Canadian History Jan 16th
Introduction to Treaties and Indigenous Peoples
Contextual Overview
Continuation from previous lecture (Tuesday).
Summary of events, primarily from textbook, with additional information from various sources.
Reminder of upcoming AQ&A and posting materials on D2L tomorrow.
Historical Context of Treaties in Western Canada
Treaty Signing Motivations
Indigenous peoples sought assurances for land and resources for future generations.
Collective desperation among Plains peoples due to deteriorating conditions.
Indigenous Groups Involved
Peoples Discussed:
Métis, particularly in Red River area.
Indigenous groups: Blackfoot, Plains Cree, Nakota, Assiniboine.
Catastrophic Environment at End of 19th Century
Major causes: Encroaching colonization leading to resource depletion and cultural dislocation.
Bison Population Decline
Bison hunting was a central economic activity for thousands of years, especially post-Ice Age, with significant cultural and economic importance.
Colonists utilized bison for industrial products, leading to mass extermination of herds.
An example of warfare against Plains peoples involved targeting the bison to weaken their sustenance and resistance.
Effects of Environmental and Economic Stressors
Drought and Climate Fluctuations
Years 1860-70 marked by drought, insufficient winter precipitation, and spring prairie fires.
Plagues of Rocky Mountain Locust further exacerbated food scarcity by damaging crops and native flora.
Resulted in food shortages and material poverty among indigenous and farming communities.
Health Consequences of Poverty
Malnutrition weakened immune systems, facilitating outbreaks of contagious diseases: Smallpox, influenza, malaria, measles, whooping cough.
Treaty Expectations and Realities
Theoretical Treaty Provisions
Rations of food, clothing, medicine, and annuity payments promised in exchange for land.
Training in European farming as a pathway to self-sufficiency.
Reality of Treaty Implementation
Federal Indian policy involved private contractors who prioritized profit over adequate provisions.
Reported Failures
Contractors provided rotten food or led to cruel punishment practices for indigenous peoples.
Reported conditions included indigenous individuals suffering from exposure and starvation due to inadequate rations and access to traditional foods.
Farming and Economic Marginalization
Government Policies Toward Indigenous Farmers
1880 legislation disallowed sale of produce without Indian agent approval, with severe penalties for noncompliance.
Introduction of Peasant Agriculture Policy restricted farmers to small land plots and limited them to hand tools, justified by stadial theory.
This echoed a continued use of antiquated methods to stifle indigenous progress.
Resource Accessibility Issues
Restrictions on Traditional Food Sources
Access to fishing and hunting diminished, leading to reliance on government-controlled food supplies.
Reserves alienated from lucrative resources such as timber, further reinforcing economic disparities.
Societal Perceptions and Indigenous Identity
Colonial Policies' Role in Shaping Indigenous Identities
Systematic policies attempted to portray indigenous peoples as anti-modern and inferior, fostering a narrative of poverty.
Reality vs. Perception
Pre-contact views of indigenous success and sustainability contrasted sharply with colonial assessments, leading to significant long-term socio-economic issues.
The Red River Rebellion and Louis Riel
Louis Riel's Role and Legacy
Historical significance stemming from the execution of Thomas Scott during the Red River Rebellion and Louis Riel's reputation thereafter.
The presence of English speaking Protestants and the Orange Order fostered anti-Catholic sentiments against Riel.
Political Dynamics Post-Rebellion
Riel's exiles led to the emergence of the Metis community and its ambitions for land rights and fair treatment.
Uprising of 1885
Metis and Indigenous Alliance
The 1885 uprising was predicated on grievances regarding land legislation and political representation.
Development of a 10-Point Bill of Rights addressing land administration, rights for English-speaking Metis, and better treatment of indigenous peoples.
Government Response and Legal Consequences
Execution of Louis Riel
Riel was put on trial, trying to reject an insanity defense due to fear it would undermine legitimate grievances of the rebellion. He was ultimately executed.
Continued Colonial Control
Assorted amendments to the Indian Act resulted in collective punishments for status Indians post-uprising, limiting autonomy and movement.
Education Policies: Residential Schools
Objectives of Residential Schools
Schools aimed to assimilate indigenous peoples, emphasizing abandonment of traditional lifestyles and languages.
Education was geared towards providing manual labor skills, deterring competition with the European workforce.
Testimony of Abuse and Neglect
Accounts revealing severe abuses (physical/psychological) in residential schools leading to a culture of impunity.
Health Issues in Schools
High mortality rates primarily attributed to overcrowded and poorly managed institutions.
The Cycle of Stereotypes and Policy
Circular Justification of Inequities
Policies justified by stereotypes perpetuated from historical misconceptions of inferiority leading to continued loss of resources and cultural identity.
Conclusion and Modern Implications
Enduring Impact on Indigenous Communities
Survivorship of indigenous peoples despite historical attempts at cultural eradication.
Rise of networking and advocacy organizations in the early 20th century as a form of resistance and persistence amidst colonial oppressions.
Invitation for Discussion
Open floor for comments and further discussion on the topic.
Mention of assignments and future topics, transitioning into the exploration of 20th-century changes.