Chapter 2

Introduction to Criminology and Crime Theories

  • Criminology Definition and Terminology: Criminology is the scientific study of crime and criminal behavior. It differs significantly from criminalistics (forensics and crime scene investigations), criminal investigations, and general criminal justice administration.

  • Proactive Utility of Theories: Theories of crime and delinquency serve as proactive tools designed to predict criminal behavior. Predicting behavior allows social and legal systems to prevent, minimize, or eliminate criminal occurrences.

  • Behavioral Deterrence Analogy: Learning from consequences operates on basic cause-and-effect information. If touching an object repeatedly burns a person's finger, that person stops touching it to avoid pain, excluding edge cases like masochism.

  • Case Study: Richard Ramirez:

    • Known historically as "the Night Stalker" (transcribed in context as "nice talker").

    • Responsible for over 2020 murders and between 4040 and 5050 rapes.

    • Victim age demographics spanned from 66 years old to 9191 years old (with secondary accounts citing 8888 years old).

    • Etiology and Behavioral Predictors: Ramirez suffered a severe traumatic brain injury (TBI) at age 66. Theoretical explanations of complex criminal acts require multi-factorial analyses rather than a single cause; multiple distinct theories can simultaneously be correct in explaining his behavior.

  • Crime Fads and Cyclical Social Patterns:

    • Social behaviors and crime patterns emerge, disappear, and re-emerge over time in modified forms.

    • Naming Trend Analogy: Popularity of child names cycles historically. Names common in earlier eras (e.g., Michael, Robert) shifted toward modern names (e.g., Cameron) before returning to older generational names (e.g., Clara, born in 19071907, re-emerging after 4040 years of disuse, distinct from unused elderly names like Hector or Lester).

  • Historical Emergence of Criminology:

    • Criminology formally emerged as a recognized discipline in the late 1700s1700\text{s}, though historical roots extend several centuries prior.

    • Major modern criminology developments took place in the United States from the early 1900s1900\text{s} into recent decades.

    • Key developmental theories include Edwin Sutherland's Differential Association (early 1900s1900\text{s}), Robert Agnew's General Strain Theory (19381938 lineage), and Travis Hirschi's Social Control Theory.

Deviance, Social Norms, and Cultural Concepts

  • Defining Deviance: Deviance refers to behavior, traits, or beliefs that stray from established social norms. Deviant conduct is not inherently illegal.

  • Historical Shifts in Social Norms:

    • Tattoos on Women: Considered highly deviant and socially frowned upon 3030 to 4040 years ago, though legal.

    • Women in Gyms: Female participation in weightlifting or gym workouts was socially unaccepted 2020 to 3030 years ago.

    • Earrings on Men: Wearing an earring in the right ear was historically viewed as a social indicator of homosexuality. The first prominent heterosexual public figure to wear a right-ear earring was Dave Parker, a Hall of Fame baseball player for the Pittsburgh Pirates.

  • Cultural Values and Cultural Universals: Complete acceptance and understanding across all global cultures is statistically and socially unattainable; societies continually struggle with cultural integration.

  • Normlessness and Anomie:

    • Anomie: Defined as a state of normlessness, social instability, or the erosion of established social norms (spelled a n o m i e).

    • Pop Culture Metaphor: The character Norm (played by actor George Wendt, real name George Wayne) on the television series Cheers embodied social routines, famous for comedic lines such as "It's a dog eat dog world and I'm wearing a coat of underwear."

Legal Classifications: Mala In Se vs. Mala Prohibita

  • Standard Categorizations of Crime: Crimes are categorized legally into felonies vs. misdemeanors, property crimes vs. violent crimes, and victimless crimes.

  • Mala In Se:

    • Crimes that are inherently evil or wrong in and of themselves (mala = bad; in se = in and of itself).

    • Examples: Murder, grand theft, physical assault. Recognizing mala in se offenses relies on basic human intelligence and foundational social experience.

  • Mala Prohibita:

    • Offenses that are criminal solely because statutory authority prohibits them, not because the act is inherently immoral.

    • Examples: Speeding infractions, regulatory drug possession offenses.

  • Victimless Crimes and Drug Regulation Debates:

    • Certain substances, such as cannabis, possess demonstrated medical utility, whereas others (e.g., cocaine) present distinct medical and social risks.

    • Hypothetical private substance use (e.g., isolated recreational drug use following entertainment at a club like Cheerleaders) illustrates the theoretical construct of victimless crime, where no clear external victim incurs direct physical injury.

