLuhan
Marshall McLuhan was an important figure in medium theory.
His famous idea was:
“The medium is the message.”
His argument was that the important thing is not simply what media contain, but how the experience of using a particular medium changes people and society.
McLuhan argued that print:
Emphasized the visual sense.
Required people to use their eyes to read.
Separated visual experience from other senses, especially sound.
Electronic Media
McLuhan argued that electronic media:
Combined sound and images.
Could reconnect senses that print had separated.
Allowed people to experience events from distant locations almost instantly.
Global Village
McLuhan believed electronic communication could create a “global village” by connecting people across distances.
10. Criticism of Technological Determinism
The chapter discusses critics who argue that technology alone does not determine social outcomes.
For example:
Television did not automatically become entertainment-focused simply because of its technology.
The television industry was shaped by commercial interests.
Companies wanted audiences because audiences could be sold to advertisers.
The internet's emphasis on engagement and entertainment is also influenced by commercial forces.
Therefore, economic and social forces matter along with technology.
11. Social Constructionism in Media
Social constructionism emphasizes that humans actively shape technology.
Social reality is created in three steps:
People create society through physical and mental activity.
Over time, these creations appear to be objectively real and separate from human activity.
People internalize the norms and values of their culture.
Because people create social reality, people can also change it.
12. Raymond Williams and Television
Raymond Williams argued against the idea that television simply “altered the world” by itself.
He showed how television developed differently in the United States and Britain because of different social values.
United States
More individualized social values.
Television became privately owned and commercial.
Programming was designed to attract audiences.
Advertisers supported the system.
Britain
More collectivist social values.
The BBC was owned and funded by citizens.
Television focused more on public service.
Main lesson:
The same basic technology can develop in different ways depending on society's values and institutions.
13. Domestication Theory
Domestication theory focuses on how ordinary people bring technology into their homes and everyday lives.
Users:
Adapt technology to their own needs.
Use technology in unexpected ways.
Can influence how future technologies are developed.
Therefore, users are not simply passive consumers.
14. Print Technology
Johannes Gutenberg's printing press used movable metal type.
Effects of printing:
Books became more affordable.
Books became more widely available.
Literacy increased.
Learning became more accessible.
People could increasingly learn without depending on a mentor.
Ideas spread more quickly across cultures.
Printing and the Protestant Reformation
The printing press helped spread the ideas of the Protestant Reformation.
Literate believers could read the Bible themselves, sometimes challenging the Catholic Church's interpretation and authority.
Printing and thinking
Written communication encouraged:
Linear organization of ideas
Reasoned arguments
Disciplined communication
The chapter connects these developments to Western philosophical and scientific thinking.
15. Limits of Print
Print communication depended on physical transportation.
Information could only travel as fast as:
Horses
Trains
Ships
could carry it.
Consequences:
Information traveled slowly.
European information could take weeks to reach the United States.
News between American cities could take days.
Publications tended to remain local.
Media culture was fragmented and isolated.
16. The Telegraph
The telegraph changed communication because it allowed information to travel over long distances almost instantly.
Important change:
The telegraph separated communication from physical transportation.
Newspapers could:
Receive stories quickly.
Send reporters' stories over long distances.
Print the information locally.
Wire services
Wire services created content that could be used in multiple markets.
This:
Spread news faster.
Made news available in more places.
Helped create a more unified news culture.
Problem: Centralized control
Telegraph technology encouraged centralized control.
By the 1870s, Western Union controlled the nationwide telegraph network.
The chapter uses this as an example of how control over technology can influence what information is available.
17. The Telephone
Alexander Graham Bell received a patent for the telephone in 1876.
The telephone became an important communication system and later helped other media.
AT&T
AT&T eventually became a major telephone monopoly.
Its four divisions included:
Bell companies — local telephone service
AT&T Long Lines — long-distance service
Western Electric — communications equipment
Bell Labs — research and development
Government regulations protected the monopoly.
Advantages of the monopoly:
Standardized equipment
Broad telephone access
Generally high-quality service
Disadvantages:
High costs
Less competition
Some innovations were delayed or suppressed
18. Breakup of AT&T
In 1982, AT&T agreed to be broken into eight separate “Baby Bell” companies.
This increased:
Competition
Innovation
Access to long-distance services
Long-distance prices dropped sharply.
However, the companies later reconsolidated.
By 2018, the former Baby Bells had largely become part of three major telecom companies:
AT&T
Verizon
CenturyLink
Main lesson:
The history of the telephone shows that government regulation, competition, companies, and users all influenced technological development.
19. Sound Recording
Sound recording made it possible to preserve music and sound.
Development:
Early phonograph recordings
78-rpm records
LP records
Cassette tapes
CDs
MP3s
Digital music
Streaming services
Effects on music:
Before recordings:
Music was mainly experienced through live performances.
Performances happened in public places.
After recordings:
People could listen at home.
People could replay music whenever they wanted.
