Comprehensive Study Notes on Money, Asset Markets, and Monetary Creation

Financial Assets, Maturity, and Expected Returns

  • Asset Allocation Choices:

    • Individuals make daily portfolio decisions regarding how much wealth to retain in checkable liquid accounts (e.g., 1000 dollars1000\,\text{dollars} in a checking account) versus investing in financial assets (e.g., purchasing 2000 dollars2000\,\text{dollars} in bonds or allocating capital to corporate stocks).
    • Portfolio choices depend directly on liquidity needs, risk preferences, and expected asset returns.
  • Concept of Maturity:

    • Maturity represents the total time required for a financial asset—such as government debt securities—to mature, at which point the issuer repays the principal balance alongside outstanding interest.
  • Treasury Instruments and Debt Structures:

    • Treasury Bills (T-bills): Short-term government debt obligations issued and sold at a discount relative to their face value. They mature in periods such as 6 months6\,\text{months} without explicit periodic coupon payments.
    • Treasury Notes and Treasury Bonds: Longer-term debt securities issued at face value (e.g., 1000 dollars1000\,\text{dollars} per bond). The holder receives coupon interest payments every 6 months6\,\text{months}, and the full principal value (e.g., 1000 dollars1000\,\text{dollars}) is returned upon maturity (e.g., at the end of a 30 year30\,\text{year} horizon).
  • Risk and Expected Returns Across Asset Classes:

    • Government Securities: Assumed to be default risk-free because they are backed by the federal government.
    • Corporate Bonds: Issued by private corporations to raise debt capital. They carry default risk because corporations can enter bankruptcy. To compensate for default risk, corporate bonds yield higher returns than government bonds.
    • Corporate Stocks: Represent equity ownership in private corporations. Equity carries significantly higher volatility and bankruptcy risk than debt instruments.
    • Historical Return Profiles in the United States (Over 100+ years100+\text{ years}):
    • Stocks: Average annual return of approximately 8%8\% over a century-long horizon.
    • Government and Corporate Bonds: Average annual return between 3%3\% and 5%5\%.
    • Cash / Checking Accounts: Yield lower expected returns than bonds and stocks.
  • Market Price Adjustments:

    • Equilibrium across financial and macroeconomic markets relies on key relative prices, including the real interest rate (the price of loans) and the real wage (the price of labor).

Definition and Functions of Money

  • Economic Definition of Money:

    • Money is defined as the stock of assets used directly to perform economic transactions.
    • Money is distinct from wealth; wealth includes the sum of all accumulated financial and real assets, whereas money refers exclusively to liquid transaction assets.
  • Classification of Assets as Money:

    • Currency / Cash: Physical bills and coins in circulation.
    • Checks and Checking Accounts: Demand deposits held at financial institutions that are widely accepted for settling payments.
    • Credit Cards:
    • Credit cards are not money.
    • Swiping a credit card does not execute a final payment of money; it issues an instruction to the credit card company to grant a temporary loan and transfer funds from the credit card company's checking account to the merchant's checking account.
    • Including credit card balances in money supply measures would lead to double-counting, as the underlying transaction balances in checking accounts are already counted in the money supply.
  • The Three Functions of Money:

    1. Medium of Exchange:
    • Facilitates transactions by serving as an item buyers give to sellers when purchasing goods or services.
    • Replaces barter systems and eliminates the structural friction of finding a double coincidence of wants (where a seller of tables must find a buyer who produces chairs and simultaneously wants tables).
    1. Unit of Account:
    • Provides a standardized numerical unit for quoting prices and recording debts.
    • Simplifies relative price comparisons across complex goods.
    • Highly divisible: 1 dollar1\,\text{dollar} is divided perfectly into 100 cents100\,\text{cents}, unlike physical capital (e.g., an iPhone cannot be divided into 1000 pieces1000\,\text{pieces} to purchase an apple).
    1. Store of Value:
    • Allows purchasing power to be transferred from the present into the future.
    • Requires relative price stability. High inflation or hyperinflation undermines money as a store of value, prompting populations to adopt foreign currencies (e.g., US dollars).
  • Forms of Money:

    • Commodity Money: Money with intrinsic value based on the underlying material (e.g., gold, silver, or cigarettes in prisoner-of-war (POW) camps).
    • Fiat Money: Money without intrinsic value, established by government decree or legal tender status.
    • Fiat bills are intrinsically useless pieces of paper with low production costs: approximately 7 cents7\,\text{cents} to produce a 1 dollar1\,\text{dollar} bill and 11 cents11\,\text{cents} to produce a 100 dollar100\,\text{dollar} bill.
    • Value and acceptance are driven by legal enforcement (settling tax liabilities and debts) and self-fulfilling expectations (the forward-looking belief that other market actors will accept the paper currency in future exchanges).

