Clifford Irving

Introduction

  • In 1972, novelist Clifford Irving fooled American publishing giant McGraw-Hill into believing that Howard Hughes, America's richest and most enigmatic man, had requested Irving to write his biography.

  • Irving provided a letter he said was written by Hughes, in which Hughes stated that he had called Irving to compliment one of his works.

  • Hughes had also provided him audiotapes and a manuscript, he said.

  • The author assumed that Hughes, a hermit since 1958, would not want to attract the attention of the media or the police and would do nothing to prevent the book from being published.

Sealing the deal

  • Clifford Irving was invited to McGraw-New Hill's York headquarters, where editors offered contracts for both Irving and Hughes to sign.

  • The publishers gave Irving a $100,000 (£80,000) advance and Hughes a $400,000 (£320,000) advance.

  • However, before completing and delivering the text, Irving renegotiated the entire amount to $765,000 (£610,000).

  • Irving's friend and partner, children's novelist Richard Suskind, faked Hughes' signature on the contract, which McGrawHill accepted without issue.

  • The publishers gave Irving the checks for his and Hughes' advances.

  • Irving's then-wife Edith deposited the cheques made out to H.R. Hughes in a Swiss bank account that she had just created under the name "Helga R. Hughes".

Two lucky breaks

  • During their study, Irving and Suskind were handed an unfinished novel by author James Phelan about Hughes' former business manager.

  • Phelan was unaware that Irving had been handed the manuscript, which Irving stole and claimed as his own in major portions.

  • Irving handed a full draft to his editors at McGraw-Hill in late 1971, and they planned to publish the following year.

  • When Hughes' attorneys learned of this, they interfered, raising concerns to Irving's publisher about the legitimacy of the autobiography.

  • After a handwriting company examined writing samples and certified them legitimate, McGraw-Hill continued to support Irving.

The gamble backfires

  • Hughes ultimately emerged from seclusion in March 1972, two months before the book's scheduled publication, to attend a telephone news conference with reporters.

  • He called the book a forgery, and McGraw-Hill canceled the contract.

  • Irving was selected "Con Man of the Year" by Time magazine in its February 1972 edition.

  • Irving was investigated by the police, and a grand jury was formed to evaluate accusations of mail fraud, perjury, and forgery.

  • He was charged with "conspiracy to defraud by the use of the mails," but instead of going to trial, he pled guilty, received a $10,000 (£8,000) fine, was required to repay the advance, and was sentenced to 30 months in a federal jail.

  • Irving declared bankruptcy the next year.

  • Edith was punished with two months in prison, while Suskind was sentenced to six months in prison for stealing and conspiracy.

  • Irving's amazing narrative was published in 1977, and it was adapted into a big film in 2006.

The art of the hoax

  • Hoaxers often go to considerable pains to make a con seem credible.

  • The discussions with Hughes that Clifford Irving wrote about were not just made up; rather, he performed them out with Suskind, who played Suskind and Irving, respectively.

  • Because it was authentic and based on actual interactions with someone who knew Hughes well, the information Irving had stolen from novelist James Phelan seemed credible.

  • This made the book an engaging read, and Irving's undoubted writing talent—he had achieved acclaim in 1969 with his biography of forger Elmyr de Hory—also contributed.

  • There was a global desire to uncover the truth about the eccentric, secretive millionaire, thus the timing of the book was also ideal.

  • Irving subsequently acknowledged his secret: he had been duped by his own deceptions.

  • Hughes, who, in contrast to Irving's prognosis, ultimately broke his quiet to criticize Irving, was the single thing he miscalculated.

Related Crimes

  • 1844: Thomas Monck Mason, an Irish balloonist, is said to have flown over the Atlantic Ocean, according to The New York Sun, but this is later shown to be a fake by Edgar Allan Poe.

  • 1998: With the help of David Bowie, who performs readings from the book during the "launch party," author William Boyd publishes a biography of fictitious American artist Nat Tate in an attempt to ironically mislead the New York art community.

  • 2015: Coming Home, Texas, by Laura Harner is taken off the market when it is found that she copied parts of a book by New York Times best-selling author Becky McGraw.

robot