Listening became more individualized.
20. Recording Technology Changed Music
Recording technology affected how musicians created music.
Three-minute recordings
Early 78-rpm records could hold about three minutes per side.
This influenced musicians to create shorter pieces.
The three-minute format continued with 45-rpm singles and became common for popular music.
Studio recording
As recording technology developed:
Studio recordings became increasingly important.
Complex recordings could be created that were difficult or impossible to perform live.
The chapter uses the Beatles as an example of artists whose later studio recordings became difficult to reproduce on stage.
21. Digital Music and Streaming
Digital technology changed the music industry again.
MP3s made music easier to distribute online.
Digital music eventually became the majority of music sales.
Streaming services later became a major source of digital music revenue.
Streaming allows users to:
Access large catalogs.
Choose what they want to hear.
Listen without purchasing individual recordings.
22. Film and Video
Photography allowed visual experiences to be permanently captured.
Modern movies developed in 1895, when Auguste and Louis Lumière demonstrated their cinematograph.
Early movies were often about:
News
Travel
Everyday life
Sports
Eventually, filmmakers began producing more elaborate fictional stories.
23. The Film Trust
In the 1910s, a group of companies known as the Film Trust controlled much of the U.S. film industry.
Because the Trust controlled important patents:
Competition was restricted.
Creativity was limited.
Films were generally short.
Foreign films were restricted.
Actors were often unknown and poorly paid.
Europe
France and other European countries did not have the same film cartel.
Feature-length films and well-known actors developed more quickly there.
Hollywood
Independent U.S. filmmakers resisted the Film Trust.
They moved away from New York and eventually established filmmaking in Los Angeles.
This helped lead to the development of the Hollywood movie industry.
24. VCRs, DVDs, and Online Video
Later technologies changed how people experienced movies.
VCR
Allowed people to rent or purchase movies.
Made watching movies at home easier.
Privatized the movie experience.
Digital technology
DVDs moved movies toward digital formats.
Digital cameras and smartphones made video production easier.
Users could record, edit, and store their own videos.
Online platforms
Websites such as YouTube and Vimeo allowed users to:
Upload videos.
Store videos.
Share videos.
Bring personal videos into the public sphere.
25. Radio Broadcasting
Radio developed during the first two decades of the 20th century.
Its major difference from the telegraph and telephone was broadcasting.
Instead of sending a message to one specific person:
Radio could send audio to anyone within range.
People could receive broadcasts using radio equipment.
Radio made possible:
Live programming
Free content
Individualized media experiences
26. Radio Was Not Always Meant to Be Broadcasting
At first, radio was called the “wireless.”
Guglielmo Marconi viewed it as:
A telegraph without wires.
A point-to-point communication system.
Amateur radio operators began experimenting with the technology.
They:
Built transmitters and receivers.
Communicated over long distances.
Helped develop radio as a leisure activity.
Helped create the idea of broadcasting.
Main lesson:
The way radio developed was influenced by users, not simply its inventors.
27. Government and Control of Radio
Different groups wanted control of radio's airwaves:
Corporations
Wanted private control for profit.
U.S. Navy
Wanted government control for military and security purposes.
Amateur radio users
Viewed the airwaves as public property that citizens should be able to use.
The Radio Act of 1912 required transmitting stations to receive government licenses.
This reduced amateur access and helped establish a system of:
Centralized senders
Large numbers of individual listeners
28. Television
Television combined:
Film's moving images and sound
Radio's ability to broadcast live
Early television technology was mechanical.
Electronic television eventually became practical because it produced better-quality images.
Early television industry
The companies that dominated radio also became major television companies.
This meant:
NBC
CBS
ABC
became dominant television networks.
Early television often looked like radio with pictures because existing radio programs were moved to television.
29. Television and Family Life
Television was marketed as a form of entertainment that could take place inside the home.
Television became extremely widespread:
By 1955, television sets were in about 65% of American households.
By 1960, they were in about 90%.
The television industry both:
Adapted to existing family routines
Tried to change family routines
30. Television Programming and Women
Early television producers believed middle-class women were an important audience.
Radio worked well while women were doing housework because listening did not require looking at a screen.
Television created a problem because it required visual attention.
TV-Stove
Manufacturers created a TV-Stove so women could watch television while cooking.
However:
The TV-Stove was a market failure.
This demonstrated that users' preferences and existing cultural practices could influence whether a technological innovation succeeded.
Soap operas
Soap operas were designed so viewers could:
Listen while doing housework.
Miss parts of episodes.
Still follow the story.
Variety shows
Variety shows moved between different acts, making them easier to watch in pieces.
31. Television Changed Daily Routines
Television networks also attempted to change people's routines.
They:
Created regular schedules.
Previewed upcoming programs.
Connected programs to household activities.
Encouraged people to organize their day around television.
Television eventually became a major part of U.S. consumer culture.
32. Cable Television
Early cable television developed because some communities could not receive broadcast television signals clearly.