    • Over-Criminalization: Jurisdictions (e.g., Texas or Georgia) enforcing strict prohibition treat drug possession as severe moral offenses.

    • Under-Criminalization: States legalizing or decriminalizing possession reflect shifting standards on statutory harm.

Informal and Formal Social Control

  • Primary Deterrents to Criminal Behavior:

    • Peer pressure, social expectations, and fear of judgment from one's immediate social circle are the primary mechanisms stopping individuals from committing deviant or criminal acts.

    • Peer Interpersonal Dynamics: Social environments (e.g., local establishments like Union Hall, Brewers, Village Pub, Alicia's, The Whip—formerly Steater's, formerly Rats—Jay's, or The Jug) often encourage risky choices under the influence of alcohol, but common sense interventions by peers or staff act as primary informal controls.

  • Informal vs. Formal Social Control:

    • Informal Social Control: Relies on unwritten norms, customary expectations, and peer relationships without requiring codified statutory legal codes.

    • Formal Social Control: Operates through written statutes, official state institutions, legal mandates, and designated enforcement personnel.

  • Three Primary Sources of American Law:

    1. Constitutional Law: The foundational law of the nation; statutes passed by legislatures that violate constitutional protections are subject to judicial review and overturned by the Supreme Court.

    2. Case Law / Judicial Precedent: Legal principles established by appellate and Supreme Court rulings.

    3. Statutory Law: Legislative enactments passed by federal, state, or municipal legislative bodies.

  • Local Directives and Obsolete Concepts: Municipal ordinances govern ticketable infractions like jaywalking. Theoretical or obscure concepts include "mopare" (a mock legal term describing exposure to a visually impaired individual, such as Stevie Wonder).

  • Institutional Prerequisites for Crime: Organized crime requires political or law enforcement corruption to sustain operations.

Legal Structure, Felonies, Misdemeanors, and Elements of Crime

  • State Legal Structure (New Jersey Classification): The state of New Jersey does not formally utilize the traditional terms "felony" or "misdemeanor" in its criminal code; statutory offenses are classified strictly by degrees.

  • General Definitions:

    • Felony: A severe offense punishable by incarceration of 1 year1\,\text{year} or longer in a state prison facility.

    • Misdemeanor: A lesser offense punishable by a maximum incarceration period of 364 days364\,\text{days} in a county or local facility.

  • Essential Elements of Criminal Liability:

    • Actus Reus: The guilty, prohibited physical act or conduct.

    • Mens Rea: The guilty mind or criminal intent.

    • Legal Concurrence: A crime requires the explicit concurrence of actus reus and mens rea directly causing harm.

    • Motive: Motive is not a required legal element to secure a criminal conviction. Only a guilty mind and a guilty act are required.

    • Target of Harm: Property or state assets (e.g., cutting down protected timber or damaging public landmarks like the Washington Monument reflecting pool) satisfy the harm requirement without direct physical injury to a human victim.

Specific Intent and Criminological Distinctions

  • Specific Intent Requirement: Certain crimes require a specific, calculated state of mind where the actor intends the precise unlawful outcome.

  • Attempt: Criminal attempt is strictly a specific intent crime; an individual cannot "accidentally" attempt a crime.

  • Fraud: Defined legally as theft accomplished through intentional deception; fraud cannot be committed accidentally.

  • First-Degree Murder vs. Reckless Disregard:

    • First-degree murder requires explicit malice and specific intent, or actions demonstrating a reckless disregard for human life (e.g., discharging a firearm blindly inside an occupied building without target identification).

  • Absence of Mens Rea in Accidental Acts:

    • If a passenger on a sudden-stopping train or bus accidentally falls into an elderly individual ("Grandma Millie"), breaking her hip, no crime has occurred despite severe physical injury, because the act completely lacked mens rea (guilty mind).

Labeling Theory, Stigma, and System Re-entry Challenges

  • Contemporary Terminology Standards:

    • Preferred academic and legal terminology: "Currently incarcerated person" or "formerly / previously incarcerated person."

    • The term "ex-convict" is legally inaccurate; a formal conviction remains on record permanently unless expunged, making the individual legally convicted regardless of release status.

  • Structural Obstacles to Re-entry:

    • Employment and Housing Barriers: Formal labeling creates severe social stigma, preventing released individuals from securing stable employment or rental housing.

    • Credit Score Deficiency: Extended incarceration deprives individuals of the ability to build or maintain credit history.

