Comprehensive Guide to Change in Profit Sharing Ratio and Firm Reconstitution
Nature and Instances of Firm Reconstitution
Reconstitution of a firm refers to any change in the existing agreement of partnership. When this occurs, the existing agreement comes to an end, and a new agreement comes into existence. Crucially, while the agreement changes, the partnership firm continues to operate.
Reconstitution of a firm can take place under the following circumstances:
- Change in the profit-sharing ratio among existing partners.
- Admission of a new partner.
- Retirement of an existing partner.
- Death of a partner.
- Amalgamation of two partnership firms.
Understanding Change in Profit-Sharing Ratio (PSR)
A change in the profit-sharing ratio among existing partners is a form of reconstitution that occurs without the admission, retirement, or death of a partner. This change implies that one or more partners are purchasing a share of profits from another partner or partners.
Key Definitions
- Sacrificing Partners: These are the partners whose shares in the profit have decreased due to the change in the profit-sharing ratio.
- Gaining Partners: These are the partners whose shares in the profit have increased due to the change in the profit-sharing ratio.
- Sacrificing Ratio: The ratio in which partners surrender or sacrifice their share of profit in favor of another partner.
- Gaining Ratio: The ratio in which partners acquire or gain a share of profit from other partners.
Calculation of Share Changes
The formula to determine the gain or sacrifice for a partner is:
Illustrative Example of Ratio Change
Consider a firm where the partners' shares change as follows:
- **Old Profit Sharing Ratio =
- Partner A:
- Partner B:
- Partner C:
- **New Profit Sharing Ratio = (equivalent to to maintain a common denominator of 10 for comparison)
- Partner A:
- Partner B:
- Partner C:
In this scenario, Partner A's share decreases (sacrifice), Partner B's share increases (gain), and Partner C's share remains unchanged.
Comprehensive Adjustments for PSR Changes
When the profit-sharing ratio changes, specifically four types of adjustments are required:
- Determination of sacrificing and gaining ratios.
- Adjustment of Goodwill.
- Adjustment of Profits or Losses arising from the Revaluation of Assets and Reassessment of Liabilities.
- Adjustment of Reserves and Accumulated Profits or Losses.
Accounting Treatment of Goodwill
Determining the sacrificing and gaining ratios is essential because the gaining partner must compensate the sacrificing partner by paying a proportionate amount of goodwill.
Steps for Goodwill Adjustment
- Step 1: Value the goodwill according to specified methods (such as those discussed in standard valuation practices).
- Step 2: Execute accounting treatments based on whether goodwill is already in the books or being adjusted for the future.
Writing Off Existing Goodwill
If goodwill already appears in the Balance Sheet at the time of reconstitution, it must be written off among all partners in their old profit-sharing ratio:
- Journal Entry:
- [Amount: Existing book value of Goodwill; Ratio: Old PSR]
Adjustment of New Goodwill (Compensation)
The gaining partner's account is debited and the sacrificing partner's account is credited in the sacrificing ratio.
In Case of Fluctuating Capitals:
In Case of Fixed Capitals:
Revaluation of Assets and Reassessment of Liabilities
Assets and liabilities are revalued so that no partner benefits or suffers due to changes in their value that occurred prior to the date of the PSR change. There are two primary methods for handling this:
Method 1: Revised Values Recorded in Books
In this method, changes are passed through a Revaluation Account (a nominal account). The net gain or loss is transferred to the partners' Capital or Current accounts in their old profit-sharing ratio.
Journal Entries:
- Increase in Asset Value:
- Decrease in Asset Value:
- Increase in Liability:
- Decrease in Liability:
- Unrecorded Asset:
- Unrecorded Liability:
Transfer of Revaluation Balance:
- For Net Gain (Credit > Debit):
- [Individually in Old PSR]
- For Net Loss (Debit > Credit):
- [Individually in Old PSR]
Method 2: Revised Values Not Recorded in Books
If revised values are not to be shown in the balance sheet, there are two alternatives:
- Single Adjusting Entry: Adjust the net effect through Capital Accounts by debiting the Gaining partner and crediting the Sacrificing partner (for profits).
- Memorandum Revaluation Account:
- Step 1: Perform revaluation as in Method 1 and distribute gain/loss in the Old PSR.
- Step 2: Reverse the entries from Step 1 (gains become losses and vice versa) and distribute the result in the New PSR.
Adjustment of Reserves and Accumulated Profits/Losses
There are two approaches to adjusting reserves:
- Distribution: All reserves and accumulated profits/losses are distributed among partners in their Old PSR.
- Adjustment Entry: If reserves are to remain in the New Balance Sheet, the gaining partner compensates the sacrificing partner for their share of the reserves via a capital adjustment.
Specific Guidelines for Reserves and Liabilities
- General Rule: Unless specified otherwise, reserves and accumulated profits/losses should always be distributed.
- Workmen Compensation Reserve (WCR): Created to meet potential liabilities towards workmen. The treatment depends on the expected liability:
- No liability: Distribute the entire WCR to partners in the Old PSR.
- Liability = WCR: Transfer the entire amount to 'Provision for Workmen Compensation Claim Account'.
- Liability > WCR: Transfer the balance of WCR to 'Provision for Workmen Compensation Claim Account'. The shortage (excess liability) is debited to the Revaluation Account.
- Liability < WCR: Transfer the amount of the liability to 'Provision for Workmen Compensation Claim Account' and distribute the remaining balance to partners in their Old PSR.
- Investments Fluctuation Reserve (IFR): Created to cover potential drops in the market value of investments. If the market value is lower than the book value, the difference is adjusted against this reserve. Any excess IFR is credited to Partners' Capital accounts in the Old PSR.
- Employees Provident Fund (EPF) / Employees State Insurance Fund: These are actual liabilities of the firm. They belong to employees, not partners, and are never distributed among partners.