Aquinas Exam 2
Synderesis
Definition: Innate capacity to understand basic moral principles of natural law.
Function: Moral compass guiding individuals to pursue good and avoid evil.
Relation to Conscience: Holds moral truths; conscience applies them to specific situations.
Analogy: Like a pre-loaded hard drive of intuitive moral knowledge.
First Precept: "Good is to be done and pursued; evil is to be avoided."
Thomas Aquinas's Notion of Natural Law
Key Concepts
Natural Right: Following natural law is essential to being good.
Natural Law: Commands based on God's will aligning reason with divine law.
Intrinsic Morality: Good/bad is determined by nature, not just God's decree.
Types of Law
Eternal Law: Divine governance of the universe—all creation is subject to it.
Divine Law: Revealed law through scripture, including natural laws.
Natural Law: Moral truths discernible through human reason, existing in conscience.
Authority and Power
Obedience/Disobedience: Obligation to obey rulers unless they act against fundamental virtues.
Just War: War is permissible for just causes such as defense or peace.
Revolution
Minor vs. Excessive Tyranny: Minor tyranny may be tolerated, but excessive tyranny justifies rebellion.
Public Authority: Only public authority can rightfully remove a ruler, under God's influence.
Relationship Between Church and State
Higher End: Pursuit of eternal happiness, a relationship with God, is paramount.
Church's Role: Guides toward divine relationship; State enforces ecclesiastical laws.
Natural Law Principles
First Precept: Universal principle to do good and avoid evil.
Nature of regimes reflects the nature of mankind and its virtuousness; a city influences moral development.
Importance of the City
City: The only self-sufficient association influencing people's nature.
Hierarchy: City ➜ Family ➜ Individuals; the ultimate end for a city is complete human good.
Common Good
Definition: Proper care of citizens, prioritizing community over individual good.
Peace: Not merely absence of war, but harmonious relationships among citizens.
Regimes and Governance
Best Regime: Ideally a monarchy (kingship), practically a mixed regime (monarchy + aristocracy + polity).
Dangers of Regency: Monarchy can lead to tyranny without checks.
Practical Governance: A blend of effective elements from various regimes ensures stability and virtue.
Virtue and Natural Law
Four Cardinal Virtues: Prudence, Courage, Moderation, Justice.
Natural Law: General principles of conduct derived from nature, universally applicable; conscience embodies these principles.
Summary
Aquinas emphasizes that the best regime reflects God's kingdom, utilizing divine authority and grace; moral virtue and natural law are essential for guiding just governance and societal relationships.
Relationship Between Philosophy and Revealed Religion:
Philosophy and religion are complementary; both seek truth.
Philosophy can understand and explain aspects of natural law and morality that align with divine revelation.
Origin/Evolution of Civil Society According to Aquinas:
Civil society emerges from human nature and the need for communal living.
The development of civil society is based on natural law principles, facilitating cooperation and common good.
Nature of Political Regime:
Political regimes reflect the moral nature of humanity.
Regimes can either promote virtue or lead to moral corruption.
Relationship Between Private Good and Common Good:
The common good is paramount; private good should align with the common good.
Individuals pursue their own good while contributing to the society's overall virtue.
Types of Regimes:
Monarchy (best), Aristocracy, and Polity.
Degenerate forms: Tyranny (worst - from monarchy), Oligarchy (from aristocracy), and Democracy (from polity).
Significance of the Rule of Law:
Ensures that justice prevails; establishes order and stability within society.
Aims to curb arbitrary power, promoting
Authority and Power in Aquinas's Philosophy
Obedience/Disobedience: Individuals have an obligation to obey rulers unless those rulers act against fundamental virtues. This reflects Aquinas's belief in the moral framework governing civil authority.
Just War: War is deemed permissible only for just causes, such as defense or the pursuit of peace.
Dealing with Tyrants
Minor vs. Excessive Tyranny: Aquinas differentiates between minor tyranny, which may be tolerated, and excessive tyranny, which justifies rebellion.
Public Authority: Only public authority, under God's influence, has the right to remove a ruler who has become excessively tyrannical.
Moral Virtue and its Application
Virtue and Natural Law: Moral virtue is essential for guiding just governance and societal relationships. Aquinas emphasizes the role of the four cardinal virtues: Prudence, Courage, Moderation, and Justice.
Common Good: The pursuit of moral virtue aligns with promoting the common good, ensuring that private goods contribute to the overall virtue of society.
**
Aquinas' Concept of Natural Law
Definition: Natural law is a moral law discoverable through human reason, reflecting God's design for humanity.
Key Characteristics:
Rooted in human nature and guides individuals toward the good.
Universal and immutable; applies to all people in all times.
Distinctions Between Types of Law:
Natural Law:
Based on human nature and moral reasoning.
Serves as the foundation for true justice and moral conduct.
Example: The principle that "Good is to be done and pursued; evil is to be avoided".
Human Law:
Laws created by human beings to govern society.
Should align with natural law to be just; unjust laws are not true laws.
Example: Statutes that protect individual rights and promote social welfare.
Divine Law:
Law revealed through scripture, including the commandments and teachings of faith.
Complements natural law, provides guidance beyond human reason.
Example: The Ten Commandments.
Eternal Law:
Divine governance of the universe that God establishes.
All creation is subject to eternal law and reflects the divine mind.
Example: The laws of nature and moral truths inherent in creation.
Relationship Between Church and State:
Higher End: The primary purpose is the pursuit of eternal happiness and a relationship with God.
Church's Role: Guides individuals toward this divine relationship and moral teachings.
State's Role: Enforces laws that should reflect moral truths, creating a society conducive to virtue.
Cooperation: Both institutions should work together for the common good, where the Church provides moral guidance and the State ensures justice and order.
When to Obey
Aquinas believed that political authority is legitimate when it promotes the common good and aligns with natural law. Therefore, citizens should obey laws and authorities that are just and aimed at the well-being of society. Obedience is seen as a virtue when the laws are designed to maintain social order and justice.
When to Disobey
Aquinas argued that if a law is unjust or contrary to natural law, it loses its binding force. He stated that laws that conflict with natural law are more akin to acts of violence than legitimate laws. In such cases, citizens are not morally obligated to obey these laws. For example, a law that mandates actions that harm the common good or violate fundamental moral principles would not need to be obeyed.
When to Revolt
Revolution or rebellion against a government, according to Aquinas, can be justified under certain conditions. If a ruler becomes a tyrant and consistently acts against the common good, undermines justice, or oppresses the people, then it can be morally permissible to overthrow such a ruler. However, Aquinas cautioned that rebellion should not lead to greater harm than the tyranny itself. The goal of such a revolution should be to restore justice and the common good, not to create more chaos and suffering.
In summary, Aquinas's approach to governance emphasizes a balance between obedience to just laws, disobedience to unjust laws, and the cautious consideration of revolution when a ruler becomes tyrannical. His ultimate aim was always the promotion of the common good and adherence to natural law.