Monetary Aggregates and the Money Supply

  • Definitions of Key Variables:

    • Currency (CC or CUCU): Physical cash held strictly by the non-bank public (excluding vault cash held in commercial banks).
    • Deposits (DD): Total transaction deposits (checking, demand, and allowable savings balances) held at private depository institutions.
    • Reserves (RR): Cash held by private banks in their vaults plus bank reserve accounts held at the central bank.
    • Money Supply (MM): Total stock of monetary assets available in the economy for transactions:     M=C+DM = C + D
    • Monetary Base (BB): High-powered money issued directly by the central bank:     B=C+RB = C + R
    • The monetary base is not equal to the money supply because bank reserves (RR) sit in vaults or central bank accounts and do not circulate directly as a medium of exchange.
  • Key Measures of Money Supply:

    • Monetary Base (BB): Cash held by the public plus bank reserves. Exhibited steady, stable growth prior to the 20082008 Great Recession.
    • M1M1 Aggregate: Includes currency held by the public (CC) plus demand deposits, checkable deposits, and savings deposits transferred into M1M1
    • M2M2 Aggregate: Includes M1M1 plus small-denomination time deposits, savings accounts, and money market mutual fund balances. Stands at approximately 20×1012 dollars20 \times 10^{12}\,\text{dollars}.

Banking Systems and the Money Multiplier

  • Comparison of Reserve Systems:

    • 100%100\% Reserve Banking System:
    • Banks store 100%100\% of all customer deposits in reserves (R=DR = D).
    • Banks issue zero loans and create no money.
    • Money Multiplier is 11 (m=1m = 1), meaning M=BM = B.
    • The central bank maintains total control over the money supply.
    • Fractional Reserve Banking System:
    • Modern standard adopted worldwide.
    • Banks keep only a fraction of total deposits as reserves (R<DR < D) and lend out the remaining balances to earn interest income.
    • Allows efficient capital deployment for home purchases, auto purchases, and business investment without requiring borrowers to rely solely on personal or family savings.
    • Generates money multiplication (M>BM > B).
  • Mathematical Model of the Money Multiplier:

    • Currency-Deposit Ratio (crcr or cc): Ratio of cash held by the public to bank deposits:     cr=CDcr = \frac{C}{D}
    • Reserve-Deposit Ratio (rrrr or rr): Ratio of reserves held by banks to bank deposits:     rr=RDrr = \frac{R}{D}
    • Derivation of the Money Multiplier (mm):     m=MB=C+DC+Rm = \frac{M}{B} = \frac{C + D}{C + R}     Dividing both numerator and denominator by total deposits (DD):     m=CD+DDCD+RD=cr+1cr+rrm = \frac{\frac{C}{D} + \frac{D}{D}}{\frac{C}{D} + \frac{R}{D}} = \frac{cr + 1}{cr + rr}
    • Total Money Supply Expression:     M=m×B=(cr+1cr+rr)×BM = m \times B = \left(\frac{cr + 1}{cr + rr}\right) \times B
  • Comparative Statics of the Multiplier:

    • Effect of an Increase in Currency-Deposit Ratio (cr↑cr \uparrow):
    • If households hold a larger fraction of funds as physical cash (crcr increases), less money flows into bank deposits.
    • Banks have fewer deposits to lend out, causing the money multiplier (mm) and total money supply (MM) to decrease.
    • Effect of an Increase in Reserve-Deposit Ratio (rr↑rr \uparrow):
    • If commercial banks hold higher reserves or the central bank increases reserve requirements (rrrr increases), a smaller fraction of each deposit is lent out.
    • This lowers the money creation capacity, causing the money multiplier (mm) and total money supply (MM) to decrease.
  • Historical Values of the Money Multiplier:

    • Prior to the 20082008 Great Recession, the money multiplier m=M1Bm = \frac{M1}{B} was approximately 22 (historically ranging around 1.61.6 to 22).
  • The Three Main Entities Determining the Money Supply:

    1. The Federal Reserve (Central Bank): Controls the total Monetary Base (BB).
    2. The Public (Households and Businesses): Determines the Currency-Deposit Ratio (crcr) through portfolio preferences.
    3. Private Depository Institutions (Commercial Banks): Determine the Reserve-Deposit Ratio (rrrr) through reserve allocation choices.

Banking Regulation, Systemic Risk, and Interest on Reserves

  • Systemic Risk in Fractional Reserve Banking:

    • Because banks hold only a fraction (e.g., 10%10\%) of total deposits in liquid reserve holdings (RR), a sudden loss of confidence can trigger a bank run.
    • If all depositors attempt to withdraw cash simultaneously, the bank cannot meet total cash demand, leading to insolvency or systemic closure.
    • Policy Solution: Introduction of government-backed deposit insurance (e.g., FDIC) to guarantee deposit safety and eliminate liquidity runs.
  • Interest on Reserves (IOR / IORB):

    • Private banks pay interest on customer checking and savings deposits.
    • Effective in 20082008, the Federal Reserve began paying Interest on Reserve Balances (IORB) to commercial banks for reserves held at the Fed.
    • Scale of Policy: Private bank reserve holdings at the Fed total trillions of dollars. At an interest rate of 4%4\%, annual interest paid by the central bank to private banks equals tens to hundreds of billions of dollars.

