In-Depth Notes on the Representation of Older People in Flemish Public Television
Representation of Older People on Television
Overview
- Research indicates older people are underrepresented on TV and often depicted using fixed archetypes.
- These representations reflect cultural myths about aging, portraying older individuals as either vulnerable (old-old, >80 years) or dynamic (young-old, 65-80 years).
- Qualitative analysis of Flemish public TV from 2019 and 2020 reveals predominant themes in broadcasting concerning older adults, especially during the COVID-19 pandemic.
Key Findings
- Underrepresentation: Older individuals make up only a small percentage of roles in TV, mirroring their demographic in society but in narrow, stereotypical roles.
- Cultural Myths: The coverage emphasizes vulnerability, decline, and increasing individual responsivity for “successful aging.”
Age Distinction
- Young-Old (65-80 years): Represented as dynamic, active, and associated with positive traits and successful aging ideals.
- Old-Old (>80 years): Portrayed as passive and fragile. This demographic saw an uptick in representation due to the pandemic, focusing on issues of health, loneliness, and dependency.
Thematic Representation
- Health and Vulnerability: Increased media portrayal of old-old people during the pandemic depicts them primarily in contexts of illness and dependency, emphasizing decline without showcasing variance in capabilities.
- Cultural Myths about Aging: Six myths identified, framing aging as a disease, equating aging with decline, and focusing on perceived costs to society instead of positive contributions.
- Positive Counterframes: Some broadcasts introduced counterframes showcasing vitality in aging, depicting older individuals in everyday life or exceptional contexts.
- Symbolic Annihilation: Older population is significantly underrepresented in media compared to actual demographic proportions. The media often fails to reflect the diversity within older adult experiences, reinforcing negative stereotypes.
- Visual Ageism: Representation often lacks realism and diversity, reducing older individuals to stereotypes like frailty or inactivity.
- Intimacy: Older individuals are often portrayed as lacking sexual expression, which fails to address their actual sexual needs and interests.
- Loneliness: Portrayals of social isolation reflect cultural stereotypes, linking aging to loneliness. Media often presents older adults as socially disengaged or incapable of forming connections.
- Death and End of Life: There exists a taboo in addressing death with dignity, yet some programs tackle end-of-life choices sensitively, reflecting a need for discussion in public discourse.
Methodology Insights
- Qualitative Content Analysis: Investigated 44 Flemish public TV programs across genres to determine representation of older people and aging. Included a mix of interviews with aging experts to gain additional perspective.
- VRT Context: Flemish public service broadcaster (VRT) does not set specific targets for the representation of older people, yet acknowledges diversity issues.
Recommendations for Improved Representation
- Diverse Portrayals: Call for more nuanced representations of older individuals that include those who are neither extraordinarily dynamic nor helpless.
- Encouragement of Active Narratives: Highlighting the agency of older adults and presenting them in diverse roles can combat stereotypes and foster a more balanced view of aging.
- Need for Future Research: There's a need to further explore how representations of older adults, especially the old-old, evolve in different contexts, including the ongoing implications of the COVID-19 pandemic.