Canadian History Jan 16th

Introduction to Treaties and Indigenous Peoples

  • Contextual Overview

    • Continuation from previous lecture (Tuesday).

    • Summary of events, primarily from textbook, with additional information from various sources.

    • Reminder of upcoming AQ&A and posting materials on D2L tomorrow.

Historical Context of Treaties in Western Canada

  • Treaty Signing Motivations

    • Indigenous peoples sought assurances for land and resources for future generations.

    • Collective desperation among Plains peoples due to deteriorating conditions.

Indigenous Groups Involved

  • Peoples Discussed:

    • Métis, particularly in Red River area.

    • Indigenous groups: Blackfoot, Plains Cree, Nakota, Assiniboine.

Catastrophic Environment at End of 19th Century

  • Major causes: Encroaching colonization leading to resource depletion and cultural dislocation.

  • Bison Population Decline

    • Bison hunting was a central economic activity for thousands of years, especially post-Ice Age, with significant cultural and economic importance.

    • Colonists utilized bison for industrial products, leading to mass extermination of herds.

    • An example of warfare against Plains peoples involved targeting the bison to weaken their sustenance and resistance.

Effects of Environmental and Economic Stressors

  • Drought and Climate Fluctuations

    • Years 1860-70 marked by drought, insufficient winter precipitation, and spring prairie fires.

    • Plagues of Rocky Mountain Locust further exacerbated food scarcity by damaging crops and native flora.

    • Resulted in food shortages and material poverty among indigenous and farming communities.

  • Health Consequences of Poverty

    • Malnutrition weakened immune systems, facilitating outbreaks of contagious diseases: Smallpox, influenza, malaria, measles, whooping cough.

Treaty Expectations and Realities

  • Theoretical Treaty Provisions

    • Rations of food, clothing, medicine, and annuity payments promised in exchange for land.

    • Training in European farming as a pathway to self-sufficiency.

  • Reality of Treaty Implementation

    • Federal Indian policy involved private contractors who prioritized profit over adequate provisions.

  • Reported Failures

    • Contractors provided rotten food or led to cruel punishment practices for indigenous peoples.

    • Reported conditions included indigenous individuals suffering from exposure and starvation due to inadequate rations and access to traditional foods.

Farming and Economic Marginalization

  • Government Policies Toward Indigenous Farmers

    • 1880 legislation disallowed sale of produce without Indian agent approval, with severe penalties for noncompliance.

    • Introduction of Peasant Agriculture Policy restricted farmers to small land plots and limited them to hand tools, justified by stadial theory.

    • This echoed a continued use of antiquated methods to stifle indigenous progress.

Resource Accessibility Issues

  • Restrictions on Traditional Food Sources

    • Access to fishing and hunting diminished, leading to reliance on government-controlled food supplies.

    • Reserves alienated from lucrative resources such as timber, further reinforcing economic disparities.

Societal Perceptions and Indigenous Identity

  • Colonial Policies' Role in Shaping Indigenous Identities

    • Systematic policies attempted to portray indigenous peoples as anti-modern and inferior, fostering a narrative of poverty.

  • Reality vs. Perception

    • Pre-contact views of indigenous success and sustainability contrasted sharply with colonial assessments, leading to significant long-term socio-economic issues.

The Red River Rebellion and Louis Riel

  • Louis Riel's Role and Legacy

    • Historical significance stemming from the execution of Thomas Scott during the Red River Rebellion and Louis Riel's reputation thereafter.

    • The presence of English speaking Protestants and the Orange Order fostered anti-Catholic sentiments against Riel.

  • Political Dynamics Post-Rebellion

    • Riel's exiles led to the emergence of the Metis community and its ambitions for land rights and fair treatment.

Uprising of 1885

  • Metis and Indigenous Alliance

    • The 1885 uprising was predicated on grievances regarding land legislation and political representation.

    • Development of a 10-Point Bill of Rights addressing land administration, rights for English-speaking Metis, and better treatment of indigenous peoples.

Government Response and Legal Consequences

  • Execution of Louis Riel

    • Riel was put on trial, trying to reject an insanity defense due to fear it would undermine legitimate grievances of the rebellion. He was ultimately executed.

  • Continued Colonial Control

    • Assorted amendments to the Indian Act resulted in collective punishments for status Indians post-uprising, limiting autonomy and movement.

Education Policies: Residential Schools

  • Objectives of Residential Schools

    • Schools aimed to assimilate indigenous peoples, emphasizing abandonment of traditional lifestyles and languages.

    • Education was geared towards providing manual labor skills, deterring competition with the European workforce.

  • Testimony of Abuse and Neglect

    • Accounts revealing severe abuses (physical/psychological) in residential schools leading to a culture of impunity.

  • Health Issues in Schools

    • High mortality rates primarily attributed to overcrowded and poorly managed institutions.

The Cycle of Stereotypes and Policy

  • Circular Justification of Inequities

    • Policies justified by stereotypes perpetuated from historical misconceptions of inferiority leading to continued loss of resources and cultural identity.

Conclusion and Modern Implications

  • Enduring Impact on Indigenous Communities

    • Survivorship of indigenous peoples despite historical attempts at cultural eradication.

    • Rise of networking and advocacy organizations in the early 20th century as a form of resistance and persistence amidst colonial oppressions.

  • Invitation for Discussion

    • Open floor for comments and further discussion on the topic.

    • Mention of assignments and future topics, transitioning into the exploration of 20th-century changes.