    • Case Example (Anton Henshall): Incarcerated for 2727 years beginning at age 1919. Despite offering 8000 dollars8000\,\text{dollars} in liquid cash to pay a full year's rent up front, property managers routinely rejected his application due to a complete absence of credit history.

    • International Travel Case Study (2024):

    • Three formerly incarcerated individuals—Audrey Wilson (Penny Green Foundation tutoring director), James Clausle (former New Jersey death row inmate), and Anton Henshall—traveled across five nations (England, Wales, Northern Ireland, Ireland, and Scotland) without customs impedance.

    • Upon re-entering the United States at Philadelphia International Airport, federal customs agents detained and interrogated all three for several hours strictly due to background record flags.

    • Incarceration Subculture Analogy: During the trip in Edinburgh, Scotland, James Clausle received a haircut from a local barber who was a former prisoner and instantly recognized and executed a standard prison "fade" haircut.

  • Research on Criminal Justice Debt (Dr. Nathan Link):

    • Research conducted by Dr. Nathan Link (Rutgers Graduate Director, PhD from Temple University who received a unanimous standing ovation from his dissertation defense panel).

    • Documents how court fines, restitution fees, legal surcharges, and child support arrears accumulate prior to, during, and after imprisonment.

    • Unpayable financial obligations create a cascading "tumbleweed effect," generating severe psychological stress and driving high national recidivism rates.

Quantitative Data, Crime Trends, and Systemic Disparities

  • Demographic Disparities in Death Penalty Statistics:

    • African American males comprise approximately 6.8%6.8\% (or approx6%\\approx 6\%) of the overall United States population.

    • African American males represent approximately 41%41\% (fluctuating historically between 40.6%40.6\% and 42.4%42.4\%) of the death row population in the United States.

    • Disproportionate capital sentencing increases significantly in cases involving an African American male defendant and a white female victim.

  • Historical Crime vs. Incarceration Trends:

    • Crime Rates: Overall crime rates in the United States have consistently declined since the mid-to-late 1990s1990\text{s} (with localized shifts, such as COVID-19 pandemic spikes in domestic violence paired with simultaneous drops in burglaries).

    • Incarceration Rates: National incarceration rates expanded by approximately 450%450\% between the early 1700s1700\text{s} / 1970s1970\text{s} baseline and 20102010.

    • Primary Drivers: Mandatory minimum sentencing, extended prison terms, parole revocations without new criminal offenses, and the statutory War on Drugs.

  • Global Incarceration Share: The United States contains roughly 5%5\% of the global human population, yet incarcerates approximately 25%25\% of the total world prison population.

Research Methodology, Financial Costs, and Psychological Impacts

  • Standards of Scientific Validity:

    • Peer-Reviewed Literature: Represents the essential standard for empirical validity in criminological research; peer review subjects methodology and data to rigorous critical evaluation to identify analytical flaws.

    • Methodological Debates: Ethnographic studies, such as Alice Goffman's research in West Philadelphia, faced severe academic criticism from peers (e.g., Kurt Fowler) over data accuracy, field reporting integrity, and factual verification.

  • Financial Operating Costs of Criminal Justice:

    • Capital punishment procedures are drastically more expensive to administer than life imprisonment without parole—costing up to 11×11\times more in certain states due to extended constitutional appeals, specialized defense teams, and protracted trial phases.

  • Non-Quantifiable Psychological Costs:

    • Direct costs incurred by victims and society include irreplaceable personal items and emotional loss.

    • Personal items (e.g., a deceased parent's worn, dilapidated wallet or a grandmother's 1950s1950\text{s} nurse pulse stopwatch) possess infinite personal value that cannot be computed or compensated through financial metrics.

Questions & Discussion

  • Q: Should all illegal drugs be legalized across the board?

    • Response: Drug policy reform should distinguish between substance risk profiles. Blanket legalization of every drug is problematic, but legalizing non-dangerous or medically beneficial substances (such as cannabis under an age-restricted model like alcohol for individuals 2121 and older) is a rational policy direction.

  • Q: What single factor most effectively deters individuals in a room from committing a crime?

    • Response: Initial student suggestions included fear of getting caught or acquiring a permanent criminal record. However, the primary immediate deterrent against committing criminal or deviant acts is informal peer reaction, fear of social embarrassment, and social disapproval from peers.

  • Q: What are the three primary sources of law in the United States legal system?

    • Response: Student identified Constitutional Law, Case Law (Precedent established by judicial rulings), and Statutory Law passed by legislative bodies.