CMST 110 Libel Law Fall 23

Freedom of Speech: U.S. Libel Law

Overview

  • Course Code: CMST 110-07

  • Date: Thursday, November 15, 2023

The Twin Torts of Defamation

  • Defamation: Any spoken or published communication that damages someone's reputation.

    • Slander: Refers to spoken defamation.

    • Libel: Refers to published defamation.

Definition and Elements of Libel in the U.S.

  • Requirements to Prove Libel:

    • The content must be a statement of fact (not mere opinion).

    • The statement must be published (print or electronic).

    • It must be about the plaintiff.

    • The statement must be defamatory and hurt the plaintiff’s reputation.

    • It must be false; truth is a defense against libel.

    • There must be proof of damages or harm to the plaintiff.

    • The defendant must be at fault for the damage caused.

Legal Considerations

Legal Risks of Libel Cases

  • Libel cases in the U.S. can be exceptionally costly and may lead to unexpected embarrassing situations for all involved.

  • Winning a libel case may bring regret for the plaintiff due to the publicity and personal toll.

Case Study: Westmoreland v. CBS (1984)

  • Involved General William C. Westmoreland and CBS, which led to significant consequences:

    • CBS stated it did not intend to assert accusations against Westmoreland's patriotism.

    • General Westmoreland withdrew the case and receded from public engagement.

    • CBS suffered financial losses related to libel insurance.

    • Network TV reduced the production of investigative journalism and documentaries.

Content That Cannot Be Libelous

Categories of Protected Expression

  • Under U.S. law, the following types of published material are not considered libelous:

    • Critical reviews (books, films, restaurants).

    • Artistic expressions.

    • Editorial statements (opinion-based content).

    • Satire and parody.

    • Political cartoons.

    • Statements prefixed with “In my opinion…” are also protected.

Winning a Libel Case

Grounds for Winning

  • To have a chance of winning a libel case, a litigant must show:

    • Actual Malice: The reporter or media entity knew the information was false yet published it.

    • Reckless Disregard for the Truth: The journalist failed to follow established journalistic standards.

Categories of Litigants

  • Limited-Purpose Public Figures: Those who have voluntarily attained public status on a specific issue.

  • All-Purpose Public Figures: Well-known individuals like celebrities and politicians must prove actual malice in libel cases.

Implications for Journalists

Navigating Libel Risks

  • Journalists may face libel charges regardless of their intent. The guiding principle is to maintain high journalistic standards.

  • The best defense against libel charges is the truth; if a report is factual, it cannot constitute libel.

Settlements vs. Trials

  • Often, settlements are preferable to court trials to minimize public relation issues and expenses.

Perception of Journalists

  • Juries have a historical tendency to view reporters unfavorably in libel cases.

Recommendations for Reporters

  • Uphold journalistic standards rigorously.

  • Consider obtaining libel insurance.

  • Potential plaintiffs should evaluate their motives carefully before pursuing libel or slander charges.

Famous Libel Cases

Tom Cruise's Legal Actions

  • Overview of various lawsuits against publications related to Tom Cruise's reputation, resulting in settlements.

Parody and Public Figures

  • The case of Falwell v. Hustler Magazine (1988) highlights the limits of defamation laws, where parody protected under the First Amendment was upheld as non-defamatory.

Recent High-Profile Cases

Fox News and the 'Big Lie'

  • Revealed instances of actual malice where Fox News personnel reported false information knowingly, particularly regarding the 2020 election.

  • Fox settled for $787 million with Dominion over defamation claims.

Considerations on Libel Law

The Evolution of Libel Law

  • Libel law develops from decades of court cases and needs to be consistent with Supreme Court rulings, although state laws can vary.

Potential Changes

  • Justice Clarence Thomas has voiced interest in revisiting the landmark decision of New York Times v. Sullivan (1964).

Conclusion

  • Public figures must be prepared for scrutiny. If you hold a public position on controversial issues, you may face libel risks. Before pursuing libel, weigh the potential personal and professional costs.