Large antennas captured weak signals and redistributed them through wires.
This became known as Community Antenna Television (CATV).
Cable changed television because:
It increased the number of available channels.
It allowed programming from distant locations.
It helped overcome limitations of broadcast bandwidth.
33. HBO and Cable Networks
In 1972, HBO launched Home Box Office.
HBO was among the first channels to rely heavily on subscribers paying for content rather than advertisers.
In 1975, HBO began using satellites to distribute content.
Later, many cable networks developed, including:
CNN
ESPN
MTV
Bravo
Showtime
BET
Discovery Channel
Weather Channel
34. Narrowcasting
Broadcast television originally focused on reaching large mainstream audiences.
Cable allowed channels to target smaller audiences based on:
Interests
Tastes
Political orientation
This was called “narrow-casting.”
Cable therefore increased the amount and variety of programming.
However, cable remained largely commercial.
35. The Internet
The internet is a huge network of interconnected computer networks.
Its development took place over many decades.
ARPA
In 1958, the U.S. government created the Advanced Research Projects Agency (ARPA) within the Department of Defense.
ARPANET
By 1966, ARPANET had been developed as a network connecting government and university computers.
It used packet switching.
36. Packet Switching
Packet switching breaks a message into small pieces called data packets.
These packets:
Travel through different routes.
Reach the receiving computer.
Are reassembled into the original message.
Why it matters:
It allows information to move efficiently.
It avoids certain bottlenecks.
It makes the network difficult to completely shut down.
37. Development of the Internet
Important developments included:
1969: ARPANET went online, initially connecting four universities.
1970s: Researchers developed common communication protocols.
1975: More than 50 university and government sites were connected.
1983: ARPANET was divided into:
MILNET — military uses
NSFNET — civilian uses
TCP/IP became the standard communication protocol.
Government support helped early internet developers experiment without the same commercial pressures that would later influence the internet.
38. Early Internet Culture
Computer enthusiasts promoted ideas such as:
Sharing
Openness
Decentralization
Free access
These ideas helped form the foundation for later:
Open-source movements
Free-software movements
The early internet was influenced by a belief that technology could contribute to human progress.
39. What Makes the Internet Different?
The chapter identifies several important characteristics.
1. User control
Users have considerable control over:
What they access
When they access it
How they communicate
2. Interactivity
People can communicate with one another regardless of location.
This creates the possibility of:
One-to-one communication
One-to-many communication
Many-to-many communication
3. User-created content
People with relatively modest resources can create and share media content.
4. Digitization
Different forms of media can be converted into the same digital language of 1s and 0s.
5. Convergence
Different types of media can be combined.
For example, a newspaper website can contain:
Written stories
Videos
Audio
40. Digitization and Convergence
Digitization
The shift from analog media to digital media.
Digital technology allows:
Text
Sound
Images
Video
to be stored, copied, and transmitted using the same digital system.
Convergence
The boundaries between different types of media become blurred.
The internet and mobile devices have helped make media less tied to a single physical format.
41. The Internet Is Global
The internet operates across national boundaries.
This creates questions about:
Government regulation
Access
Security
Cybercrime
Control
Openness
Because the internet is decentralized, governments can have difficulty completely controlling or shutting it down.
42. Internet Predictions
In the 1990s, many people predicted that the internet would:
Transform the world.
Bring prosperity.
Democratize culture.
Strengthen political democracy.
Challenge authoritarian governments.
Promote global understanding.
The chapter says the internet did not fully live up to these idealistic predictions, but it still produced many economic, social, and political changes.
43. Overall Argument of the Chapter
The chapter's main argument is that technology matters, but technology does not determine everything.
Technology can:
Enable social change.
Create new possibilities.
Limit certain forms of communication.
Influence how people experience media.
But technology is also shaped by:
People
Users
Businesses
Governments
Economic forces
Political forces
Cultural values
Key idea to remember:
Technology and society have a push-and-pull relationship.
People create and shape technology, while technology can also influence how people live.
44. The Cycle of Technological Innovation
Tim Wu describes a recurring pattern in the development of new technologies.
Stage 1: New technology appears
Innovation begins.
People experiment with new possibilities.
The technology is often viewed very positively.
Stage 2: Idealistic expectations
New technology may be described as something that will:
Improve society.
Create greater freedom.
Transform communication.
Stage 3: Existing industries respond
When the technology threatens older industries:
Established companies try to control it.
Uses become standardized.
Government regulation may help limit competition.
Stage 4: Corporate control
The technology becomes more centralized and commercialized.
Stage 5: Dissatisfaction
Over time:
Users become familiar with limitations.
The technology becomes less exciting.
Dissatisfaction grows.
Stage 6: New technology
New competitors introduce another technology, beginning another cycle.
Most important point:
This cycle is not inevitable.
The people involved — including:
Inventors
Corporate executives
Government regulators
Users
make decisions that shape what happens.