CMST 110 Libel Law Fall 23
Freedom of Speech: U.S. Libel Law
Overview
Course Code: CMST 110-07
Date: Thursday, November 15, 2023
The Twin Torts of Defamation
Defamation: Any spoken or published communication that damages someone's reputation.
Slander: Refers to spoken defamation.
Libel: Refers to published defamation.
Definition and Elements of Libel in the U.S.
Requirements to Prove Libel:
The content must be a statement of fact (not mere opinion).
The statement must be published (print or electronic).
It must be about the plaintiff.
The statement must be defamatory and hurt the plaintiff’s reputation.
It must be false; truth is a defense against libel.
There must be proof of damages or harm to the plaintiff.
The defendant must be at fault for the damage caused.
Legal Considerations
Legal Risks of Libel Cases
Libel cases in the U.S. can be exceptionally costly and may lead to unexpected embarrassing situations for all involved.
Winning a libel case may bring regret for the plaintiff due to the publicity and personal toll.
Case Study: Westmoreland v. CBS (1984)
Involved General William C. Westmoreland and CBS, which led to significant consequences:
CBS stated it did not intend to assert accusations against Westmoreland's patriotism.
General Westmoreland withdrew the case and receded from public engagement.
CBS suffered financial losses related to libel insurance.
Network TV reduced the production of investigative journalism and documentaries.
Content That Cannot Be Libelous
Categories of Protected Expression
Under U.S. law, the following types of published material are not considered libelous:
Critical reviews (books, films, restaurants).
Artistic expressions.
Editorial statements (opinion-based content).
Satire and parody.
Political cartoons.
Statements prefixed with “In my opinion…” are also protected.
Winning a Libel Case
Grounds for Winning
To have a chance of winning a libel case, a litigant must show:
Actual Malice: The reporter or media entity knew the information was false yet published it.
Reckless Disregard for the Truth: The journalist failed to follow established journalistic standards.
Categories of Litigants
Limited-Purpose Public Figures: Those who have voluntarily attained public status on a specific issue.
All-Purpose Public Figures: Well-known individuals like celebrities and politicians must prove actual malice in libel cases.
Implications for Journalists
Navigating Libel Risks
Journalists may face libel charges regardless of their intent. The guiding principle is to maintain high journalistic standards.
The best defense against libel charges is the truth; if a report is factual, it cannot constitute libel.
Settlements vs. Trials
Often, settlements are preferable to court trials to minimize public relation issues and expenses.
Perception of Journalists
Juries have a historical tendency to view reporters unfavorably in libel cases.
Recommendations for Reporters
Uphold journalistic standards rigorously.
Consider obtaining libel insurance.
Potential plaintiffs should evaluate their motives carefully before pursuing libel or slander charges.
Famous Libel Cases
Tom Cruise's Legal Actions
Overview of various lawsuits against publications related to Tom Cruise's reputation, resulting in settlements.
Parody and Public Figures
The case of Falwell v. Hustler Magazine (1988) highlights the limits of defamation laws, where parody protected under the First Amendment was upheld as non-defamatory.
Recent High-Profile Cases
Fox News and the 'Big Lie'
Revealed instances of actual malice where Fox News personnel reported false information knowingly, particularly regarding the 2020 election.
Fox settled for $787 million with Dominion over defamation claims.
Considerations on Libel Law
The Evolution of Libel Law
Libel law develops from decades of court cases and needs to be consistent with Supreme Court rulings, although state laws can vary.
Potential Changes
Justice Clarence Thomas has voiced interest in revisiting the landmark decision of New York Times v. Sullivan (1964).
Conclusion
Public figures must be prepared for scrutiny. If you hold a public position on controversial issues, you may face libel risks. Before pursuing libel, weigh the potential personal and professional costs.