Step-by-Step Mathematical Process of Deposit Expansion

  • Hypothetical Parameters for Multiplier Demonstration:

    • Initial Monetary Base Injection: ΔB=100 dollars\Delta B = 100\,\text{dollars}
    • Currency-Deposit Ratio Assumption: cr=0cr = 0 (the public holds zero additional cash and deposits 100%100\% of all funds).
    • Reserve-Deposit Ratio Assumption: rr=0.10rr = 0.10 (banks hold 10%10\% in reserve and lend 90%90\%).
  • Stage-by-Stage Money Creation Sequence:

    • Stage 1:
    • Central bank injects ΔB=100 dollars\Delta B = 100\,\text{dollars} into the system.
    • Initial deposit created: ΔD1=100 dollars\Delta D_1 = 100\,\text{dollars}.
    • Bank retains 10%10\% as reserves: 0.10×100 dollars=10 dollars0.10 \times 100\,\text{dollars} = 10\,\text{dollars}.
    • Bank lends out remaining 90%90\%: 0.90×100 dollars=90 dollars0.90 \times 100\,\text{dollars} = 90\,\text{dollars}.
    • Stage 2:
    • Borrower spends 90 dollars90\,\text{dollars}. The seller receives 90 dollars90\,\text{dollars} and deposits it entirely into the banking system.
    • Second deposit created: ΔD2=90 dollars=0.90×100 dollars\Delta D_2 = 90\,\text{dollars} = 0.90 \times 100\,\text{dollars}.
    • Bank retains 10%10\% as reserves: 0.10×90 dollars=9 dollars0.10 \times 90\,\text{dollars} = 9\,\text{dollars}.
    • Bank lends out remaining 90%90\%: 0.90×90 dollars=81 dollars0.90 \times 90\,\text{dollars} = 81\,\text{dollars}.
    • Stage 3:
    • Borrower spends 81 dollars81\,\text{dollars}. The recipient deposits 81 dollars81\,\text{dollars} into the banking system.
    • Third deposit created: ΔD3=81 dollars=(0.90)2×100 dollars\Delta D_3 = 81\,\text{dollars} = (0.90)^2 \times 100\,\text{dollars}.
    • Bank retains 10%10\% as reserves: 0.10×81 dollars=8.10 dollars0.10 \times 81\,\text{dollars} = 8.10\,\text{dollars}.
    • Bank lends out remaining 90%90\%: 0.90×81 dollars=72.90 dollars0.90 \times 81\,\text{dollars} = 72.90\,\text{dollars}.
    • Subsequent Stages (kk):
    • Each subsequent deposit is given by: ΔDk=(0.90)k−1×100 dollars\Delta D_k = (0.90)^{k-1} \times 100\,\text{dollars}.
  • Summation of Total Cumulative Money Supply Creation:

    • Total Change in Money Supply / Total Cumulative Deposits:     ΔM=ΔD=100+0.90(100)+(0.90)2(100)+(0.90)3(100)+…\Delta M = \Delta D = 100 + 0.90(100) + (0.90)^2(100) + (0.90)^3(100) + \dots
    • Factoring out the initial 100 dollars100\,\text{dollars} deposit:     ΔM=100×(1+0.90+(0.90)2+(0.90)3+… )\Delta M = 100 \times \left(1 + 0.90 + (0.90)^2 + (0.90)^3 + \dots\right)
    • Applying the infinite geometric series identity ∑k=0∞xk=11−x\sum_{k=0}^{\infty} x^k = \frac{1}{1 - x} where x=1−rr=0.90x = 1 - rr = 0.90:     ΔM=100×11−0.90=100×10.10=100×10=1000 dollars\Delta M = 100 \times \frac{1}{1 - 0.90} = 100 \times \frac{1}{0.10} = 100 \times 10 = 1000\,\text{dollars}
  • Verification Using Formula:

    • When cr=0cr = 0, the money multiplier formula simplifies to:     m=0+10+rr=1rr=10.10=10m = \frac{0 + 1}{0 + rr} = \frac{1}{rr} = \frac{1}{0.10} = 10
    • Total Change in Money Supply:     ΔM=m×ΔB=10×100 dollars=1000 dollars\Delta M = m \times \Delta B = 10 \times 100\,\text{dollars} = 1000\,\text{dollars}

Questions & Discussion

  • Question / Problem:

    • What is the total expected increase in the money supply if the central bank increases the monetary base by 100 dollars100\,\text{dollars}, given a currency-deposit ratio cr=0cr = 0 and a reserve-deposit ratio rr=0.10rr = 0.10?
  • Dialogue Analysis:

    • Common Student Misconception: Answering 100 dollars100\,\text{dollars} or failing to account for the full geometric sequence of lending cycles.
    • Mathematical Resolution: Applying the money multiplier formula m=1rr=10.10=10m = \frac{1}{rr} = \frac{1}{0.10} = 10 confirms that an initial base increase of 100 dollars100\,\text{dollars} expands cumulative money supply by 1000 dollars1000\,\text{dollars}.