Notes on Critical Thinking & APA Essay Planning (5-paragraph structure, two quotes, two citations)
APA format essentials
Essay basics: title page, in-text citations, references page.
References page includes one article (the same article for everyone).
Length: full pages (not counting title page or references).
Spacing and format: double-spaced; no extra spaces; APA font and margins.
In-text citations and references: follow APA; two quotes total, two APA citations total.
Topic: 12 dispositions (critical thinking traits) discussed in the article.
Submission: Word or PDF; Turnitin enabled; originality required.
Essay structure and key layout
Overall form: five paragraphs total
Paragraph 1: Introduction
Paragraph 2: Body 1 – trait you already demonstrate
Paragraph 3: Body 2 – disposition you need to work on
Paragraph 4: Body 3 – plan to improve that disposition (no quotes)
Paragraph 5: Conclusion
Thesis: intro ends with a thesis that maps to body paragraphs (what you have, what you need to work on, and your plan).
Quotes: two quotes positioned in Body 1 and Body 2 with APA citations
Citations: in-text citations like ; reference page lists the article (e.g., Gwyer, 2019).
Correspondence: the article used for quotes is the same for all students.
Point of view and pronouns
Acceptable: first-person pronouns to describe your thinking (I, me, my, mine, we, our, us).
Not acceptable: second-person pronouns (you, your, yourself, you’ll). Do not address the reader directly in the essay.
Practical rule: write from a first-person perspective when discussing personal thinking; avoid addressing the reader directly.
Free writing and planning steps
Free writing steps (to generate ideas and reduce writer's block):
Step 1: Understand directions and read assignment details; if unclear, ask the instructor after class.
Step 2: Brainstorm and generate ideas via free writing, lists, web, or charts.
Step 3: Free write for five minutes on a chosen topic; don’t edit or worry about spelling/grammar.
Step 4: Organize the rough material into a skeleton outline (introduction, body sections, conclusion).
Step 5: Draft using the outline; keep writing until time runs out; fluency improves with practice.
Free writing aims: surface thoughts, increase writing fluency, and prepare material for a formal draft.
Planning and outline (skeleton)
Five-paragraph skeleton plan:
Intro: hook; define critical thinking; mention reading title, author, publication; state overall point; end with a thesis.
Body Paragraph 1: trait you already have; include a direct quote with APA citation; explain how you demonstrate it.
Body Paragraph 2: disposition you need to work on; include a direct quote with APA citation; explain your relation to the quote.
Body Paragraph 3: plan to improve that disposition; no quotes; list concrete steps (bullets are acceptable; keep concise).
Conclusion: rephrase thesis; summarize learning and future use; close with a sense of closure.
Thesis map: the introductory thesis should anticipate body Paragraphs 1–3 (what you have, what you need to work on, and your plan).
Direct quotes and APA citations in this essay
Use two quoted passages from the article with APA citations in-text, e.g.:
(Gwyer, 2019,
\text{para. } 2)
Each quote requires a corresponding APA in-text citation; place the citation after the quote.
The reference list (References page) will include the article details: author, year, title, source.
Example structure mapping (summary for quick recall)
Intro: hook + definition + article details + thesis mapping to body points.
Paragraph 2 (Body 1): one trait you already have; one direct quote + citation; connect to your behavior.
Paragraph 3 (Body 2): one disposition you need to work on; one direct quote + citation; connect to your behavior.
Paragraph 4 (Body 3): plan to improve; no quotes; bullets of steps.
Paragraph 5 (Conclusion): rephrase thesis; brief closing.
Practical steps to complete the assignment
Confirm you have an APA-style title page, in-text citations, and a References page.
Ensure the essay length is pages (excluding title/references); format with five paragraphs total.
Write in first person (I/we) and avoid second-person forms (you/your).
Include exactly two quotes with APA citations and two corresponding citations in-text.
Draft a brief thesis that outlines what you have, what you’ll work on, and your plan to improve.
Prepare the body paragraphs with concise bullet-style plans for the plan paragraph to simplify grading.
Save as Word or PDF and submit via Turnitin; ensure originality.
Key reminders for last-minute review
Read directions carefully; ask the instructor if anything is unclear.
Use brainstorming/free writing to generate material before outlining.
Keep paragraphs tight: one idea per paragraph; use quotes strategically in Body 1 and Body 2.
Use the five-paragraph structure; maintain the order: Intro, Trait you have, Disposition to improve, Improvement plan, Conclusion.
Maintain APA formatting across title page, in-text citations, and references page.