Substitution Method and Extraneous Solutions in Quadratic Equations page 7

Questions & Discussion

  • Question: Could we have substituted values for yy into the second equation to solve for xx in Example 1?

  • Answer: Yes, but because xx is squared in the second equation this could give us extraneous solutions for xx.

Substitution Analysis and Extraneous Solutions

  • Substituting values for yy into the equation y=x2+1y = x^2 + 1 demonstrates how solving for a squared variable can yield extraneous solutions.

Case 1: Evaluation for y=1y = 1

  • Equation setup: y=x2+1y = x^2 + 1

  • Substituting y=1y = 1 into the equation: 1=x2+11 = x^2 + 1

  • Simplifying by subtracting 11 from both sides: x2=0x^2 = 0

  • Solving for xx by taking the square root: x=±√0=0x = \text{±}√{0} = 0

  • Result:

    • This gives the same value as in the primary solution.

Case 2: Evaluation for y=2y = 2

  • Equation setup: y=x2+1y = x^2 + 1

  • Substituting y=2y = 2 into the equation: 2=x2+12 = x^2 + 1

  • Simplifying by subtracting 11 from both sides: x2=1x^2 = 1

  • Solving for xx by taking the square root: x=±√1=±1x = \text{±}√{1} = \text{±}1

  • Result:

    • Notice that −1-1 is an extraneous solution.