Political Socialization and Political Learning - Study Notes
CHAPTER 5 Political Socialization and Political Learning
LEARNING OBJECTIVES
Describe the influence of the family on political predispositions.
Describe how personality and our genes influence political predispositions.
Describe how schooling affects political opinions.
Identify life cycle and generational effects on political opinions.
Introduction to Political Socialization
Political socialization parallels other forms of learning, like reading and writing.
A significant amount of political learning occurs before one can vote.
Adults often generalize their childhood family authority structures into their preferences for the state's authority structures.
Childhood experiences influence later political attitudes, a concept rooted in "the primary principle," which posits that preadult learning affects adult behavior (Stoker & Bass, 2011).
Perspectives on Political Socialization
Two perspectives on political socialization:
Traditional Approach: Focuses on acquiring attitudes, values, and behaviors necessary to fit into the political order.
Generic Political Learning Approach: Emphasizes individual political change throughout life over the need for conformity to political norms (Jennings, 2004).
The Preadult Years: Socialization to Citizenship
Children are indoctrinated early to accept the prevailing political order (David Easton and Jack Dennis, 1969).
Importance of Early Socialization: Successful childhood socialization fosters loyalty to the government; failures can lead to civil unrest (e.g., Iraq after Saddam Hussein).
Studies show children form a sense of national identity and idealize political authority figures (police, president).
Benevolent Leader Hypothesis states that positive childhood impressions of leaders foster future favorable attitudes towards political institutions (Greenstein, 1965).
Childhood Political Awakening
Political awareness can begin before formal education.
Children may identify political authority with religious authority, indicating a merging of political and religious identifiers.
Children often naively view political figures positively, unlike the cynicism of adults.
Adolescence and Political Learning
Major political learning occurs during adolescence.
Data from Conover and Searing (2000) highlight that while most adolescents develop a citizen identity, political tolerance remains low.
The Consequences of Preadult Socialization to Citizenship
Children personalize government and idealize authority. This can vary significantly across demographics:
African-American, Latino, Native American, and socioeconomically disadvantaged children may be more cynical about authority than middle-class white children.
The theory of diffuse support regarding authority idealization lacks broad empirical support.
The Agents of Preadult Socialization
The Family
Families play a crucial role in shaping political attitudes through effective communication and strong emotional bonds (Sears & Levy, 2003).
Youth-Parent Socialization Panel Study: A longitudinal study that tracked high school seniors and their parents from 1965 to 1997, revealing attitudinal transmission across generations.
Results from the study indicate that children often mirror their parents' political stances, particularly on emotionally charged issues.
Peer Groups
Peer groups become increasingly influential in adolescence but are often seen as reinforcing family lessons rather than shaping politics independently.
Students may prioritize peer influence on immediate, youth-relevant political issues while family retains predominance on long-term political affiliation.
Schools
Schools are viewed as instrumental in political training, tasked with teaching obedience to political authority and achieving political stability.
Despite their critical role, student interest and knowledge about politics remain notably low.
Innovations in the curriculum have shown potential to significantly affect student political outcomes, particularly regarding civic knowledge and participation.
College: Higher Education and Its Impact
Political Attitudes in College
Increasing proportions of college students identify as liberals, with changes in personal beliefs often occurring throughout college (CIRP Surveys).
College attendance correlates with increased liberalism, particularly on social issues, though faculty influences and peer environments also play significant roles.
The Impact of Higher Education
Political tolerance and support for democratic values increase with education, alongside a rise in liberal social perspectives over time.
Factors like increased awareness, enlightenment through education, and potential indoctrination by faculty contribute to shifts in political attitudes during college years.
Personal Predispositions and Political Attitudes
Personality Development
Personality traits significantly influence political predispositions, particularly those established early in life (Big Five Model). Traits include openness to experience, conscientiousness, extraversion, agreeableness, and emotional stability.
Genetic Influences
Genetic analysis suggests personality traits can have a genetic basis, which might reflect on political affiliations. Research indicates a substantial genetic component in political ideology, estimated at 58% (Hatemi & McDermott, 2016).
Socialization During Adulthood
Lifelong Political Socialization
Political beliefs established in youth tend to persist through adulthood, with early formative experiences having long-lasting effects.
Life-cycle effects: Tendencies for individuals to become more conservative as they age.
Generational effects: Unique historical events shape distinct political identities among cohorts.
Impacts of Major Events
Shared dramatic events (like 9/11) can engender period effects on political attitudes across generations.
Conclusion
The chapter emphasizes the importance of the formative years in shaping political orientations, the role of family, education, and social experience in adulthood, and the genetic predispositions influencing political beliefs. Persistent political orientations gained early in life highlight the need for effective political socialization practices.