Module 1: The Problem of Definitions in the Study of Religion

Introduction to the Problem of Definitions in Religious Studies

  • Speaker Profiles:     * Mike McVicar: Associate Professor in the Department of Religion, specializing in the American religious history track.     * Professor Drew Jurden: Collaborator on the first module who will lead the second part of the discussion.

  • Central Objective: To explore the general approaches to defining "religion," evaluate common definitions, and examine the philosophical and political implications of those definitions as presented in Martin’s text.

  • The Baseline Survey: The course begins with a survey asking students to reflect on common definitions used in everyday life. This establishes a baseline of expectations regarding what people generally mean when they use the word "religion."

Analysis of Common Descriptive Definitions

  • Definition Sources and Characteristics:     * Wikipedia (Option A): Offers a wide-ranging definition focusing on sociocultural systems, behaviors, practices, and texts.     * Dictionary.com (Option B): Focuses primarily on beliefs regarding the cause, nature, and purpose of the universe.     * Merriam-Webster (Option C): Provides a simple definition: "The belief in gods or a group of gods."     * Merriam-Webster (Option D): Defines religion as a personal set of institutionalized religious attitudes and beliefs.

  • Status of These Definitions: According to McVicar, none of these definitions are "wrong." They are descriptive definitions found in standard American English reference texts to explain common usage.

  • The Problematic Nature of Definitions: Martin (the course author) argues against using standard dictionary definitions. He suggests that defining religion is not impossible but is inherently problematic because every definition carries specific political, social, or cultural implications.

Historical Evolution of the Term "Religion"

  • Ancient Root (Latin): The term has roots in the Latinate word roughly meaning scruples, devotion, reverence, or rules.     * In the ancient context, religion was inseparable from politics or other forms of cultural life.

  • Early Modern Shift (1500s–1600s):     * During the Protestant Reformation's conflict with the Catholic Church, a progressive attempt began to separate "religion" from "politics."     * This period marked the disentanglement of these two major spheres of human action and belief.

  • Colonial Influence:     * As European powers colonized the globe, "religion" became a comparative concept used to classify "us" (the colonizers) versus "them" (the colonized).     * Indigenous Context: Spanish and English colonizers encountered indigenous populations in the Americas and had to determine if they possessed something analogous to Christian/Catholic/Protestant religion.     * Ethical Implication: Religious status was often tied to "humanness." Deeming a population "religion-less" made it easier to justify colonization.

  • Modern Context: Religion is now widely associated with a private or interiorized network of personal beliefs. It is often linked to individual faith, spirituality, the supernatural, and tradition as opposed to modernity or secularization.

Four Classic Definitions of Religion

  • E.B. Tyler (English Anthropologist, late 1800s–early 1900s):     * Work: Primitive Cultures.     * Definition: "A minimum definition of religion, the belief in spiritual beings."     * Key Concept: Animism: The belief that all natural phenomena possess an "anima" (soul or spirit).     * Implications: Tyler emphasized a cognitive or neurological basis for religion and argued for the "psychic unity of all human beings."

  • William James (American Philosopher/Psychologist):     * Work: The Varieties of Religious Experience.     * Definition: He offered an "arbitrary" definition: "the feelings, acts, experiences of individual men in their solitude as far as they apprehend themselves to stand in relation to whatever they may consider divine."     * Focus: Emphasized individualized, mystical experiences rather than shared group beliefs.

  • Emile Durkheim (French Sociologist):     * Work: The Elementary Forms of Religious Life.     * Definition: "A unified system of beliefs and practices relative to sacred things, that is to say, things set apart—beliefs and practices which unite into one single moral community, which he called a church."     * Functionalism: Durkheim moved away from interior belief and focused on the social functions of religion. He proposed a "bipartite division of reality" between the sacred and the profane.

  • Clifford Geertz (American Anthropologist):     * Focus: Culture as a matrix of ideas, customs, symbols, and institutions.     * Five-Part Definition: Religion is (1) a system of symbols which acts to (2) establish powerful, persuasive, and long-standing moods and motivations in men by (3) formulating conceptions of a general order of existence and (4) clothing these conceptions with such an aura of factuality that (5) the moods and motivations seem uniquely realistic.     * Dialectic: Religion is a feedback effect between external cultural institutions and internal human psychology.

J.Z. Smith and the Academic Construction of Religion

  • Scholarly Influence: Martin’s work is heavily influenced by J.Z. Smith, an American religious studies scholar.

  • The Creation of the Object: Smith famously stated in Imagining Religion that while there is data for human experience, there is "no data for religion."

  • Key Theses:     * Religion is solely the creation of the scholar’s study for analytic purposes.     * Religion has no existence outside or apart from the academy.     * "Religion" is not a native term; it is a "second-order generic concept" used to establish a disciplinary horizon, similar to how "language" functions in linguistics or "culture" functions in anthropology.

Synthesizing the Limitations of Definition

  • The Wetland Metaphor: Martin uses the example of a wetland to show that definitions change based on the interests served. No single definition fits all everyday uses.

  • Power Mechanisms: Defining a term sets limitations. One must ask whose interests those limitations serve.

  • The Problem of "Belief": Many standard definitions (B, C, D) prioritize "belief." However, cross-culturally, many religions emphasize "practice" over belief. Defining religion primarily as belief is a specific Western/American bias.

  • Taxonomic Category: "Religion" is a taxonomic category popularized in Western Europe and North America to classify a subset of human behaviors. While it has "descriptive utility," it often has very little "prescriptive utility" when applied to other cultures.

Questions & Discussion

  • Task for Students: Review the second reading response and reflect on the following:     * How has the lecture and Martin's chapter altered or encouraged a change in your understanding of common definitions of religion?     * What work are these definitions actually doing in society?     * How would you revise the definition you selected (or wrote) in the initial survey after considering the historical and scholarly critiques provided?